Skip to main content
AlexPermit
Prodigy I
Apr 29, 2024 11:52 PM UTC
Answered

Seeking Advice: Upgrading Legacy Sonos System

Hello Everyone,

After a decade of learning from this forum, I'm excited to make my first post.  I’m seeking feedback on my planned strategy to upgrade my Sonos System. This Thursday, I intend to transition from my legacy Sonos hardware, which operates on my 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi mesh network, to the latest models that will utilize my 5 GHz network and operate at 802.11n or better.  I am particularly interested in hearing your thoughts on the potential challenges of switching between these two sets of hardware and these two frequency bands.

Current Setup: My existing system includes three Play:5s (Gen 2), two Subs (Gen 2), a Play:3, a Play:1, a Connect (Gen 2), and an Era 300, all running without SonosNet.

New Setup: My upgraded system will have three Fives, two Subs (Gen 3), two Era 100s, a Port, and continue using the same Era 300.

Networking Gear: I use a Verizon-provided CR1000A router and an AiMesh network setup consisting of an Asus GT-BE98 Pro and three Pro ET12s. Each access point shares the same Wi-Fi channel per frequency. The 2.4 GHz band has one SSID, while the 5 and 6 GHz bands share another. I am confident in my 5 and 6 GHz setup and coverage.

Upgrade Plan:

  • Network Transition: I'll start by renaming, unplugging, and hiding all devices except the Era 300. Then, I'll update the network credentials to the 5 GHz network and remove the 2.4 GHz settings. The Era 300 will then be rebooted to ensure it connects properly.
  • Device Setup: I will gradually introduce the new devices, reassigning the old names to them and configuring static IPs for each via my router's DHCP server.
  • Device Reboot: After setting up all the new devices, I'll perform a system-wide reboot to ensure everything is properly synchronized.
  • Reset: Once I confirm the system is stable, I will perform a hardware reset on my old devices before giving them away. 

Concerns:

  • Sonos Not Found: Over the years, I've learned that Sonos devices can be VERY sensitive to network changes. If my Sonos app struggles to find the ERA 300, I plan to temporarily switch to a wired Ethernet connection to get it online. My final fallback is reconnecting one of my legacy devices to “retrieve” my Sonos System settings, factory reset my Era 300, and iterate to a solution.
  • Changing IP: What’s the best way to assign a new static IP to my devices? Should I reboot each device after I set its static IP so each will have its new IP address before adding the next device? Or should I wait until they are all added and reboot them all simultaneously?  What problems should I anticipate?
  • Can’t Connect to Older Hardware: Will Sonos allow me to change the system's network credentials without updating the network credentials of the legacy devices? Even if they are offline? Do I need to wait a few days, or is hiding them good enough?
  • What Else: Are there any other roadblocks I should prepare for?

I'm eager to learn from your experiences and any insights or recommendations on the order of operations for adding and configuring new devices, handling potential network issues, and the best practices for factory resetting the old devices.

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
AlexPermit
Prodigy I
May 2, 2024 5:03 AM UTC

 Transition Complete!

Crutchfield delivered earlier than I expected, so I completed today.  It was a seamless transition.  I can't believe everything worked.  I renamed, unplugged, and hid all devices except the Era 300. Then, I updated the network credentials to the 5 GHz network and removed the 2.4 GHz settings. I proceeded to change the DHCP reservation for the ERA 300, and rebooted it. I then set up static leases for my new devices before powering them up and added them to my network.

For posterity, I'll note the following:

  • I needed to split the pairing between the left and right speakers and their subs before disconnecting and hiding.  Without doing that, I could not hide "missing" devices.
  • Sonos took a while when I changed network credentials on the ERA 300 and complained that I didn't alter network credentials on the devices I disconnected and hid.  I just ignored the message.

I am now streaming Tidal High Def on all my speakers, and it is rock solid.

I have never had such a pleasant experience making such a significant change to my Sonos system.  I suspect my substandard 2.4 GHZ network caused all my previous headaches.

Thanks @AjTrek1 and @Stanley_4  for giving me the comfort and confidence I needed

13 replies

Stanley_4
Grand Maestro
May 1, 2024 12:06 AM UTC

Took one look at my Quantum Fiber router and grabbed the manual so I could flip it to transparent bridging. I’d hate to have to live with a low function router.

I’m starting to look at moving from the SG-3100 I have now to something newer, too many projects are dropping 32 bit Arm support. Maybe a 64 bit Arm or a bit more expensive Intel based box

Translate
AlexPermit
Prodigy I
May 1, 2024 2:34 AM UTC

I ran the G1100 in bridge mode for a few years. Setting it up is pretty straightforward.  I’m sure there are still guides online for how to do it.

You lose some functionality, such as Remote DVR programming.  My biggest issue was having to reset the router as primary whenever I needed any sort of tech support from Verizon. If memory serves me correctly, I think I had to release the public IP everytime I swapped devices.  I remember cloning MAC addresses to address that.  My connection to the ONT was through ethernet.  If your connection is through Coax the steps may be different.

One day, my Netgate died, and I swapped in my “spare” G1100 router.  It was supposed to be a temprary fix, but I got lazy and used that setup until I upgraded to Fios TV One.  When I did, I  lost the option to use my own router.

Translate
AlexPermit
AlexPermitAuthorAnswer
Prodigy I
May 2, 2024 5:03 AM UTC

 Transition Complete!

Crutchfield delivered earlier than I expected, so I completed today.  It was a seamless transition.  I can't believe everything worked.  I renamed, unplugged, and hid all devices except the Era 300. Then, I updated the network credentials to the 5 GHz network and removed the 2.4 GHz settings. I proceeded to change the DHCP reservation for the ERA 300, and rebooted it. I then set up static leases for my new devices before powering them up and added them to my network.

For posterity, I'll note the following:

  • I needed to split the pairing between the left and right speakers and their subs before disconnecting and hiding.  Without doing that, I could not hide "missing" devices.
  • Sonos took a while when I changed network credentials on the ERA 300 and complained that I didn't alter network credentials on the devices I disconnected and hid.  I just ignored the message.

I am now streaming Tidal High Def on all my speakers, and it is rock solid.

I have never had such a pleasant experience making such a significant change to my Sonos system.  I suspect my substandard 2.4 GHZ network caused all my previous headaches.

Thanks @AjTrek1 and @Stanley_4  for giving me the comfort and confidence I needed

Translate