Skip to main content
Dec 19, 2016 8:34 AM UTC
Question

Sonos power consumption

Hi,
i'm new to SONOS community and going to get my first Sonos Play:1 very soon as Christmas gift.
I've a couple of questions about the product i was not able to found in the forum (sorry if i miss them in case already asked/answered)

1) i found that power consumption of Sonos Play:1 is 3.8W when in idle mode, no music playing (+0.3W if connected by ethernet). Is it possible to put the speker in sleep mode and wake it up by a WOL magic packet?

2) as i plan to not use the wifi, is it possible to disable the WIFi functionality of the speaker?

Thanks
Simone
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

29 replies

ratty
Dec 19, 2016 11:25 AM UTC
1) i found that power consumption of Sonos Play:1 is 3.8W when in idle mode, no music playing (+0.3W if connected by ethernet). Is it possible to put the speker in sleep mode and wake it up by a WOL magic packet?
Sonos doesn't support WOL. The processor remains active, and indeed so does the wireless interface, so as to be able to respond instantly to a controller.

2) as i plan to not use the wifi, is it possible to disable the WIFi functionality of the speaker?

This practice is not officially supported by Sonos at all, but google will find the instructions for you. Allegedly disabling the radio can reduce idle consumption by up to 2W.
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 20, 2016 10:10 AM UTC
So, i'm close to conclude Sonos products are not applicable to my case. The play 5 2nd gen seems to have reduced power consumption to 1W when in idle, that is good, but the cost is too high.

BTW, as electronic engineer, i can say that adding the WOL function is very easy and making it configurable by user just enlarge the audience without sacrifice usability in other use cases. When WOL is active all the rest of circuits can be turned off and the whole unit consumption can be less than 0.5W!

Probably if Sonos didn't implemented WOL til now is because they designed the HW without support for this function, otherwise it was just a matter of firmware change to add this functionality, that do not to change the philosophy of their mesh system.

If Sonos tell me they will implement WOL on play 1, i'll buy it immediately, otherwise i'll look for something else.
Translate
ratty
Dec 20, 2016 11:06 AM UTC
Sonos is a wireless music system. Ethernet WOL would be of interest to a vanishingly tiny minority: those with an all-wired system. In SonosNet mode the wireless nodes depend on the wired nodes to be fully active so they can actually communicate.

Reducing idle consumption is clearly a Sonos priority since, as you observe, the later models (BOOST, PLAY:5 Gen2) have considerably lower figures. If a matter of a watt or two really bothers you, good luck with your search for an alternative product.
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 20, 2016 12:39 PM UTC
So, why Sonos provided ethernet port on each of their product, if this system is just thought to be wireless?
WOL can be applied also to WiFi, not just ethernet. As it can be made configurable (enabled/disabled), it's just an end user choice how to use the system. If they had this implemented, they surely enlarge the audience, with very low efforts, as i said.
About the wasted 1 watt or 2... it depends on the usage one will make of the product. In my case, that maybe is not just the case of a vanishingly tiny minority, i cannot accept to keep the audio system idle consuming a couple of watts 20 hrs/day (for each speaker): assuming i can listen music/watch TV 4 hours/day, that is a lot, with those figures energy consumed when system is idle is the same as when the system is playing music -> very poor efficiency!
Come on, we're in 2016 and there are ways to make it better! And WOL is one method, also considering that probably the Atheros controller used for ethernet already has this function, and from design point of view they just need to route a couple more wires and pay few hours of firmware development to implement the feature. They've redesigned Play 5, why not redesign also the other products to meet next generation performances?
But, after all, they will make their choice, i'll make mine, i just need to know what can be done and what cannot be done, and decide the way to go.
Thanks
Translate
ratty
Dec 20, 2016 1:02 PM UTC
From http://www.sonos.com/system:
What is Sonos?
Sonos is the wireless home sound system that fills as many rooms as you want with great-sounding music, movies and TV.

The Ethernet ports are there primarily to allow the system to operate in SonosNet mode (the original wireless mesh connection method) where at least one node must be wired.

The operating principle behind SonosNet is that each node can act as a relay for the others, for which its CPU must be functional. Waking wirelessly on demand, even if possible, doesn't fit that model.

Moreover Sonos' approach is to limit the configuration options wherever possible, to make it simple to use and to minimise the support requirements. It doesn't take a genius to figure that the idea of users being able to effectively hibernate some or all of their units could increase support calls dramatically when the system doesn't work as expected. As I said before, Sonos won't even officially condone the disabling of the radio.

IMO there is zero chance of WOL being implemented, whether or not it's a "few hours of firmware development". And we've seen enough of the "only a few lines of code" claims to last a lifetime.

Good luck with finding a comparable multiroom music system which supports WOL. Let us know what you end up with.

In the meantime the few watts my system burns when idle can continue to help heat the house. 🆒
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 20, 2016 2:27 PM UTC
🙂
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 21, 2016 4:02 PM UTC
So, i've made some research, it seems no one had the idea to save power with WOL function. If this will be implemented they've to pay me royalties... 🆒
Seriously, other manufacturer have idle standby power around 4W or more (Heos, BlueSound, Bose...). Yamaha musiccast claims to have just 2 watt in idle mode, that is good. Sonos Play 1 is rated for ~4W idle (and 2W if WiFi is disabled, but this function is not officially supported by Sonos). Sonos play 5 seems to be just 1W consuming, but also this figure come from a user in the forum and is not officially documented.
Considering all other aspect, including the fact that Yamaha musiccast system has an open API that allow to heavily customize audio system operation, my choice defentively goes that way.
I'm interested in the WX-030 speaker and, when i'll win the lottery, in the NX-N500 😃
Translate
jgatie
Dec 21, 2016 4:25 PM UTC
Good luck. By my count, this is the third go round for Yamaha and multi-room music, the first attempts being miserable failures. But if you are willing to give up reliability, reputation, cutting edge engineering, market leading sales figures, etc. for a couple watts power savings, I admire your dedication to green living.
Translate
Dec 21, 2016 5:33 PM UTC
If we had been talking in kilowatts here, I could have made some sense of this thread........
Translate
ratty
Dec 21, 2016 5:42 PM UTC
Such planet-saving effort for the sake of a couple of watts (which isn't wasted anyway if it heats the house) would be totally wiped out by the environmental impact of manufacturing a replacement system. Since the words "Sonos" and "system replacement" are non sequiturs I reckon that puts most Sonos customers well up the scale in terms of eco-credentials.
Translate