Skip to main content
Question

Issues with external music library running on Windows Server after S2 upgrade

  • October 23, 2024
  • 0 replies
  • 36 views

Hi

My SONOS setup is as follows;

1 * Play 1 (not hard wired)

1 * One SL (not hard wired)

1 * SONOS Boost (hardwired)

1 * TP Link router (no range extenders) - stable and excellent WIFI 

All running S2

SONOS app on IOS and Windows 10

1 * Music Library of "ripped" MP3 CDs residing on a windows share of a Windows Server 2012 box (using SMB2 - SMB1 not enabled). Share / NTFS permissions on Windows have been checked and are correct. Windows 2012 firewall rules conform to the SONOS documentation.

I purchased my SONOS speakers so that I could play music from my "relatively small" (approx. 6000 tracks), music library. I don't use subscription music services. My SONOS content servers comprise various radio stations and BBC Sounds.

All worked well until the S2 upgrade. Now I can access my music library from the SONOS IOS app but get inconsistent results when trying to play tracks. Sometimes a selected track will play fine - sometimes from IOS I get a "content unavailable" error or from Windows get an "access denied" type error. If I try later, tracks that didn't play before will play ok. No pattern or consistency to any of it.

After spending 45 minutes on a call with SONOS support, they have told me that my configuration is not supported with S2. My Windows 2012 Music Library is classed by them as a "media server" which is not supported apparently. They say that only "dedicated" NAS servers are supported as external music libraries. The support guy was getting this information from "internal" documents - has anyone seen anything in the public domain that states this is not a supported configuration? - I cannot find anything.

I have asked SONOS for a list of "supported" NAS servers that they have tested and certified with S2 - surely this must exist? They have told me there isn't one - does anyone in the community know? Their response was "as long as the NAS supports SMB2 then it should be ok!" - seems a bit of a "vague" response!

Obviously before I splash the cash and purchase a dedicated NAS, I want some confidence that it will work and satisfy my use case. If SONOS cannot supply this what are other people using that works with S2? Advice / experience / recommendations please?

I don't really want to go down the PLEX route - seems overkill for what I need. I just want a simple external audio library.

As a workaround I have downloaded and installed SonoPhone. First impressions of this are excellent - it seems to just work - maybe I will stick with this and not use the "official" SONOS app.

SONOS support suggested I could "downgrade" to S1 - seems like a backward step which I would prefer not to do.

Does anyone know if the issue with compilation albums in the Music Library are on a SONOS development backlog? At the moment "Music Library - Albums" displays one album per individual artist on the compilation. Other posts have suggested "tinkering" with the tagging - not sure I want to do this. Also not seeing album / track artwork

FYI - this is the second time I have posted this - the first attempt didn't seem to get past the moderators for some reason.

Did you find what you were looking for?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

Cookie policy

We use cookies to enhance and personalize your experience. If you accept you agree to our full cookie policy. Learn more about our cookies.

 
Cookie settings