Skip to main content
Contributor I
Mar 25, 2022 10:05 PM UTC
Answered

Sonos Play 5 Stereo Pair Line-In Problem

Hello All,

New to Sonos and the community.

I purchased two Sonos 5 Speakers.  I have them setup (via wireless) with the app and was able to successfully put them into a “Stereo Pair”.  This works perfectly when playing Spotify, Pandora, etc.  The issue I am having is with the Line-In from my Turntable.   I have the new AT-LP120XBT-USB and have it connected directly to the Line-In of the Left Sonos 5.  I only ever get sound out of that speaker.  If I move the Line-In to the right speaker - I don’t ever get sound out of the right speaker.  Is this by design?

I also notice in the app, that it does correctly show the Line-In connected to the respective speaker, but for the life of me, I can’t get it to play in stereo which is very disappointing.

Can anyone offer any assistance?  Thanks!

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
smigma8Answer
Contributor I
Mar 27, 2022 12:56 AM UTC

@ratty @Ken_Griffiths @John B @Airgetlam @jgatie - You all absolutely ROCK!  Setup one of the Five’s to hardwire which changed the system over to WM: 0 (SonosNet) and now my Stereo Pair works perfectly!  Thank you all for your assistance and suggestions.  This is a great forum!

Even better, it is working with Audio Uncompressed and 75ms Audio Delay.  Very Happy!

25 replies

ratty
Mar 26, 2022 3:02 PM UTC

This sounds like a possible wireless network issue. The right unit should take its stream directly from the left, assuming they’re both on the same channel. 

Translate
smigma8Author
Contributor I
Mar 26, 2022 3:29 PM UTC

This sounds like a possible wireless network issue. The right unit should take its stream directly from the left, assuming they’re both on the same channel. 

@ratty @John B - Yes, I am starting to think this could related to my wireless network - although not 100% sure.  I have controller based Aruba Wireless in my home, as I am in IT, so this isn’t your traditional consumer grade wireless product.  I do see that the speakers are both connected to wireless, but one has negotiated 2.4Ghz and the other has negotiated 5Ghz - as such, they are obviously also on different channels.

I guess my confusion is that IF that were the issue, I wouldn’t expect Stereo Pair to work at all, but it does when steaming Pandora, Spotify, etc. in this exact same configuration.  That all works flawlessly - it’s literally just the Line-In that doesn’t use both speakers.  Do the speakers function differently with a line-in source vs streaming with regard to how the sync/pair?

@John B - Autoplay is set to “Bedroom” which is the room where the Stereo Pair resides.  I am going to try to find my audio cable for my iPhone to connect Line-In from it to see if I get a different result.

@Ken_Griffiths - Yes, I have tried all the different options for compression - no change.  Also tried all the different options with audio delay - no change. 

Translate
ratty
Mar 26, 2022 3:37 PM UTC

Line-In, at least in Uncompressed form, is more demanding than the other sources listed. It’s WAV/PCM, with shallow buffers by default.

I suppose one could try fiddling with the compression and/or delay (buffer) settings, but to be honest the combination of 2.4G and 5G wireless connections across the two units is pretty horrid. Inter-unit latency could be decidedly variable.

I’d suggest fixing the network such that both units are on the same channel. They’ll then be able to stream directly peer-to-peer. 

Translate
Mar 26, 2022 3:41 PM UTC

With those connections direct routing between the paired speakers is prevented. It is possible that the system copes with the alternative routing better with other sources. Although I would have thought using compression and delay would have got round that.

As an experiment you might try wiring a Sonos speaker to your router so that everything connects over SonosNet. 

Translate
ratty
Mar 26, 2022 3:48 PM UTC

Sorry, I skipped the fact that the OP had already tried compression/delay tinkering.

It’s conceivable, but not necessarily logical, that Sonos does something different with stream distribution for Line-In -- multicast vs unicast maybe -- and the Aruba system is obstructing traffic between the two bands.

Translate
Ken_Griffiths
Mar 26, 2022 4:02 PM UTC

It’s a strange one and ‘perhaps’ maybe related to your Aruba WiFi and the different WiFi bands - but next maybe try the speakers on SonosNet instead and see if that resolves the matter for you.

I’ve tested both line-in’s on the ‘Fireplace’ Five stereo pair here and both play to the pair - however I’m currently using a SonosNet setup.

Translate
ratty
Mar 26, 2022 4:07 PM UTC

It definitely ought to work, once the network is sorted out.

I’ve also used a stereo pair in the total absence of a central network, with Line-In fed into one unit. They SonosNetted together to form an AutoIP island, and both played fine.  

Translate
smigma8Author
Contributor I
Mar 26, 2022 4:40 PM UTC

Appreciate all the help here.  I am going to give the SonosNet option a try.  I will need to move the equipment around a bit, so I will do that and report back.  Thanks!

Translate
smigma8AuthorAnswer
Contributor I
Mar 27, 2022 12:56 AM UTC

@ratty @Ken_Griffiths @John B @Airgetlam @jgatie - You all absolutely ROCK!  Setup one of the Five’s to hardwire which changed the system over to WM: 0 (SonosNet) and now my Stereo Pair works perfectly!  Thank you all for your assistance and suggestions.  This is a great forum!

Even better, it is working with Audio Uncompressed and 75ms Audio Delay.  Very Happy!

Translate
ratty
Mar 27, 2022 6:41 AM UTC

For vinyl, where there's no lip sync requirement, I'd recommend a delay setting of 150ms. It'll provide a tad more stream resilience, without upsetting the whole needle experience. 

Translate