Skip to main content
Contributor I
Sep 14, 2022 6:52 PM UTC
Answered

My speakers don't go into "idle" state. Why?

Hi Sonos community
I have a bunch of Sonos products and like most responsible home owners I suddenly got an interest to get my energy consumption under control.
Using a electricity meter (a dedicated power meter, not a smart plug) I find that my Sonos speakers consume roughly 15W (S1), 18W (S3) and 20W (S5). It is a lot higher than mentioned on https://support.sonos.com/s/article/256 but when I look more careful (in Home Assistant) the devices are in "paused" state, not "idle"... Hm, perhaps that is my problem.

The same article as above explains how/when the devices turn into "idle" (and reach the advertised low energy consumption state) but regardless of what I do I can't observe that ever happening. None of the devices are playing anything, I wait for 3 minutes but nothing happens... I wait for 30 minutes, still nothing. I don't have any surround system which can cause a longer delay accordig to the article. When I look at the state history (in Home Assistant again) I can't see any device ever going idle - not even when we leave the house for vacation.


It does not seem to change anything if I close all clients/apps that control the system. 

The only thing I can think of is the Home Assistant integration, could that possibly keep the system from going idle??

Any ideas?

 

---------------------------------
Play:3: SonosA
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.1.3-2.0
Serie-ID: A100

Play:1: SonosB
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.3.7-2.0
Serie-ID: A101

Play:1: SonosC
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.3.7-2.0
Serie-ID: A101

Play:1: SonosD
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.3.7-2.0
Serie-ID: A101

Play:5: SonosE
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.17.4.1-2.0
Serie-ID: B100

Play:1: SonosF
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.3.7-2.0
Serie-ID: A101

Play:3: SonosG
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.8.1.3-2.0
Serie-ID: A100

Play:1: SonosH
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.20.1.6-2.1
Serie-ID: A200

Play:1: SonosI
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.20.1.6-2.1
Serie-ID: A200

Play:1: SonosJ
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.20.1.6-2.2
Serie-ID: A200

Play:5: SonosK
Sonos OS: S1
Version: 11.5 (build 571231030)
Maskinvaruversion: 1.17.4.1-2.0
Serie-ID: B100
 

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
John BAnswer
Sep 20, 2022 7:47 AM UTC

Hi. This is interesting.  I think you should repeat the experiment with the line in removed from the Play:5.  All Sonos devices should have not been playing audio for 10 minutes (say)..

Incidentally, if three of your devices are wired the other devices will not connect over WiFi but over SonosNet (unless you have "disabled WiFi" on the wired devices).

20 replies

buzz
Grand Maestro
Oct 7, 2022 1:29 AM UTC

Switch mode power supplies are very difficult to measure accurately. Which model power meter are you using? How does it handle power factor and harmonics?

Translate
Oct 7, 2022 2:21 AM UTC

Is there a significant reduction in standby power consumption for units that are ethernet wired and have their WiFi disabled? My Connect unit seem to run noticeably less hot in that mode, so that is likely to be the case? The next obvious question - where all Sonos units are ethernet wired, what is the advantage of leaving WiFi enabled if one does not need their WiFi for any non Sonos uses?

Translate
ratty
Oct 7, 2022 8:44 AM UTC

Is there a significant reduction in standby power consumption for units that are ethernet wired and have their WiFi disabled? My Connect unit seem to run noticeably less hot in that mode, so that is likely to be the case?

https://support.sonos.com/s/article/256

Please note that your Sonos product will consume approximately 0.3 W more with an Ethernet connection. With WiFi turned off, products can consume approximately 1 W less than typical figures.

 

The next obvious question - where all Sonos units are ethernet wired, what is the advantage of leaving WiFi enabled if one does not need their WiFi for any non Sonos uses?

None, assuming there are no wireless Sonos devices (including home theatre satellites) and no ancient CR100/200 devices. Android connection to SonosNet was withdrawn long ago. That said, Sonos Support will probably automatically request the radios be re-enabled if they’re contacted about any problem.

