Update on S2 fixes

I didn’t realise the Sonos download site linked back to a users local App Store - I assumed it just gave access to the latest Sonos App, so sorry if I have that incorrect. I was only trying to assist.

I have always had (and recommend) that the firmware updates are enabled in the Sonos App, as things don’t always work correctly for my own Home setup, if the App and device-firmware are allowed to fall out of sync with each other. I guess If you’re not updating the firmware, I would personally not install a different version of the App, or vice versa.. however I guess that’s a matter for yourselves.

The Sonos App here is working fine and I was just trying to show I have not seen any issues either adding new products, or grouping Sonos rooms. In fact both ‘individual’ and ‘grouped’ room volume-control has greatly improved (for the system here) and become much more responsive, compared to when the App was initially rolled out last May. I can’t say I have ever personally encountered any issues grouping my Sonos devices via the new App.

Oh ok I thought you were maybe having issues since there’s been issues since May 7 here. 

Ken I appreciate your willingness to help and optimism here.  And I’m very happy your system is working well enough that you’re happy with it.  However, that doesn’t invalidate my experience or the hordes and hordes of people posting here, and facebook, and Reddit, etc. etc. with the same issues.  I posted here because I know actual Sonos employees are very active here and I just had a small sliver of hope that my post would get an official and meaningful response.  One half-way apologetic acknowledgement from the CEO plus months of vague “bug fixes” release notes with no tangible or noticeable impact on the performance of our systems is not acceptable.  Unfortunately they’re not doing nearly enough to make me confident that these issues ARE going to be fixed, and more importantly, that they won’t happen again.  The S2 app is such a catastrophic failure that I can’t help but question the leadership, operations, and vision of the company currently.  I could deal with much of the issues except, as I mentioned, they’ve designed the speakers in such a way that they’re utterly useless if not part of a “system”.  So when they drop from the “system” like flies, I lose patience.  I realize I probably won’t get a response, but my post was out of desperation because I’ve been a huge fan for years and I don’t want to leave so I’m just looking for any reason to stay at this point.  

@wallymonster There has been a lot of communication from Sonos. Since the blog post you mentioned, there have been multiple release notes, multiple Reddit AMAs (including one with Spence himself), the Trello board, the earnings call, countless comments here (and on Reddit) from Sonos staff, and probably other things I’ve forgotten about. Frankly, it’s hard to think of what more they could do in terms of communication to the public at large.

I suspect you’re frustrated that you have not received a solution directed personally to you for your particular problem. But since they can’t read your mind they’re not going to reach out to you for that; you will have to initiate it by contacting support like Ken said.

I can assure you that your experience is not universal. No cables strewn anywhere here.

Thanks @edmountain. The release notes of “bug fixes” are meaningless and I was not notified of any of Reddit activity or Trello boards or whatever. I get PLENTY of in app notifications about new products.  I’ve gotten 0 about the issues or specific fixes.  They have my email as well.  I’m not suggesting that my experience is universal, but 30 seconds searching will show I’m certainly not in the minority.  Again, I’m very happy your system is working well enough that you’re happy with it but that doesn’t help me and it’s simply not genuine to pretend like this wasn’t and isn’t still an issue.  

There’s a big giant link to the Trello board right on the home page of this forum for goodness sake. And the release notes do not just say "bug fixes”; since the date of your “last communication” they’ve said stuff like:

• Improved queue management including ability to delete and reorder on Android
• Music library indexing and reliability improvements
• Improved TalkBack functionality in Settings on Android
• The ability to schedule System Updates on Android
• Improvements to setup flow
• Added ability to set appearance between light mode/dark mode/system default
• Added setting to change the Alexa wake word language
• Accessibility improvements in Settings
• Improved smoothness and reliability for product setup
• Added the ability to clear the queue on Android
• Added Night Sound toggle in Room Settings for sound bars
• Introduced TV Audio swap for Sonos Ace from Arc, Beam (Gen 1), Beam (Gen 2), and Ray on Android
• Added TV Audio swap for Sonos Ace from Beam (Gen 1), Beam (Gen 2), and Ray on iOS
• Added S2 to S1 downgrade tool
• Improved smoothness and reduced latency for Group Volume controls on iOS
• Added mute buttons for individual products in Group Volume controls
• Added Group Volume controls from the Now Playing screen on iOS
• Added the ability to clear the queue on iOS
• Improved performance for large queues on iOS
• Added the ability to “forget system” on Android
• Improved reliability for speech enhancement and night mode settings on iOS
• Improved reliability when starting playback from a playlist on Android
• Improves stability when adding new products
• Addresses an issue where the app used excess phone battery
• Improves responsiveness of volume changes
• Improves time to add a new song to the queue in certain conditions
• Addresses an issue with local library browsing timing out

They have everyone’s email, not just yours. They’re not going to randomly pick your email out of the crowd and send you a message asking how it’s going. Did you try contacting support?

@wallymonster I’m with you, the Sonos comms has been severely lacking since day 1. Reddit posts and the Trello board are good, but they are aren’t enough for the average owner imo. 
 

Did you know they have been changing and extending the dates for things to be fixed and brought back to the app?  It’s crickets cause there’s no good news with the app. 

@Ken_Griffiths You seem like you’re trying to be helpful.  Again, thank you.  The issue is definitely not my network.  Choose to believe me or not on that front.  These are issues that started with the new app upgrade and have persisted.  And the complaints are consistent with others.  Either the stance is that I’ve never had S2 issues and it’s been my network to cause all these same issues the whole time, or Sonos fixed everything somewhere along the way, but coincidentally my network has changed in some way that has created all the same issues.  That just doesn’t hold.  And network issues may cause some of the things I’ve reported, but not most of them.

@edmountain I’m not really sure how to respond.  Taking things I didn’t actually say to absurd extremes might be fun for you on a Friday night, but not helpful to me or anyone else frustrated on the forums looking for some sort of answer or confidence.  I’m not frustrated because I don’t have a personal Sonos assitant who can read my mind.  I’m frustrated because I’ve spent thousands on equipment that has spent a significant amount of time as unusable bricks over the past 5 months.  It’s also extraordinarily common for businesses to mass email their customers for various reasons.  I’m pretty certain that when the CEO emailed his apology it wasn’t just to me personally.  So no, I don’t expect, nor did I imply that anyone at Sonos should be checking in on me personally.  Again, I haven’t stopped receiving in-app messages and emails about new products.  It would have been much better for Sonos to send messages about the issue and what they’re doing to fix it and negate future issues.  Feel free to disagree with me in regard to whether or not Sonos has handled this well, but to say they couldn’t have done more in regard to communication is just wrong.  

Again, I’m glad that both of you have systems that are working well.  I hope you have great weekends and future endeavors.

@wallymonster

There are often some reasons why multicast packets for device discovery may not work well across some network setups. Examples being using WiFi extenders, systems like Sky Q whilst working with a Sky Router, or incorrectly configured managed switches. There can also be issues with the configuration, or software that’s running on the Sonos mobile controlling device or local router. 

Everything may work perfectly well on the LAN, but that’s not to reason why your products are disappearing from your Sonos App - those items missing are likely still correctly connected to the router but if they are not talking to each other or being seen by your App then there is an issue and it is likely something interrupting the ‘discovery’ packets on your network - if you can’t accept that, then I don’t think you will get your issue resolved, at least perhaps not in the near term.  

So the suggestion to speak to Sonos Support is still an option, but it’s entirely a matter for you as to whether you want to go that route.