Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jul 27, 2024 11:18 AM UTC
Answered

Hi-Res audio with wired input on Sonos Ace

Trying to understand if it’s possible to play hi-res audio on Sonos Ace. Seems like bluetooth is a no-go, but I was hoping that the USB-C to USB-C connectivity would support it. However when I connect them to my Mac and open Audio Midi Setup, the Sonos Ace audio device only reports 16bit and 48kHz, and I can’t select any other option. Not sure if there is any limitation on MacOS here, and if it’s possible to use higher sampling or depth on other devices. Anyone had any success with this?

The 3,5mm to USB-C adapter it’s a different mystery. From what I can understand this is a ADC adapter, and not an analoge passthrough cable using USB-C’s Audio Accessory Mode. So even if I use a DAC from the computer that supports hi-res, the signal is anyway converted back to digital using the adapter cable, and then probably ending up using the same DAC that is used for USB-C to USB-C. There is so many conversions going on in this signal path it feels like a bit of a stretch to even call it lossless (as Sonos is stating). 

Am I getting this all wrong?

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
HiFi Oasis
Lyricist III
Jul 31, 2024 3:57 PM UTC

I was curious about this during my review of the Ace, so I reached out to my contact and they confirmed that the 16-bit/48kHz limitation is also applied to the 3.5mm connection. This would make sense since the connection needs to go through the onboard DAC of the Ace regardless of the cable used.

58 replies

Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 1:23 PM UTC

Hi

from mi MacBook Air M1 ace with USB C in midi Options I see 24 bit 48hz only one option.

Andrea.

 

Is this for Input or for Output in the MIDI Options? On input (mic) I also see 1ch 24bit, but for output I only get 2ch 16bit

24 bit 48hz in the first voice Input…

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 1:25 PM UTC

But then the Sonos Ace connected via USB to the Mac book don't convey lossless audio?

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 1:38 PM UTC

With my EarPods usb c with my MacBook Air in midi output I see 2 ch 24 bit 48 Khz. instead Sonos Ace 16 bit 2 ch.

Not lossless?  A Mistake…

Translate
sigh
Prodigy II
Aug 13, 2024 1:39 PM UTC

But then the Sonos Ace connected via USB to the Mac book don't convey lossless audio?

Define lossless audio.

According to Apple

https://support.apple.com/en-gb/118295

Apple Lossless is upto 24/48

Apple Hires Lossless is upto 24/192

 

Translate
jgatie
Aug 13, 2024 1:47 PM UTC

With my EarPods usb c with my MacBook Air in midi output I see 2 ch 24 bit 48 Khz. instead Sonos Ace 16 bit 2 ch.

Not lossless?  A Mistake…

 

“Lossless” has to do with the type of codec used to encode the audio, not the bit-depth or sample rate.  You can have lossless 16-bit 44.1 kHz, it doesn’t need to be 24-bit.  In fact, if you know about sampling (and this guy does: 24/192 Music Downloads), anything over 16-bit 44.1 kHz makes no sense because you are wasting bandwidth on dynamic range that, if used, could render you deaf, and a frequency range that no human can hear. 

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Aug 13, 2024 1:50 PM UTC

If it helps clear the mist, The above isn’t showing anything about the adc rates after the analogue cable, you are seeing the ugreen adapter input value. The ugreen adapter has no way to display what is happening inside the Ace or the ace 3.5mm to usb cable over the analogue connection.

If you have a 32bit/384Khz source going into the ugreen that output would list 32 bit/384 kHz.

What it is showing isn’t the full signal path which is

Source 24/192 — digital — iPad Pro 24/192 — digital — ugreen input 24/192 — ugreen DAC output (analogue) — 3.5mm analogue — ace cable ADC — ace 

What it does show is nothing has changed the bit size and sample rate (24/192) from the source to the ugreen adapter input. It isn’t showing you what happens after the ugreen converts it to analogue. So what the adc in the cable or the ace internal values are.

Yes I’ve had this discussion with other friends and that’s why I mentioned the 24/48 audio quality. I did go onto use a USB-C to USB-C cable only from an iPad Pro to the Ace and no external DAC and that showed up-to 24/48 audio - so my thoughts are that’s perhaps what the Ace internal DAC supports - other friends have reported seeing 24/48 too.

It would be nice though to see it confirmed, although anything over 16/44 is not likely going to make a difference to what I seem to be able to hear.

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 1:52 PM UTC

Ok thanks.

Andrea. 
 

Translate
Local Superstar
Aug 13, 2024 2:10 PM UTC

I have found these lossless ‘placebo’ logos quite misleading, I don’t trust them.

eg Apple Music will display a lossless logo, clicking shows 24/48 when I Airplay to Sonos, but checking bandwidth from AP to Sonos speaker its around 1Mbs, 24/48 would be around 2.5-3Mbs.

Playing same track via Apple Music service in Sonos App will consume 3-4Mbs, but without 24/48 logo.

But of course it must sound better with the logo? 

 

 

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Aug 13, 2024 2:53 PM UTC

I have found these lossless ‘placebo’ logos quite misleading, I don’t trust them.

eg Apple Music will display a lossless logo, clicking shows 24/48 when I Airplay to Sonos, but checking bandwidth from AP to Sonos speaker its around 1Mbs, 24/48 would be around 2.5-3Mbs.

Playing same track via Apple Music service in Sonos App will consume 3-4Mbs, but without 24/48 logo.

But of course it must sound better with the logo? 

Whenever I do see these type of threads, either in this community, or elsewhere online, I always think that it infers that people can’t often tell the difference (myself included) between 16/44 and higher bit/sample rates, simply by listening to the audio itself and that the majority rely on seeing a visual representation (label/display/badge etc.). I personally believe though CD quality lossless audio 16/44 is usually as good as it gets for my own hearing. Anything over that, I doubt I would be able to identify in any A/B test - I would (hand on heart) just be guessing. 

Translate
skullc
Prodigy III
Aug 13, 2024 3:03 PM UTC

The thing with hires music is more about the mastering than the bitrate, a well mastered 16/44 track will probably sound better than a 24/192 average file but the reverse is also true a well mastered 24/192 will blow you away with the detail and quality of the sound.

I  am lucky enough to be able to hear differences in low quality sound from poor to well mastered tracks but in my experience there’s way more well mastered 16/44 tracks than higher resolution ones 

In closing if it sounds good to you then it’s good enough for you 😊

Translate
Network= livewire cpe pro 3 +eero 6 pro wireless