Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Sep 20, 2014 1:01 PM UTC

What do I need to know?

Hello folks,

I don't actually have a problem that needs solving at the moments, and I'd like to try to keep it that way. I am more or less by accident about to become a Sonos user and while I think I have a handle on what I'm doing, the more I read, the more I wonder...

I recently upgraded my wireless router (to a Fritz!box 7490), and discovered shortly thereafter that my trusty old internet radio no longer worked. The issue is one of supported wifi encryption standards and is unsolvable.

So, I've been shopping for a replacement internet radio, and on a whim looked through the catalogue for my credit card's rewards program. They had, and I have ordered (but not yet received) a Play:1 intended to be used as a stand alone device in the family room connected to either a switch or my router both of which are close by.

It would be easiest to plug it into a spare 100 meg port on the switch, but would there be any advantage in shuffling things around so I could plug it into a 1000 meg port on the router instead?

My music library is on a qnap ts-112 nas, and at this point is all in mp3 format, although I suppose I could re-rip all the original disks to something less lossy. Could never hear the difference on the old radio so didn't bother.

Clearly the Sonos system is way more than I will be able to take advantage of in the short term, but already the juices are flowing over what it might grow into one day.

I'll be using the android version controller on a Samsung tablet.

What do I need to know that I don't already know? Are there any issues with my plan, and what would you advise in terms of any of the setup choices I don't yet know about?

Regards,

Pcal
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    18 replies

    ratty
    Oct 10, 2014 3:41 PM UTC
    Ah, good old SonosNet. Thanks for posting an update.
    Translate
    pcalAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    Oct 11, 2014 1:53 AM UTC
    Ah, good old SonosNet. Thanks for posting an update.

    [weep]

    New day. Same problem...

    This time, during a brief window of connectivity, I set sonosnet to accept connections and hooked my tablet directly to sonosnet completely bypassing my router and switch all together.

    Still, the tablet/controller can't find the system that it is connected directly to. Internet access was working at that point so I know the connection was good.

    Sometimes, after walking away to calm down, I find it connected when I come back. It is capable of making a connection, so logically there can't be any structural problem that is preventing it from working - it's just being recalcitrant!

    I am close to my limit with this system. The build quality is great, and the sound is fantastic, but if I can't control it without tearing my hair out and setting up a completely new system every time I want to use it...
    Translate
    ratty
    Oct 11, 2014 8:57 AM UTC
    Talk to Sonos Support. In my experience -- and a lot of others' -- they're excellent.
    Translate
    buzz
    Grand Maestro
    Oct 11, 2014 9:19 AM UTC
    pcal,

    Within about 15 minutes after one of these events, submit a diagnostic, note the confirmation number, and follow up with SONOS support. The diagnostic data is comprehensive and networking issues will leave tracks. The fine detail cache scrolls, hence the 15 minute recommendation.
    Translate
    Belly M
    Oct 11, 2014 10:26 AM UTC
    If you have a PC or Mac or even another device that can be used as a controller its worth giving it a try.
    Translate
    pcalAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    Oct 24, 2014 1:10 PM UTC
    The solution ended up being less than optimal.

    My tablet has a firewall (which was set to allow the sonos controller unrestricted access). The firewall uses a virtual vpn to filter all network connections. Some of the protocols used to control sonos, do not survive passing through a vpn even if they have been permitted to pass.

    Unfortunately, the firewall needs to stay - so sonos is now being controlled by an old android phone that has been rebirthed as a remote. Didn't really want another device, but at least it is all working now.

    Beware the NoRoot Firewall!

    Thanks for all the suggestions...
    Translate
    pcalAuthor
    Trending Lyricist I
    Jun 7, 2015 1:35 PM UTC
    The solution ended up being less than optimal.

    An accidental experiment led to a better solution...

    I found that the Sonos controls to FIND a Sonos network are not passed by the VPN system, but the controls to DRIVE the system once found, pass through fine. So I can disable my vpn firewall briefly to connect to sonosnet, then reinstate it. The system works fine until the controller app closes - potentially days later. The extra phone as a controller has been done away with completely.

    The speaker system (which has grown again by another box) still impresses everyone who hears it, and the controller frustration has reduced to only a couple of clicks a week, so everything is good!
    Translate
    Lyricist II
    Oct 1, 2016 11:23 AM UTC
    Well done pcal, I too had to endure identical hair-tearing frustration with my new Play:1's . Beware the No-Root Firewall indeed!

    Really, this issue should be made known to novices right up front. It would save many breakdowns I'm sure.

    Your discovery " I found that the Sonos controls to FIND a Sonos network are not passed by the VPN system, but the controls to DRIVE the system once found, pass through fine.", is correct. It helps to implement some kind of reminder, so that you remember to disable the firewall each time you restart the Android Sonos controller app.

    The way I did it is to make a "folder" and place shortcuts to three Apps in there. [1. Sonos. 2. No Root Firewall. 3. Fast reboot.] Fast reboot is not always necessary but can hasten the process sometimes. This way, each time you go to open the Sonos App, you see the No Root Firewall app there as well. Works well for forgetful minds like mine anyway! :)

    If anyone has a better solution I would be very happy to hear it.

    As an aside, I had similar grief a few years back with my Play:5 and the Windows controller... after endless problems with dropouts etc I had to ditch the firewall I was using and revert to the standard Windows one. Haven't had a glitch ever since. There may well have been a rule that could have been implemented, or another workaround, but at the time my hair was turning grey at a great rate of knots so I took the quickest route.

    Lesson - keep firewalls front of mind when you are struggling with dropouts and connectivity problems.
    Translate