With the introduction of the Amp Multi and the lack of any hdmi input or atmos support, I thought it might be an interesting conversation to consider why that decision was made. I personally would have liked to seen hdmi input, whether that brings atmos or not, but I can see some reasons why.
The primary reason is essentially that home theatre is just not then intended reason the device was made. It’s for whole home audio.
- Adding hdmi and atmos would be features that many users don’t want and don’t want to pay for.
- Additional features and use cases like this lead to increased possibility for bugs/issues to occur.
- The amp multi is designed to be primarily be in a rack far away from a TV, requiring a long hdmi cable.
- This is 8 channels, or 4 stereo pairs. Home audio setups are usually odd numbered, with a center channel. So either a center channel is missing, or one of the audio channels would be unused.
- Amp multi is 125W per channel, which is probably overkill for many of the channels you want in an atmos home theatre setup.
- Many users would want a hybrid setup with some wired speakers and some wireless. for example, you may want to use a soundbar, or Sonos fives in the front, or era 300s in the rear, but wired atmos/ceiling speakers. The amp -multi doesn’t look like it’s setup to send audio to bond with other Sonos devices wireless in a room configuration. It can bond 1 Sonos sub per zone, but no more.
All that said, I think there is an outside chance, maybe just wishful speculation on my part, that the Amp Multi could be used for atmos audio in the future. If a follow up, next gen, amp is released, it will likely have hdmi inputs because the current gen does. It could still be limited to basic surround sound, but they could make it atmos capable, with the ability to connect to a amp multi via ethernet cable for an additional 8 channels of wired audio + 2 subs, giving you a 7.2.2 setup, or 5.2.4 setup. the rear channels could be Sonos speakers, as the Sonos amp already has this capability. It would eliminate many of the concerns I listed above for a better over all solution.
I do like that idea, but the more of think of it, the less likely I think that’s going to happen. And it’s still not exactly what I want from a home theatre setup.
