Skip to main content
Contributor I
Oct 7, 2017 10:53 AM UTC

Why the concept behind Sonos is basically flawed

I thought I would like to share my thoughts on why I would never recommend
Sonos to my friends. After having given it some thought, in my opinion, the whole
concept behind Sonos is basically flawed.

First off, a little about my current Sonos situation. Today I have, and enjoy, a
fully working Sonos system with multiple devices spread across several rooms.
The system is stable, because at some point I decided to cable everything.
The majority of my past Sonos problems could all be related to wireless instability.

Here is why the concept behind Sonos, in my opinion, is basically flawed.

Sonos is sold as a speaker system with flexibility and ease of use as part of its core values.
The idea is simple. The speakers look good, and can easily be moved around
your home in various wireless configurations. I dont doubt that for many users,
this is in fact reality (eventhough the speakers are probably rarely moved around).
However, if you inspect the troubleshooting section of the community, you will see that
many Sonos users are having trouble with the wireless stability of their systems.

The answer from Sonos support is almost always the same - "Your wireless network
is not good enough.. you need to improve or otherwise change it". The user is left
confused, because most often the wireless network is performing sufficiently in all other respects.
Somehow the Sonos system is introduced as the weakest link on your wireless network.
There may be plausible technical reasons for this, but how was the user supposed to know?
And worse: The user has no way of knowing upfront, if this will be an issue on your network.
You may end up lucky, or not, it is a flip of the coin.

The weaksest link in your upcoming Sonos environment, will be the one factor
for which Sonos cant take responsibility - and for which you can never be sure to
fullfill the requirements.

To me this proofs that the whole concept behind Sonos is flawed.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    46 replies

    Paulw123
    Virtuoso
    Oct 7, 2017 11:24 AM UTC
    This is not a sonos problem, but a household wifi problem that becomes apparent with wifi hungry kit. This has not and will not flawed sonos in 12yrs.
    Exactly the same problems crop up on the SkyQ forum, where sky has to push video around wireless mesh as well as audio.
    Do you think SkyQ is therefore flawed as well?
    Translate
    Oct 7, 2017 12:15 PM UTC
    This is not a sonos problem, but a household wifi problem that becomes apparent with wifi hungry kit

    I think that it's sometimes difficult for people to believe this, when every other system on the network works perfectly. I have had huge file transfers traverse the network without problems, yet Sonos (which has much, much lower data requirement) was never reliable on my wireless network/Sonos Mesh - despite changing every piece of network kit, every cable, buying a Bridge and using the different wireless connection methods. In the end, we moved house - and still had problems, unfortunately too intermittent to easily track down. In the end, I went wired - even though this meant using EoP adaptors, and now have a fairly reliable system. No-one else I know would have persevered with it.

    So no, I wouldn't recommend Sonos to a friend. Knowing (and hearing) a number of the problems that I've had over the past six years has put most of our friends off of getting Sonos anyway, as I'm usually (in my circle) one of the more technically capable people - and they reckon that if I can't get it to work properly, then they certainly won't.

    I bought the system as a simple interface to my music stored on a NAS (as I'm not particularly interested in streaming services) so also find that the quality of the UI has actually deteriorated (IMHO, of course) since I bought in to the system. Plus, at the time that I bought it the 65k limit wasn't that obvious. Successive iterations of the controller software have slowly distanced themselves from my preferred usage, so I've dreaded every upgrade since 4.x Even though I've locked the system off as much as I can, sooner or later someone is going to press a button on one of the lesser used devices and the whole thing will kick off again.

    I'm still using Sonos - I'll continue to use it until something better comes along. I fully understand, of course, that other people may have very different experiences - I'm very happy for them 😃
    Translate
    Paulw123
    Virtuoso
    Oct 7, 2017 12:33 PM UTC
    I understand a lot of people have problems in their houses.
    Iam glad to say sonos is rock solid, as is SkyQ, sometimes used at same time, with fibre broadband, but then it is a 1999 house with paper thin walls 😉
    Translate
    jgatie
    Oct 7, 2017 2:43 PM UTC
    Sonos is basically flawed . . .

    . . . proof the whole concept is flawed . . .

    And yet "other people" (actually it is an extremely vast majority of Sonos users) have very different experiences? That's a pretty overarching critique to arrive at from analysis of a single installation. And I would tell you things about file transfers lacking the real-time constraints that streaming has, so naturally they are successful regardless of the bandwidth available, but why bother?
    Translate
    tprehnAuthor
    Contributor I
    Oct 7, 2017 3:26 PM UTC
    ...That's a pretty overarching critique to arrive at...

    It was meant to be an overarching critique. Sonos is selling you rather expensive products that might not be working (or at least could cause you a lot of headache) from day one. However, the products are marketed on the exact opposite and (for some) false conditions.. ease of setup, no need for technical knowledge, flexible positioning etc..

    I hope you are right, that the vast majority of Sonos systems are playing without problems..
    Translate
    passopp
    Oct 7, 2017 3:50 PM UTC


    I hope you are right, that the vast majority of Sonos systems are playing without problems..


    That could easily be answered by looking into the average number of daily customer support requests related to network-related playback issues.
    As these figures are not publicly shared, we will never know though.
    Translate
    jgatie
    Oct 7, 2017 4:02 PM UTC
    ...That's a pretty overarching critique to arrive at...

    It was meant to be an overarching critique. Sonos is selling you rather expensive products that might not be working (or at least could cause you a lot of headache) from day one. However, the products are marketed on the exact opposite and (for some) false conditions.. ease of setup, no need for technical knowledge, flexible positioning etc..

    I hope you are right, that the vast majority of Sonos systems are playing without problems..


    Your critique is the thing which is flawed. To give an overarching critique of Sonos performance, you must be in possession of overarching performance data, of which you have nothing but a single personal anecdote. Which means either you don't understand the term "overarching", or your post was mere melodramatic nonsense based on your anger over your particularly flawed network.

    I know which one I'm going with.
    Translate
    chicks
    Oct 7, 2017 4:08 PM UTC


    I hope you are right, that the vast majority of Sonos systems are playing without problems..


    That could easily be answered by looking into the average number of daily customer support requests related to network-related playback issues.
    As these figures are not publicly shared, we will never know though.


    Or, one could simply look at the dozens of professional reviews, which are overwhelmingly positive. Or the customer reviews at Amazon, Play Store, Best Buy, etc, which are also overwhelmingly positive. Most people love their Sonos, and have very few, if any, issues. Most issues can be traced to the home wifi network, which can easily be avoided by using a Boost.
    Translate
    Virtuoso
    Oct 7, 2017 4:42 PM UTC
    My Sonos works flawlessly with Virgin Media Super Hub 2 and would recommend it without hesitation.

    If you think about all the systems out there, and the small number of fault reports on here it paints a pretty good picture for Sonos.
    Translate
    Lyricist II
    Dec 19, 2017 6:16 PM UTC
    I'm with you mate. The system is crap. It doesn't make any difference whether I'm using it wirelessly or hard-wired in. It's working one minute and defunct the next usually with a message saying that my music file can't be found. It worked ok for a while and then suddenly seemed to develop problems. Sonos support couldn't help. They even took over my pc and couldn't sort it. I only use it now to play Spotify and I'm thinking about just getting a decent bluetooth speaker and selling the lot.
    Translate