Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 14, 2016 7:22 PM UTC

Is it worth it to add a Sonos SUB to a GEN 2 PLAY:5 stereo pair?

Does anyone see the value in adding a SONOS SUB to a stereo pair of GEN 2 PLAY: 5's?

I've been told that the DSP / crossover functionality of adding the sub to this set would lighten the low end load of the PLAY: 5's, allowing them to more powerfully and clearly produce the mids and highs.

My specific questions:

1. Are there really high and mid frequency benefits to be gained from allowing the sub to handle the low end? Or would the sub just handle the low end, while the highs and mids on the PLAY: 5's sound exactly as they did without the SUB?

2. The pair of PLAY: 5's already deliver substantial bass, so are there even more substantial / noticeable gains to be had from adding the SUB? Or do 2 PLAY: 5's roughly equal the low end output of 1 SUB?

I consider myself a very lightweight audiophile, so I would love to gain more clarity and power if adding the SUB can achieve this, but I do not want to waste the money, if the stereo pair can provide roughly the same clarity and high / mid range power as it already does, while also handling similar low end to the sub?

Many thanks in advance to anyone, who may have input.

Best,

Patrick
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

66 replies

Lyzheng
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 17, 2016 7:06 AM UTC
Awesome thread. Exactly what I wanted to hear. I have two of the new play 5s in stereo and was thinking about getting the sub in the future. Coming from a Logitech Z‑5500 5.1 setup, I feel that the new play 5 is lacking the bass that my Logitech easily pumps out. On the plus side, the Logitech can not compete with stereo separation and clarity of the play 5s. So, does anyone know if the Sonos Sub as good if not, better than the Logitech Z‑5500?
Translate
Lyricist III
Jan 17, 2016 10:20 AM UTC
Just the read through the thread. Nice input everyone! The Sonos userbase seems very helpful and friendly 🙂
Im very pleased to hear you like the setup Patrick. I will give your EQ settings a try later today and see how i like them. One thing i seem to have forgotten - which you even point out yourself - is how the sub adds a lot of sound to the system when its playing on low volume settings. I enjoy this a lot, since i live in an apartment and cannot crank up the sub when its getting late 🙂
Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Jan 17, 2016 4:05 PM UTC
Runedk,

"Loudness" is a human condition. Here is a thread that explains some details. A Wikipedia article has more detail.

In most situations I prefer not to use Loudness, but the SONOS Loudness function is one of the best available because SONOS knows the efficiency of their speakers. Unfortunately, SONOS cannot know the room size.

A subwoofer tends to improve the overall system sound by minimizing system intermodulation distortion because the job presented to the main speaker and subwoofer is simplified. Here is a quick tutorial on distortion.
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 20, 2016 5:17 AM UTC
Another thought: Since you have a play 1 pair on hand, and your focused listening is from just 5 feet away, there may be an opportunity to drop 1 units in place of the 5 pair and redeploy the two 5 units to another room, or even rooms. In smaller spaces, just one of the new 5 units ought to do very well, by all accounts.

Sonos is rare in offering these kind of options/flexibility.


Kumar:

I have not had a moment to swap out speakers, but I will let you know as soon as I get the 1's hooked up for a detailed comparison, using the criteria we discussed...
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 20, 2016 5:19 AM UTC
Awesome thread. Exactly what I wanted to hear. I have two of the new play 5s in stereo and was thinking about getting the sub in the future. Coming from a Logitech Z‑5500 5.1 setup, I feel that the new play 5 is lacking the bass that my Logitech easily pumps out. On the plus side, the Logitech can not compete with stereo separation and clarity of the play 5s. So, does anyone know if the Sonos Sub as good if not, better than the Logitech Z‑5500?

