Skip to main content
Piar
Contributor I
July 29, 2024
Answered

Anyone who have found an external harddrive with end-to-end encryption SMB3?

Hi,
I have to buy a new harddrive for the music library - my portable Samsung are to old :) for SMB3.
But - the external drives I found have no specifications for the end-to-end.
I have talked to a couple of suppliers and they have no more information - and have no knowledge about what harddrive do recommend.

So are there any friendly soul here who knows?
I just need 1 TB and I have Windows 11 and the connection in the router is a “classic” USB.

🙏
Pia

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Stanley_4
Stanley_4Answer
Grand Maestro
July 31, 2024

If you have no other issues with your router the NAS is a good option. It can also be a backup storage for other data.

With a NAS it will be in control of all settings, using the router only to provide the communication link.

16 replies

Piar
PiarAuthor
Contributor I
July 30, 2024

Maybe this is the “only” parameters that I can configure in the router regarding the SMB:

 

 

press250
Prodigy III
July 30, 2024

Maybe this is the “only” parameters that I can configure in the router regarding the SMB:

Hi @Piar, have you used your router as a file server with Sonos in the past? I’d guess that it supports only SMBv1 (which will not work with Sonos) but that is only a guess.

Back to your original question, let me clarify something: an external USB drive does not change the version of SMB. Your ‘old’ Samsung drive will produce the exact same result as a brand new external drive.

I’d be happy to suggest a few NAS boxes that support SMBv2 and work with Sonos. Worth noting that this would be a separate device that sits on your network, connected to your router via an Ethernet cable (not via USB).

Your other option could be zero cost: setup a shared directory on your Windows 11 machine!

Let me know what appeals to you.

sigh
Prodigy II
July 30, 2024

I suspect you will be out of luck trying to enable smb v2/v3 it if it’s not visible there or in an advanced options section.

Unfortunately it is yet another of the Technicolor range which is usually branded for different ISPs and rarely available direct so has no ‘default’ openwrt firmware available. Technicolor brand and usually quite heavily restrict the user interface options to the bare minimum based on the telco/isp requirements that they are branding it for. The 799 series is based on openwrt which is more than capable of supporting and configuring different smb versions, until Telcos add their firmware lock down requirements.

There is a healthy community unlocking Technicolor routers and freeing them from the ISP restrictions due to so many being supplied and rarely good security on them.

Piar
PiarAuthor
Contributor I
July 31, 2024

Press250 & Sigh,

Thank you - my brain is going at high speed now - this is not my area … ;)

I would very much like to not have my music on any of my computers - when Im working in my studio below - there I just like to handle my music thru my phone - and I like to have all computers shut down up here. 
Just to go by I have moved some music to a shared folder on my computer … 

Ok -
1. IF buy a real NAS supporting SMB3 - connecting trhu RJ45/Ethernet to my router.
   - Will that be like an separate “unit” that has its own will and the NAS would not to be restricted by the routers configuration?

  1. Unlocking/remove restrictions on my Technicolor router - is that for real. I mean for an non technichal person  as med and also - the router is provided from my internetsupplier - can they have a say?

 

Conclusion?:
We are down to that my external hardddrive is not the problem. (Right?)

I have 2 options (?) - buy a “real” NAS or get my self o new router that is configurable for SMB3. (Right?)

Is there other options? 
Any advice on how to proceed?

🙏 Pia

Stanley_4
Stanley_4Answer
Grand Maestro
July 31, 2024

If you have no other issues with your router the NAS is a good option. It can also be a backup storage for other data.

With a NAS it will be in control of all settings, using the router only to provide the communication link.

Piar
PiarAuthor
Contributor I
August 1, 2024

Hi Stanley,

thank you for clear answers.

Now I know how to proceed. 

 

Time to close this question:

Happy for all help I have received!

Allt gott,

Pia