Skip to main content
revdv
Trending Lyricist I
March 31, 2019

What to replace Sonos with

I want to replace my Sonos system
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    39 replies

    ratty
    April 1, 2019
    1/ Remove the Bridge unless/until you can test its wall-wart power supply. Substitute another Sonos device for now. The PSU has a risk of failing with age. The voltage drops, and the Bridge's connectivity becomes intermittent. A healthy PSU puts out a steady 5.1V.

    2/ Remove Sonos' dependency on the EoP (Ethernet over Powerline), even for the controllers. It's very variable, and any attempt to use it across the two consumer units is really asking for trouble.

    I am not connected to SonosNet
    That's inconsistent with the fact that a Bridge is deployed. If you've ever been persuaded to configure WiFi details into the system then:

    3/ Remove the WiFi credentials via the 'reset' button at Advanced Settings/Wireless Setup.
    revdv
    revdvAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    April 1, 2019
    Just read - Android. Have you tried connecting them to SonosNet rather than WiFi?

    Thanks for helpful input, John. Support suggested I didn't do that, but have just done so, Will report Back. Reading their info suggests that I should tell my phone to forget the router's wifi. Is that best? I don't use the phone for streaming - just whatsapp, email, news, casual searching.
    thanks
    Sonos Roam SL, Play:1s, Play:5, Connect, Connect Amps, Boost. Arcam AVR5. Synology Diskstation. Harmony Ultimate "one remote to rule them all"
    April 1, 2019
    At least for the purposes of experiment, and given your use of phone, I'd suggest forgetting the home wifi to ensure phone sticks to SonosNet.

    I was going to suggest the same as @ratty and propose you get the Play:1 from top floor and wire it in place of the Bridge. Longer term a Boost might be worth it. Locate the P:1 at least a metre from router if possible.

    Do you know which channel your router is using? There are plenty of free wifi scanner apps in the Google Play Store and they can provide useful, though not comprehensive, information.
    April 1, 2019
    Note: after replacing Bridge as wired device, give things a couple of minutes to reconfigure before you think your system has disappeared!
    ratty
    April 1, 2019
    After all the above, go to http://IP_address_of_Play1:1400/support/review (get the IP from About My Sonos System). Open Network Matrix and post a screenshot.

    I'd also like to see confirmation of what the EoP is being used for. It can be a silver bullet, but at other times it can be hugely frustrating. Basically if one doesn't have a management app/console that reveals the state of the EoP connections one has only a rough idea about what it's doing.
    revdv
    revdvAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    April 1, 2019
    1/ Remove the Bridge unless/until you can test its wall-wart power supply. Substitute another Sonos device for now. The PSU has a risk of failing with age. The voltage drops, and the Bridge's connectivity becomes intermittent. A healthy PSU puts out a steady 5.1V.

    My bridge power supply is showing 6.7V.

    2/ Remove Sonos' dependency on the EoP (Ethernet over Powerline), even for the controllers. It's very variable, and any attempt to use it across the two consumer units is really asking for trouble.


    The powerlines are separated because of the problems of two consumer units. Different hard-wires from router to different powerlines, with separate pairing to keep them apart. The Diskstation is hard-wired (via a switch) to the router. So I don't think I'm depending on powerline except to get catchup TV to the Humax (which mostly works flawlessy). Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think the Sonos is at all dependent on the powerlines.[/quote]


    I am not connected to SonosNet
    That's inconsistent with the fact that a Bridge is deployed. If you've ever been persuaded to configure WiFi details into the system then:

    3/ Remove the WiFi credentials via the 'reset' button at Advanced Settings/Wireless Setup.[/quote]

    No credentials there - I took that out previously at Support's suggestion. I get the "Set up Sonos on your Wi-Fi" screen, "Let's get Sonos running on your wireless network"

    thanks all
    Sonos Roam SL, Play:1s, Play:5, Connect, Connect Amps, Boost. Arcam AVR5. Synology Diskstation. Harmony Ultimate "one remote to rule them all"
    April 1, 2019
    I would still swap out the Bridge as it uses SonosNet 1.0 not 2.0. Give the SonosNet phone connection a try. A screenshot of matrix, as suggested by @ratty, would definitely be worth it.
    ratty
    April 1, 2019
    My bridge power supply is showing 6.7V. Either it or your meter is faulty.

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think the Sonos is at all dependent on the powerlines.
    If the Bridge is/was the sole wired device then the Sonos units won't depend on EoP to interconnect. However a controller in a device using an EoP-based WiFi could encounter problems.
    revdv
    revdvAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    April 1, 2019
    I would still swap out the Bridge as it uses SonosNet 1.0 not 2.0. Give the SonosNet phone connection a try. A screenshot of matrix, as suggested by @ratty, would definitely be worth it.

    Router is using channel 6
    As is pretty much everything else - including what I assume to be the SonosNet, (HHID-55xf......etc)

    Portable (RINCON_7828CA27FEB601400)
    Kitchen (RINCON_B8E9378288AC01400)
    Dining Room (RINCON_000E58DE629801400)
    Bedroom (RINCON_000E583806A401400)
    Living Room (RINCON_000E5826CEE801400)
    Attic (RINCON_000E5880323201400)
    Network Matrix



    I've put the Attic Play:5 gen 1 in the place of the bridge (not the P:1) for domestic reasons.

    thanks.
    Gonna have to go off-line shortly.
    Sonos Roam SL, Play:1s, Play:5, Connect, Connect Amps, Boost. Arcam AVR5. Synology Diskstation. Harmony Ultimate "one remote to rule them all"
    revdv
    revdvAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    April 1, 2019
    Initial results seem to be positive. Just tried grouping - no problem.
    Just tried playing from diskstation - no problem

    thanks all, let you know tomorrow when I'm back online. Out now till 10pm.
    Sonos Roam SL, Play:1s, Play:5, Connect, Connect Amps, Boost. Arcam AVR5. Synology Diskstation. Harmony Ultimate "one remote to rule them all"