Lyzheng:

I am not familiar with the Z-5500, but I would be surprised if you were disappointed with adding the SONOS SUB. I'm completely satisfied with it. If you don't mind spending the cash, GIVE IT A TRY! : )

I'm sure we'd all love to hear your opinion on the setup.
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 20, 2016 5:22 AM UTC
Just the read through the thread. Nice input everyone! The Sonos userbase seems very helpful and friendly 🙂
Im very pleased to hear you like the setup Patrick. I will give your EQ settings a try later today and see how i like them. One thing i seem to have forgotten - which you even point out yourself - is how the sub adds a lot of sound to the system when its playing on low volume settings. I enjoy this a lot, since i live in an apartment and cannot crank up the sub when its getting late :)


Rune:

Thank you for helping to get this thread started with the first replies to my question. Everyone has definitely been quite positive and helpful.

I'm interested to hear what you have to say about my EQ settings. It could be TRUEPLAY is better for you, but it limited the range of my speakers in my room.
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 20, 2016 5:26 AM UTC
Runedk,

"Loudness" is a human condition. Here is a thread that explains some details. A Wikipedia article has more detail.

In most situations I prefer not to use Loudness, but the SONOS Loudness function is one of the best available because SONOS knows the efficiency of their speakers. Unfortunately, SONOS cannot know the room size.

A subwoofer tends to improve the overall system sound by minimizing system intermodulation distortion because the job presented to the main speaker and subwoofer is simplified. Here is a quick tutorial on distortion.


BUZZ:

Thank you for your input. I will read the article, but I would have to say I already agree with your observation because the highs and mids sound noticeably cleaner when pairing the 5's with the SUB. Until I did that, there was always a little pinch of muddiness in the 5's that bothered me. It's gone now. Now the highs and mids float cleanly on a fuller cloud of bass--I LOVE IT.
Translate
Lyricist III
Jan 20, 2016 2:49 PM UTC
Earlier today - before I read this thread, I posted in the wireless speaker section relating to pairinf two 2nd gen Play 5's with the sub .... I am not anywhere near the technical skills and understanding of you guys, but I know what I heard and my response to it! Having read through this thread I have to admit to being tempted to unbox the 5's again and have another go - particularly with the suggested EQ settings.

As an aside I also have the Connect in my sitting room hooked up to an old Sony TV all in one stand with built in speakers (RHT-G900) which I bought in 2009 for 199 GBP a little more than a play 1 costs today!! I keep trying to justify getting rid of it, but it keeps delivering awesome sound from 450w of speakers! I tried the 5's against it yesterday and still could't justify the change!!

So here is my earlier post....

Hi there - I have only recently invested in Sonos kit replacing a mish, mash of bluetooth and AirPlay stuff!

Anyway - I have a pair of Play 1's and a pair of Play 5's and a sub... I bought the 5's from Amazon with the intention of putting them in my kitchen as a stereo pair with the sub.. I set it all up and waited to be blown away! In the end after much faffing around, I decided I preferred the pair of Play 1's with the sub to the Play 5's either on their own or with the sub... I was very surprised by this and did some further testing and found that I most liked the sound of the 5's when used stand alone as a single speaker. I'm no audiophile and so can't explain why I came to this conclusion - but the 1's with the sub are just more lively, defined - more fun I guess!!

I am now facing the prospect of returning the two Play 5's to Amazon and buying an additional two play 1's for my study and bathroom. I do love the play 5 in my bedroom, its ideal as a single speaker - but I'm not convinced of it's qualities as in a stereo pair config! Also I'm interested in others opinion of the Sub - the jury is out on this one at the moment - I will probably keep it but it hasn't blown me away...

PS I also have a single Play 3 and am keen to try a pair of these together and see how these compare to the Play 1's?

Nick
Translate
Jan 20, 2016 3:27 PM UTC
I most liked the sound of the 5's when used stand alone as a single speaker. I'm no audiophile and so can't explain why I came to this conclusion - but the 1's with the sub are just more lively, defined - more fun I guess!!

The reasons don't matter that much - what you like is what is right for you in these cases. The play 1 pair + Sub remains an excellent system where it isn't asked to deliver more sound levels that it can honestly deliver.
Translate
Lyzheng
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 20, 2016 11:55 PM UTC
Thanks for the reply. The reason I asked is because I was thinking about getting th Sonos connect amp and just hook up the Logitech sub with the play 5s. However, I'm not entirely sure that it will work.
Translate