Skip to main content
Contributor I
May 3, 2022 10:07 AM UTC
Answered

Can i connect a cd player directly to sonos port without having an amplifier ???

Can i connect a cd player directly to sonos port without having an amplifier

I would like to play CDS through Sonos speakers 

I am looking to purchase a Sonos connect and CD player 

Do i need anything else ie amplifier 

I know i can purchase a NAS and stream but i want to play CDS 

I would also like to add a turntable at some point 

Help required please 

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Stanley_4
Stanley_4Answer
Grand Maestro
May 12, 2022 8:48 PM UTC

Most home CD players come with pre-amp level outputs, any of them will connect to your Port with a simple stereo RCA cable.

If you want to connect the pre-amp out of a CD player to a Five or Play 5 you need an stereo RCA to 3.5 mm male cable.

 

 I’ve concluded that there are only two kinds of preamp CD players without integrated speakers: $30 portable CD players (which do work for 30 seconds, but stop every 30 seconds); high end CD players such as the Denon DM-41 

 

The Denon you mentioned is an AMPLIFIER player - it will not connect to your Port of Fives.

Any on this list should connect to your Fives. I didn’t look at sizes.

https://www.crutchfield.com/g_53100/CD-Players.html?fa=1&o=p#&nvpair=AG_Outputs|YCAnalog_RCA_Output

 

Onkyo there, this is the connection you need.

 

 

34 replies

May 16, 2022 11:33 AM UTC

I put most of my stuff on the NAS before I started streaming, see no reason to trim it down now. Adding new stuff I buy only takes a few minutes. Have to rip it and crunch to MP3 so I can play it in the car anyway.

Having my music available when I want it is a big plus, no problems like folks are reporting on streaming services, no problem if the Internet goes down for a few hours. Cost to keep the Pi based NAS running is pennies.

The main downside to using a NAS is the Sonos limits, which mean swapping music in and out just to get it to ‘fit’. At one stage I thought that the 1Gb storage that I bought in 2010 may be the limiting factor, but it turned out to be Sonos kit after all. Casting via Chromecast solves the limit issue, but seems to run the phone battery down quicker than the Sonos app.

I have tried a couple of steaming services, and while they may be good for more popular music, they weren’t good on classical - they may have the piece, but not the performance.

It has been very useful to keep streaming even when the internet connection is down - I feel that we’re all becoming rather too dependent on the availability of the cloud.

I used to buy CDs at full price to rip, but now most of mine are bought from charity shops - so I’m glad that other people are giving CDs up - more for me :-) When you consider that they can cost 10p per CD, it’s quite cheap to try out different music.

The main benefit to me of still having a CD player linked into my ZP90 is when other people come round and bring CDs with them - the assumption is still that I’ll have a working player, although I could use one of the other players (blu-ray, recordable DVD,  HD-DVD) if needed. The 26 year old CD player still sounds the best, though.

 

Translate
May 16, 2022 12:09 PM UTC

The 26 year old CD player still sounds the best, though.

 

That is surprising; I would expect it to sound at best the same as the same CD ripped losslessly and played by Sonos from a NAS that has the ripped file. At best only because the ADC additional step in a CDP wired to line in, should, in theory, downgrade the quality although I doubt that is audible in real world use.

Translate
May 16, 2022 12:14 PM UTC

The 26 year old CD player still sounds the best, though.

 

That is surprising; I would expect it to sound at best the same as the same CD ripped losslessly and played by Sonos from a NAS that has the ripped file. At best only because the ADC additional step in a CDP wired to line in, should, in theory, downgrade the quality although I doubt that is audible in real world use.

The best of the CD capable players - the DVD/Bluray/HD-DVD players don’t seem to play music as well as the old CD specific player. These ‘tests’ were done outside of Sonos, when they were all wired into the AV receiver.

Translate
May 16, 2022 1:33 PM UTC

Got it; perhaps the differences arise from better engineered transports. Electronics downstream of those should be functionally identical.

Translate