Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 14, 2016 7:22 PM UTC

Is it worth it to add a Sonos SUB to a GEN 2 PLAY:5 stereo pair?

Does anyone see the value in adding a SONOS SUB to a stereo pair of GEN 2 PLAY: 5's?

I've been told that the DSP / crossover functionality of adding the sub to this set would lighten the low end load of the PLAY: 5's, allowing them to more powerfully and clearly produce the mids and highs.

My specific questions:

1. Are there really high and mid frequency benefits to be gained from allowing the sub to handle the low end? Or would the sub just handle the low end, while the highs and mids on the PLAY: 5's sound exactly as they did without the SUB?

2. The pair of PLAY: 5's already deliver substantial bass, so are there even more substantial / noticeable gains to be had from adding the SUB? Or do 2 PLAY: 5's roughly equal the low end output of 1 SUB?

I consider myself a very lightweight audiophile, so I would love to gain more clarity and power if adding the SUB can achieve this, but I do not want to waste the money, if the stereo pair can provide roughly the same clarity and high / mid range power as it already does, while also handling similar low end to the sub?

Many thanks in advance to anyone, who may have input.

Best,

Patrick
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

66 replies

Lyzheng
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 12, 2016 3:39 AM UTC
Got the sub on Wednesday, my first impression is not good. Tuned it with the play 5s(gen 2), however, the base sounds so flat and dull, most of the time it's not even noticeable! I really like using true play and always listen using it. When I crank the sub's bass to max, you can hear the bass but it seems like it's not the full potential. When I turned true play off, the bass came alive and really rock the house. So seems like I have two choices, turn off true play and have bass or turn on true play and have very tiny bass. I will test EQ settings noted here and see if it makes a difference, especially with true play turned on.
Translate
Feb 12, 2016 4:11 AM UTC
When I turned true play off, the bass came alive and really rock the house. So seems like I have two choices, turn off true play and have bass or turn on true play and have very tiny bass. I will test EQ settings noted here and see if it makes a difference, especially with true play turned on.
If you like the way music sounds with true play off, why do you not play it that way? True play conforms to what Sonos thinks good sound should be like; not everyone has to agree with that!
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 12, 2016 4:16 AM UTC
When I turned true play off, the bass came alive and really rock the house. So seems like I have two choices, turn off true play and have bass or turn on true play and have very tiny bass. I will test EQ settings noted here and see if it makes a difference, especially with true play turned on.
If you like the way music sounds with true play off, why do you not play it that way? True play conforms to what Sonos thinks good sound should be like; not everyone has to agree with that!


I refuse to defer to TRUEPLAY when it comes to my PLAY: 5 (gen2) stereo + SUB combo; the bass is anemic when Trueplay is ON. I've read reviews that say the right custom EQ is preferable to Trueplay, if you have the time. I agree with that. I believe the pics of the EQ that worked for me are somewhere in this thread, but those are obviously for my specific room.

ALSO, KUMAR, I have not forgotten about the PLAY:5 vs PLAY: 1 stereo + SUB combo comparison. I've just been busy at work, but I will try to do it this weekend...
Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 12, 2016 4:48 PM UTC
Interestingly enough, just last night I got a SUB to add to my pair of gen2 Play:5s. I am happy with it so far. It makes a small difference on some songs and a huge difference on other songs. I have my tv plugged into the line-in on one of my 5s and it really pops there. I found the setting the SUB to half way between the max and mid setting worked best.

Tonight I will follow the suggestions from earlier in the thread and turn off the loudness and trueplay and see what happens.
Translate
Enthusiast II
Feb 12, 2016 6:28 PM UTC
I have 4 gen 2 play 5s and a SUB among various other sonos. I tried the sub with the pair and found it offers only about 5% more bass then the play:2 pair-only noticeable on Some songs not all. True there is more bass-but not a lot more. I decided the SUB was much better used with other play units where the effect was more pronounced. For 750 dollar it didn't add that value for me to a pair of play5 2nd gen
Translate
Lyzheng
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 14, 2016 3:30 AM UTC
I reset the controller and reconnect my speakers and sub. Surprisingly, it made a difference. Now when I switch the sub on and off while using trueplay, (keeping all levels at halfway mark)I can tell the difference. The play 5s are starting to sound flatter without the sub now. I also adjusted the bass and treble along with the sub and finally the Sonos sub has blown my 12 year old Logitech z-5500 away, I can finally let it go now. The sub along with the play 5s are just so clear sounding and heart pounding! I usually don't listen to song with a lot of bass, but when the bass comes in on those songs, the sub delivers, and that's what matter most. Also, the sub does seem like it expands the sound stage a bit more.
Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Jul 3, 2016 10:23 PM UTC
Hi there,

This thread is quite old but but I find myself in the same situation as some of you guys and ptsmith77 in particular where i own a pair of play5 2ng gen, and consider the option to upgrade my existing system with a play sub.
I'm not looking at a massive increase of bass but rather get more "presence" and/or depth when the volume is low(ish). I'm actually happy with my existing setup when I crank up the volume but I think the overall audio experience could be improved when the sound is played at "normal" level (when you can still talk and not scream at one another).
Also my musical taste are ranging from rock blue to heavy metal with some few exception of good old hip hop/electronics.

Can you please share your experience : would the sub really add its real value only when volume is set high up - ie.for big party... Alternatively does the sub justifiy the cost more for electronic music than rock music?

Thanks in advance,
Nico.
Translate
Enthusiast II
Jul 3, 2016 11:50 PM UTC
Short answer-no.
Can it improve it-yes.
Is the improvement of a Sub to Gen 2 play:5s worth almost $1000? In my opinion definetly not.
Translate
Jul 4, 2016 12:01 AM UTC
The Sub does add a welcome extra layer of depth/richness at low volumes to a play 1 pair regardless of music genre - my tastes run to jazz and acoustic music, and this applies just as much to that. I bought the Sub and have zero regrets with what it does for a play 1.

I can't say how much extra this layer will be for a next gen 5 pair which has significant bass delivery capability on its own, and even less on whether this would be worth the price because this gets to be a very subjective assessment of value for money. The other thing is the clean up of the mid range once bass delivery is moved across to the Sub. Even with as good a bass device as a 5, the small size of its enclosure relative to bass delivery needs suggests that this ought to be significant. In theory.

The best thing to do would be to get one on a returnable basis and see for yourself. For a 1 pair, it is a no brainer.
Translate
Enthusiast II
Jul 4, 2016 2:29 AM UTC
Btw, I've got the SUB and 4 play5s (2nd gen) so I've heard with and without. So although it does add some low end across a larger area it is not a huge change and there is very little is any at all change in the mids or the volume or any other sound qualities. So if the listener wanted to have a dance party in a large house-maybe it would be worth around 800 to add to the 5 pair in that scenario....
Translate