Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 6, 2023 3:27 PM UTC
Answered

Sonos Arc with FireTV 4k and Epson 7100 projector problem

Hello all. Just got my Sonos Arc system. Connected to Epson TW-7100 4k Projector. Using the Feintech VMS14201 HDMI 2.1 Matrix Switch to connect Apple TV 4k and Fire TV 4k. But getting no sound with the HDMI-optical connector. Feintech def supports my projector model. Any help on solving this would much appreciated. Connected the system as in the diagram (attached). I would hate to have to return the system. 

 

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 8, 2023 12:00 AM UTC

So, the TOSLINK/optical is working now. Here’s what happened. And I believe SONOS needs to address this shortcoming. 

I had a few years old Sony Bravia TV lying around. I decided to connect it to see what the “TV Setup” option does in the settings of the Sonos App for the Sonos Arc system I bought.

The TV Setup would always fail with the projector. The projector would show HDMI connected to the Sonos Arc in the Epson HDMI menu, but the Audio Out part of the TV Setup on the Sonos App would always throw errors. So the TV Setup was never successfully completed earlier.

Now, after I connected Sonos to an HDMI TV (not projector) and completed the TV Setup process successfully, I decided to reconnect the Apple TV source using the Feintech HDMI switch again with the Optical Out+HDMI dongle from Sonos. Voila! I now have 5.1 (Expanded EDID) on the Sonos Arc system using Optical Out from my HDMI switch.

So It shows me that only a successful TV Setup on the Sonos App fixes the Optical Out compatibility. It’s not a Feintech issue or another. 

This seems to me to be a software problem with Sonos. Is it a software bug then? Can anyone confirm or comment on this analysis?

 @John B what do you think?

28 replies

Trending Lyricist I
Jan 8, 2023 2:01 AM UTC

@anipalooza,

If you do decide to keep the current Feintech extractor and ever have to setup the Arc again with it in situ, then it will be interesting to see if the same thing happens next time around.

Also if you do want to report your findings to Sonos Support Staff, you can contact/chat to them via this LINK to make them aware. HTH

Thanks for the link. I’ll see how the HDfury performs. I shouldn’t have bought the Feintech product I did. Your suggestion for the other Feintech product seems more suitable for my setup with Sonos. And an alternative to HDFury perhaps, Also, thanks for the support link. I will certainly write to them and see if perhaps they have an explanation to what potentially tons of users may be facing. Cheers. 

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Jan 8, 2023 2:14 AM UTC

FWIW… albeit perhaps a bit late now if you’ve ordered the Arcana, but there is also another alternative audio extractor device/combined HDMI switch (with Arc/eARC support) that some here in the community use aswell in place of the of the Arcana, or the Feintech VAX04101A - so here’s a link to that one too from a company called OREI, just for your info…

https://www.orei.com/products/dual-hdmi-earc-audio-extractor-converter-4k-60hz-18g-hdmi-2-0-arc-support-hda-931

Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 9, 2023 1:47 PM UTC

Got the Feintech VAX04101 today. It’s doing a great job. Have got FireTV 4K, AppleTV 4K and PS4 attached to the three inputs. Works great. Esp for getting Dolby Atmos. I think this is the best solution. Should be said that TOSLINK/optical out options using an HDMI switch/splitters are not the best way forward for connecting SONOS with a projector (or TV) without eARC. 

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Jan 9, 2023 1:56 PM UTC

Got the Feintech VAX04101 today. It’s doing a great job. Have got FireTV 4K, AppleTV 4K and PS4 attached to the three inputs. Works great. Esp for getting Dolby Atmos. I think this is the best solution. Should be said that TOSLINK/optical out options using an HDMI switch/splitters are not the best way forward for connecting SONOS with a projector (or TV) without eARC. 

I have the VAX04101 and it works really well for me too. 👍

Translate
Lyricist I
Feb 3, 2023 12:24 AM UTC

I just did the setup with my BENQ projector using AVFABUL 4K splitter switch and the setup was smooth. I am receiving a quality sound from my sonos Arc and 2 One SL’s. If it is atmos sound or not I do not know yet.

Here is the link
https://www.amazon.com/Splitter-Bidirectional-Soundbar-Duplicate-Downscale/dp/B0BFPWF6T7/ref=sr_1_8?keywords=avfabul&qid=1675383527&sprefix=avfa%2Caps%2C286&sr=8-8
 

Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 3, 2023 9:10 AM UTC

Thats cool. You should be able to tell if Atmos is working by playing an Atmos show/movie say on Netflix or another streaming service and check your Sonos app. If its atmos, it will show you Dolby Atmos on the app. 

Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 3, 2023 9:15 AM UTC

Got the Feintech VAX04101 today. It’s doing a great job. Have got FireTV 4K, AppleTV 4K and PS4 attached to the three inputs. Works great. Esp for getting Dolby Atmos. I think this is the best solution. Should be said that TOSLINK/optical out options using an HDMI switch/splitters are not the best way forward for connecting SONOS with a projector (or TV) without eARC. 

BTW, just an update. I started having issues with Feintech VAX04101. When switching between AppleTV And FireTV, the 4k resolution would be lost. I’d have to shut down the projector, and unplug all sources and restart everything to get it working again. I returned the Feintech (again) and have the HD Fury Arcana working perfectly. It is a single source unit, but I don’t mind switching manually as long I get trouble-free video and audio. Has anyone else faced this issue with Feintech? Needless to say, my confidence in Feintech has dropped considerably after two middling experiences with their products. 

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Feb 3, 2023 1:16 PM UTC

I use the Feintech VAX04101, albeit with an old LG TV, rather than a projector. It’s been absolutely fine. I use it with a Nvidia Shield, a Fire TV4K and an old Google Chromecast and not seen any issues. I have not tried the Arcana though, so can’t honestly compare.

The thing I will add is the VAX04101 is well built. I programmed its remote to work with a Harmony Hub so I simply use Alexa to switch its inputs (and the inputs on the TV too). So it all works without using a remote. Picture quality has been just fine, I get Atmos audio too and no lip-sync issues at all.

So I’m happy with their extractor. Mine did come with an EU power supply (I’m in the U.K.) however I had an old UK HDMI switch in ‘man drawer’ that had the same power input, so I swapped the power supplies over to save having to use an adapter. I have not (yet) tried doing any firmware upgrades, since purchase last year, so can’t comment on how easy that is to do, but I tend to leave things alone when they are working well anyway.

Translate