Translate
Oct 7, 2022 10:07 AM UTC

So the 5.6 watts of the Connect in stand by mode will drop to around 5 watts via the net reduction of .7 watts. I guess that isn't all of why mine seems to run less hot. But if there is no advantage in having the radio on, whatever is saved is saved and cooler running electronics can’t be bad.

And obviously Sonos kit is not to be compared to the typical modern amplifier that nowadays runs in about 0.5 watts in standby mode, a EU mandate I believe for kit sold in the EU. But it means that turning off the power to less frequently used Sonos kit may be financially better in the home on the direct power savings v shorter service life via power cycling give and take. For kit used daily, leaving it in standby may still be the cheaper thing to do. Unfortunately, there is no way to know for sure since the service life effect is not easily measured, assuming it exists in the case of Sonos kit.

Translate
ratty
Oct 7, 2022 10:40 AM UTC

So the 5.6 watts of the Connect in stand by mode will drop to around 5 watts via the net reduction of .7 watts. I guess that isn't all of why mine seems to run less hot.

With the radio off, perhaps the Connect has less to do in terms of shunting packets back and forth with other units.

Translate
Local Superstar
Oct 7, 2022 10:41 AM UTC

Re wired vs wireless energy savings, your are probably ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul’, you save some energy by disabling wireless on Sonos device, but the ethernet will need to be plugged into a switch port or similar device, that will be using energy?

I have a smart meter that sends meter readings every 30 minutes to my energy supplier, so I can look at any 30 minute period. If I look during the night when the house is ‘idle’ I can see the average ‘idle’ energy consumed is pretty consistent with multiple devices still consuming energy, including Sonos devices. If you have Smart meter and ability to check readings taken every 30 minutes on the supplier website, you could turn off *all* Sonos devices one night, and compare hourly usage with them *all* turned on the next night, this would be a more accurate of actual usage for all your Sonos devices, you could then verify this with the published figures for total consumption of all your devices.

Also remember if you have a few devices giving off a little heat, you will be saving a small amount on your heating energy costs in the winter😀

Translate
ratty
Oct 7, 2022 11:07 AM UTC

Re wired vs wireless energy savings, your are probably ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul’, you save some energy by disabling wireless on Sonos device, but the ethernet will need to be plugged into a switch port or similar device, that will be using energy?

TANSTAAFL

Translate
Oct 7, 2022 11:15 AM UTC

Also remember if you have a few devices giving off a little heat, you will be saving a small amount on your heating energy costs in the winter😀

There are parts of the world that are more concerned about keeping the house cool! Where a class A amp, left on 24 hours as recommended in the audiophile world, would not help at all. My reason for leaving the WiFi off for all my wire connected units is just to reduce whatever temperature the Connect runs at and also to reduce chances for WiFi interference with other devices. The wire connection was done to assure very stable group play - not for allowing the Sonos radios to be off. That is just an associated benefit.

Translate
clabosAuthor
Contributor I
Oct 7, 2022 4:05 PM UTC

Hi
Thank you @buzz for your ideas about measurement approach. It seems this was very good advice!


I did two more tests by adding a light source to the measurement - firstly a 11W lamp and then a 40W lamp.

Since I don't have any data logger I made a 6 min video of each test and then manually noted the readings, second by second. Tedious but worthwhile it seems.

Test 1 - 11 W lamp + Play:1
Average power consumption = 21.06 W
Measured base load from lamp = 11 W
=> The Sonos added 11.06 W

Test 2 - 40 W lamp + Play:1
Average power consumption = 42.28 W
Measured base load from lamp = 38 W
=> The Sonos added 4.28 W

The “expected” line in the graphs below is the sum of the lamp + 3.8W for Sonos.

The documentation at https://support.sonos.com/s/article/256?language=en_US says the European version of Play:1 should draw 3.8 W. If I do the test again with a 60 W lamp I am probably going to get even closer to 3.8.

I consider my question solved now and I withdraw my claim.

Thank you all for contributing!

Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Oct 8, 2022 2:33 PM UTC

Thanks for the follow-up.

Translate