Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jul 27, 2024 11:18 AM UTC
Answered

Hi-Res audio with wired input on Sonos Ace

Trying to understand if it’s possible to play hi-res audio on Sonos Ace. Seems like bluetooth is a no-go, but I was hoping that the USB-C to USB-C connectivity would support it. However when I connect them to my Mac and open Audio Midi Setup, the Sonos Ace audio device only reports 16bit and 48kHz, and I can’t select any other option. Not sure if there is any limitation on MacOS here, and if it’s possible to use higher sampling or depth on other devices. Anyone had any success with this?

The 3,5mm to USB-C adapter it’s a different mystery. From what I can understand this is a ADC adapter, and not an analoge passthrough cable using USB-C’s Audio Accessory Mode. So even if I use a DAC from the computer that supports hi-res, the signal is anyway converted back to digital using the adapter cable, and then probably ending up using the same DAC that is used for USB-C to USB-C. There is so many conversions going on in this signal path it feels like a bit of a stretch to even call it lossless (as Sonos is stating). 

Am I getting this all wrong?

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
HiFi Oasis
Lyricist III
Jul 31, 2024 3:57 PM UTC

I was curious about this during my review of the Ace, so I reached out to my contact and they confirmed that the 16-bit/48kHz limitation is also applied to the 3.5mm connection. This would make sense since the connection needs to go through the onboard DAC of the Ace regardless of the cable used.

58 replies

sigh
Prodigy II
Aug 13, 2024 3:16 PM UTC

@Ken_Griffiths

If the different versions come from the same source mix then most likely, especially with a Sonos speaker.

Where it can sound obviously different is that Studios already had Cd quality 16/44.1 on the streaming service, for years but no 24 bit/hires version. The hires versions they then upload are a new remaster, often with a different sound engineer so end up a differently mixed release and don’t replace the existing 16/44.1 with the new mix.

Some owners will remaster all versions and create a new release, because people seem to love rebuying the same music over and over again. Yes, I’m being slightly cynical, some albums do benefit if the original release was an awful mix. At this point all versions are back to being the same mix again.

 

@craigski

lossless, hires is a marketing departments dream. And like the mobile phone pixel count arms race, marketing love people chasing higher numbers.

All of my Qobuz digital purchases happen to be hires lossless because it is the cheapest version with my subscription discount. It’s also often the cheapest way to buy the music I want.

If Qobuz only have the CD version, then it’s usually cheaper just to buy the CD.

In my car, while I can play upto 24/48 it’s pointless. The sound system in my previous car was ridiculously good, but anything more than a decent quality mp3 is pointless with the roof down 😂

Translate
Local Superstar
Aug 13, 2024 3:27 PM UTC

but anything more than a decent quality mp3 is pointless with the roof down 😂

We are back on topic, Sonos Ace could help with that specific use case? 😀

 

Translate
skullc
Prodigy III
Aug 13, 2024 3:31 PM UTC

but anything more than a decent quality mp3 is pointless with the roof down 😂

We are back on topic, Sonos Ace could help with that specific use case? 😀

 

Don’t know which country he is in but in the UK he would probably get pulled over by the police 😜

Translate
Network= livewire cpe pro 3 +eero 6 pro wireless
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 3:40 PM UTC

therefore listening to a lossless audio file from MacBook via Bluetooth or USB cable does not change anything since the output value is 16 bit 48 Khz...so where are they lossless?

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Aug 13, 2024 3:40 PM UTC

but anything more than a decent quality mp3 is pointless with the roof down 😂

We are back on topic, Sonos Ace could help with that specific use case? 😀

 

Don’t know which country he is in but in the UK he would probably get pulled over by the police 😜

I’d have to ask the Wife to drive.😀 I have to say the Ace ‘noise cancelling’ is really very good - not that we have a ’convertible’ to go out and test these things, but ANC, in general, works well for me.

