Skip to main content
Contributor I
Feb 22, 2017 8:01 PM UTC
Question

2 Play 1s (stereo pair) - What next? 2 more play 1s, sub, play 5?

I have 2 plays 1s in my kitchen diner (25-30 ft x 12 ft approx), I was surprised for the size at how good they sound and am very happy with them.

I am looking to add to the same room (sightly rushed by the price rise tomorrow!) and am considering the following options:

1 - A sub. Expensive and a one trick pony to an extent. I do though have a couple of good spots where I could put it.
2 - A play 5. Cheaper than the sub and offers some flexibility but I do not think I could place it centrally between the 2 1s without compromising where the 1s go. I could place it up the other end of the room from the play 1s (which is generally the end that I sit) but I fear the 5 would over power the 1s?
3 - 2 more play 1s for a 2nd stereo pair. Obviously the cheapest option and I could effectively place them so that each of the 4 would be pretty much in a corner.

Thoughts appreciated.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    17 replies

    neil74Author
    Contributor I
    Feb 25, 2017 9:28 AM UTC
    That's where I am thinking of putting it, running some trunking so I have power and putting it on the window ledge effectively opposite #3.
    Translate
    neil74Author
    Contributor I
    Feb 25, 2017 1:14 PM UTC
    All 4 set up (with 4 in the bottom corner) and I think getting the extra ones is a mistake.

    Sitting at the end of the room that I do the 2 nearest to me stand out and kind of drown out 1 and 2.

    May have to play around the fader between the 2 or maybe even consider a different position for them all, overall though, I do not think I am getting the full benefit of 4 speakers and maybe should have gone with another option like a 5 or sub. With Amazon's generous returns policy I always have the option to return them or just use them in another room.
    Translate
    Feb 26, 2017 1:57 AM UTC
    I do not think I am getting the full benefit of 4 speakers and maybe should have gone with another option like a 5 or sub.
    Adding more than a stereo pair to a room does nothing in the ideal listening position for the existing pair, and can even dilute the sound quality. What the addition can do is provide a more even coverage across a remote part of a larger room so that music can be heard every where without it being too loud anywhere - as it would be if just one speaker/speaker pair is set up at one end of a large room.

    If you want better sound quality in the existing limited listening area as just now, then the Sub or a 5/5pair is the way to go. The latter depends on whether the existing set up is a 1/1pair.

    I am repeating myself:)
    Translate
    neil74Author
    Contributor I
    Feb 26, 2017 1:25 PM UTC
    Play 1s on their way back to the good ship Amazon. Play 5 purchased.

    The Play 5 is very very nice even if paying £70 more than last week did hurt a little!

    Testing the best layout for it, currently have it like this (below) but considering that I may not even need the 1s or could move one of them to another room.

    Translate
    Feb 26, 2017 2:05 PM UTC
    paying £70 more than last week did hurt a little!

    Should you then not have it close to where you do your listening? At location 2, presuming you face that way. And keep a 1 unit in the far corner for when you want music across the space.
    Translate
    neil74Author
    Contributor I
    Feb 26, 2017 2:30 PM UTC
    There is not really enough room for the p5 at 1 or 2. I could put the P5 on the breakfast bar (4 on my older diagram)
    Translate
    Feb 27, 2017 1:39 AM UTC
    What about placing it vertically? Best sound is obtained when you are facing the speaker although for listening to music in background it doesn't matter that much.
    Translate