Sonos moves as seround speakers

That is very disappointing. I wonder whether this is technical or commercial decison?

Yes? There’s an aspect of each, I think. The Move speakers can’t connect to a ‘SonosNet’ signal, which is what the sound bars use to connect to the surround speakers. Why did they leave out this aspect? Probably because it’s too easy to ‘move’ a Move, and you’d have lots of cases of the software ‘breaking’ due to one or both surrounds suddenly missing from the home theater set up. The software currently doesn’t make it easy swap between one sort of use and the other, either, I imagine there’s a substantial change in software state between the two.

Hi @JJack 

You might say it’s a little of both. The explanation below is part Sonos and some of my personal opinion. If you want a definite answer you’ll have to call Sonos. 

Technical

1. Sonos decided not to make the Moves surround capable to prevent someone from moving one (or both) of the speakers away from the surround setup and forgetting to return it. Thereby breaking the surround for the next household person who wants to watch a movie only to discover the back channel is missing because a speaker has been removed. OK simple enough to replace it; but what if the speaker has left the house or is being used on the porch, deck or patio? I wouldn’t want to referee that argument. Ture for a single person it wouldn’t be a problem.

Commercial

1. Building software into the Move to allow bonding to take commands from a Sonos HT speaker would most likely have increased cost
2. The Move was designed to be used as a  portable speaker not as stationary. 
3. Allowing the Move to be used as a surround would erode market share and/or contribute to declining sales of Sonos speakers designed to be used as surrounds.

I hope this unofficial explanation helps. Cheers!

Sonos One can be taken to a different location yet this do not stop Ones to act as back seekers. 

The charging base can be in a fixed location so the Moves can be always pleased back to a perfect position. 

If one of the speaker is missing the system could play in 3.1. 

Strange that One SL can be the back speakers at 45% of the move price.

My mind gets from spending extra 2k on Sonos to return the Move. 

Frankly,  while the Sonos Move can’t be used as surrounds … why would you want to buy 2 Moves to use as surrounds.

2 One SL’s can be had for less than the price of a second Move.

Therefore, if you have a Move now …. you would want to buy a set of One SL’s for the rear surrounds (cheaper option then a 2nd move).   Then keep the move for another room and portability.

I like to listening in stereo in the garden. This is why I bought the Move and wanted to buy another one.

Moves are superior to One even without portability and having 2 moves in the living room is better than 2 Ones. So if Move could be used outside as portable speakers and inside as ordinary speakers capable to act as souround system when watching tv I would move for all Sonos. 

I assume your WiFi reaches the garden? Moves cannot be stereo paired in Bluetooth mode.

Sonos make different speakers for different use cases, and they cannot cover all use cases for every user in one speaker. 

The Move is a portable Bluetooth speaker that can also become part of your home audio system singly or as a stereo pair. That is what's on offer and everyone can choose whether they want that or not. 

I should have first welcomed you to the Sonos community and our addictions to Sonos speakers in every corner of our house.
 

I’m not completely on the band wagon of the Move as a speaker sounding any better than a Sonos One.   Especially for surrounds the Sonos One more than holds its own.  A couple Sonos SL’s for their price are a great addition.   They also then have the flexibility when not listening as surrounds to move to rooms to give you the true impressive part of Sonos and that is music in every room.

I’m also for flexibility for anyones need but no the Move isn’t capable of being a surround speaker and never will be due to hardware layout.

And actually surrounds to me are not the key piece in home theater with Sonos.   The Sonos Sub to me is the most important piece of a home theater setup and should be the #2 purchase after the Beam.   You can go with those two speakers and then decide when you want to go rears.

Yes, but not while still playing music...unless you’re using a long extension cord.  As pointed above, one of the issues is that sonosnet depends on speakers located in generally the same location for a stable network.  The Move, which can be moved around while still playing, would be a horrible player in sonosnet, and sonosnet is required in 5.1 setup.

Another point to make is that one of the reason the Move sounds good in the different locations you place it in is that it has AutoTrueplay, adjusting itself automatically to the room that it’s in.  If you set it up as a surround speaker, you would lose this capability, even if you moved it to another location.

You mentioned that you like to play the Move in the Garden. You do realize that if you could set this up as surround speaker, than it would have to play the same audio as the rest of your 5.1 system (while on WiFi), and would only play left or right channel audio.  Doesn’t sound ideal to me.

Not following why that is reverent.  The base provides power to the Move, doesn’t provide any connectivity functions.

Yes, it would, but it’s not a matter of it being just missing as if a surround speaker was unplugged, it likely will be in and out of range...unless you switch to BT mode only when not in the right spot for surround.  

Not at all.  Surround speaker is actually rather light and doesn’t require much.  Yes, you can use a play:5 as a surround, but it’s generally considered overkill and a waste of the play:5 potential.  Move importantly, it should be a hint that the reasons are technical in nature and not just commercial.

Because there’s another speaker brand where you can use your surround speakers as portable WIFi and BT speakers in the garden?  As far as Sonos possibly losing sales because a product doesn’t do what the customer wants, you also have to consider the customer who would have spent $800 on surround speakers that don’t sound anywhere as near as good as $800 speakers should, because they are not using them for the purpose designed for....and decides to go elsewhere for their next purchase.