Translate
jgatie
Aug 13, 2024 3:57 PM UTC

therefore listening to a lossless audio file from MacBook via Bluetooth or USB cable does not change anything since the output value is 16 bit 48 Khz...so where are they lossless?

 

Once again, you are confusing a codec, which encodes the sound and compresses it into a file, with bit-depth/sample rate, which just determines how much of a dynamic range (quietest to loudest range) and frequencies sampled (0 Hz up to ½ of the sample frequency).  A lossless codec means whatever goes in, comes out exactly the same.  A lossy codec means some data is removed in order to compress the file more, and the decoder estimates what the removed data is in order to get back as much of the original as possible. 

By the way, all Bluetooth is lossy.  Some Bluetooth codecs are better than others, but all are lossy. 

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 4:01 PM UTC

therefore listening to a lossless audio file from MacBook via Bluetooth or USB cable does not change anything since the output value is 16 bit 48 Khz...so where are they lossless?

 

Once again, you are confusing a codec, which encodes the sound and compresses it into a file, with bit-depth/sample rate, which just determines how much of a dynamic range (quietest to loudest range) and frequencies sampled (0 Hz up to ½ of the sample frequency).  A lossless codec means whatever goes in, comes out exactly the same.  A lossy codec means some data is removed in order to compress the file more, and the decoder estimates what the removed data is in order to get back as much of the original as possible. 

By the way, all Bluetooth is lossy.  Some Bluetooth codecs are better than others, but all are lossy. 


ok so what the Mac detects is correct then?
Andrea.

 

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 4:14 PM UTC

But I don't understand why other headphones like the Beats Studio pro with USB C cable can choose 24 bit 192 khz. Ah the Ace connected with its 32 bit 192 khz 3.5 jack cable but the audio is heard at a much lower level than the USB connection... Another mystery...

Translate
sigh
Prodigy II
Aug 13, 2024 5:48 PM UTC

But I don't understand why other headphones like the Beats Studio pro with USB C cable can choose 24 bit 192 khz. Ah the Ace connected with its 32 bit 192 khz 3.5 jack cable but the audio is heard at a much lower level than the USB connection... Another mystery...

Mostly because that is what the digital audio processor inside the headphones, USB dac to 3.5mm cable, device at each end of a usb-usb cable supports. Very few companies design their own processing chips and buy components from other companies. A single processing chip often targets multiple market sectors. Which chip a device manufacturer chooses is down to what fits their requirements and costs.

Marketing may then decide to use it as a feature because they know their target market responds to the “bigger/higher number is better“ marketing.

 

In general when talking about digital music, 16 bit Linear PCM sampled at 44.1Khz is the baseline minimum for what is classed as lossless audio as a source. Anything above that is also considered lossless.

It could be an audio cd, it could be a saved in a Wav, flac, alac, whatever format, as long as when decoded back to it’s original digital it is exactly the same as the digital source it was created from.

Studios when working with digital audio, usually record and manipulate the audio at a higher bitrate and sample rate. There are benefits for a studio to work in 24 bit, or higher, because the dynamic range means they don’t need to really worry about the input levels on mics and instruments, boosts or cuts when digital effects and processing are applied. That can all be levelled after recording. Engineers get on and do their thing, and somewhere a decision is made for the bit size and sample rate for the final product.

As consumer device targeted chips became cheaper supporting higher bit sizes and sample rates, an area of the audio listening market decided they were being short changed by the music industry and they must have the hires digital the studios used. Labels, rights holders, device manufacturers and marketing realised there was money to be made so here we are with terms like “full lossless”, “HD”, “Ultra HD”, “Hires” and devices advertising increasingly higher bit size and sample rates.

There are benefits to consumer devices being able to process digital audio in 24 bit, especially as room correction and other digital processing is becoming increasingly common in stereo playback.

Translate
Avid Contributor I
Aug 13, 2024 6:35 PM UTC

Thanks. 
however with the 3.5 jack the Sonos Ace have a much lower volume than the USB C counterpart. So from Mac the audio quality is considered to be the bare minimum…

Translate