Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jul 31, 2025 7:26 AM UTC
Answered

Sonos Play5 Gen1 - an interesting Stereo-Mono Postulate!

AI postulates, that the “Play 5, Gen 1” can detect placement-direction (vertical/horisontal) - and adjusts according to that (mono/stereo).

 

With the “Five” it is a YES!
and the “Five” is physically built to be placed “In 3 directions”.

..

BUT,

The “Play 5, Gen 1” are NOT built to be anything but standing Horisontally!

Yet, AI writes:  “Yes, the tweeters in the original Sonos Play:5 (gen 1) play separate left and right signals when the speaker is positioned horizontally for stereo sound.  When placed vertically, the speaker automatically switches to mono.” 


Since I have never yet owned nor listened to these speakers, then I ask you:
“Is it bogus (as I conclude), what the AI do clearly write (/has been fed with) ?”

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Mr. T
Mr. TAnswer
Jul 31, 2025 9:56 AM UTC

Don’t believe everything you read from AI. The AI response is indeed bogus.

The Play:5 (Gen1) can only be placed horizontally as you have stated.

7 replies

Mr. T
Mr. TAnswer
Jul 31, 2025 9:56 AM UTC

Don’t believe everything you read from AI. The AI response is indeed bogus.

The Play:5 (Gen1) can only be placed horizontally as you have stated.

Translate
Headliner I
Jul 31, 2025 10:54 AM UTC

The product manual is always a more reliable source of information that AI.

Translate
Iris-911Author
Contributor I
Jul 31, 2025 11:00 AM UTC

The product manual is always a more reliable source of information that AI.

You’re right - I should have taken that approach

Translate
Senior Virtuoso
Jul 31, 2025 11:57 AM UTC

The product manual is always a more reliable source of information that AI.

You’re right - I should have taken that approach

It’s the last resort though, for so many people! 😜

Translate
jgatie
Jul 31, 2025 12:54 PM UTC

When are people going to realize, AI “learns” by reading stuff on the internet.  Some (most) of the stuff on the internet is BS, guessing, or flat out wrong.  So most of the time AI is BS, guessing, or flat out wrong.   

Translate
Stanley_4
Grand Maestro
Jul 31, 2025 1:59 PM UTC

I trust AI about as much as a used car salesman, it is going to tell you what it is programmed to, not truth or even facts. Many AI also suffer from having internal rule-sets that control what it can say in response to questions, in some cases generating deceptive answers.

On the other hand I really like AI art and I've recently been very impressed with AI generated music.

Translate
Sean M
Sonos Employee
Aug 1, 2025 4:09 PM UTC

I’m not even sure how you’d get a Play:5 Gen 1 into a “vertical” orientation, given its shape. It’s probably confusing Play:5 Gen 1 for Play:5 Gen 2 which does have this feature, like Five. Play:5 Gen 1 definitely does not. 

Translate
Disclaimer: I work at Sonos, but I'm *not forum staff*. Any views expressed are my own.