Skip to main content
Contributor III
Dec 29, 2014 1:43 PM UTC

Stereo Play 5s vs Play 1 pair with sub

Moving to another apartment and selling my old stereo equipment I now have spare 2 x play 1 and 1 x play 5 on hands that were before used for different rooms. Due to convenience factor I would like to move one of these to my main listening area but i still question which way to go. Either i add another Play 5 or purchase a Sub to go with Play 1s. Having small kids my listening volume is normally quite low.

Reading this forum some suggest that the sound from play 5s would give me fuller sound but bass from the Sub would be much better, while others seem to think play 1s do sound better on their own when Sub comes into the picture. I understand the decision would always be subjective but would still like to hear some advice.

Thanks
Tomaz
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    59 replies

    Thunderbyte
    Prominent Collaborator I
    Jan 6, 2015 7:24 PM UTC
    but the expensive Sonos Connect seems cheap compared. But I still think it is extremely expensive to what it does.

    I completely agree and have said that numerous times here. Nevertheless, you get Sonos integrated 5.1 (music) sound at a pricepoint of 349$ and not 1796$. And your existing receiver possibly supports DTS. And you are free to use your Play1s in other rooms.
    Translate
    1 Playbar | 1 Sub | 2x Play:5 | 1x Play:3 | 2x Play:1 | 1x Sonos One
    tomaztwoAuthor
    Contributor III
    Jan 7, 2015 2:46 PM UTC
    I recommend the 1 pair + Sub. With the Connect Amp, since the 55 wpc can be a limitation for speakers that go as deep and loud as Sub, best results are obtained by adding a Sub - the 1 pair + Sub will be the cheaper and more elegant solution. Unless you spend a lot more money on speakers for the Connect Amp, the sound quality will be same with the 1 pair + Sub.

    Just checked some forum favourites and i was surprised that i can get Monitor Audio BX2's here for 230 EUR only. Thats crazy cheep and with connect AMP even less than Play 5 pair. Is difference in bass really so obvious since according to specs they go down to 42 Hz, while Sub itself "only" to 34 Hz?
    Translate
    Jan 7, 2015 2:53 PM UTC
    Just checked some forum favourites and i was surprised that i can get Monitor Audio BX2's here for 230 EUR only. Thats crazy cheep and with connect AMP even less than Play 5 pair. Is difference in bass really so obvious since according to specs they go down to 42 Hz, while Sub itself "only" to 34 Hz?
    Yes it is obvious, but that doesn't rule out the BX2 solution. You will get a good all round sound with a good impression of bass. With the Sub, you will also feel the bass. If you don't need that bass power, the Connect Amp + BX2 is a very decent music set up.
    Dali Zensor 3 is another good all round option. With a little lighter bass, so is the Zensor 1.
    PS: You can also add a third party Sub to Connect Amp for a lot less than Sonos Sub, but I have little experience of these to suggest any.
    Translate
    tomaztwoAuthor
    Contributor III
    Jan 8, 2015 9:48 AM UTC
    Yes it is obvious, but that doesn't rule out the BX2 solution. You will get a good all round sound with a good impression of bass. With the Sub, you will also feel the bass. If you don't need that bass power, the Connect Amp + BX2 is a very decent music set up.
    Dali Zensor 3 is another good all round option. With a little lighter bass, so is the Zensor 1.
    PS: You can also add a third party Sub to Connect Amp for a lot less than Sonos Sub, but I have little experience of these to suggest any.


    Many thanks! I really appreciate your efforts. Somehow Sub would be easiest to integrate in my situation rather than bigger stereo speakers. I just hope Play1s can at least come close to mids of mentioned speakers.
    Translate
    Jan 8, 2015 10:24 AM UTC
    I just hope Play1s can at least come close to mids of mentioned speakers.
    Once they integrate with the Sub, they will be as good once properly placed with the same care you would use to place any good stand mounted speaker. Since they won't need to produce bass, they can be in free space to allow all the mids to be well delivered.
    Ideally, place the Sub approximately between the two so that the mono effect of the Sub bass isn't an issue.
    Translate
    tomaztwoAuthor
    Contributor III
    Jan 8, 2015 11:56 AM UTC
    Once they integrate with the Sub, they will be as good once properly placed with the same care you would use to place any good stand mounted speaker.

    Any special instructions for placement other then obvious? Sonos manual has none.


    Ideally, place the Sub approximately between the two so that the mono effect of the Sub bass isn't an issue.


    Sadly this might not be possible. Is there any info from Sonos at what frequency crossover is made when pairing with Play 1? Is it well above 80HZ?
    Translate
    Jan 8, 2015 12:06 PM UTC
    Any special instructions for placement other then obvious? Sonos manual has none.



    Sadly this might not be possible. Is there any info from Sonos at what frequency crossover is made when pairing with Play 1? Is it well above 80HZ?

    No, nothing more than how you would place any decent speaker. If on a shelf, close to the front edge. Tweeters at ear height in listening position.
    No, there isn't any cross over info. But going by how they advise crossovers for the Connect Amp, my guess is 110-120 hz.
    Translate
    Thunderbyte
    Prominent Collaborator I
    Jan 8, 2015 1:55 PM UTC
    Ideally, place the Sub approximately between the two so that the mono effect of the Sub bass isn't an issue.

    As the human ear is not very good in locating low frequencies (other than high frequencies, in my opinion it doesn't matter, where the sub is located (as long as it is not completely obstructed) and certainly does not have to be between the higher frequency speakers.
    Translate
    1 Playbar | 1 Sub | 2x Play:5 | 1x Play:3 | 2x Play:1 | 1x Sonos One
    Jan 8, 2015 2:05 PM UTC
    As the human ear is not very good in locating low frequencies
    Below 80hz is where this is generally found to be the case, which, I suspect is why the crossover question was asked. To what extent localisation capability correlates to the frequency rises beyond 80hz, I do not know.
    Translate
    ratty
    Jan 8, 2015 2:08 PM UTC
    As the human ear is not very good in locating low frequencies (other than high frequencies, in my opinion it doesn't matter, where the sub is located (as long as it is not completely obstructed) and certainly does not have to be between the higher frequency speakers.
    Possibly true for steady state, but I found that putting the SUB behind the couch was not a good idea. It could be transients which gave the game away.
    Translate