Skip to main content
Contributor II
Oct 24, 2013 5:39 AM UTC

TuneIn: Choosing from different stream qualities.

I'm using the TuneInApp for several years now on my smartphone, tablet, Mac and - of course - on my Sonos devices. iTunes offers hearers the possibility to choose from different stream qualities a radio station provides. It would be great if I also may choose them from within the Sonos controller apps. This may also practical when a user is on holidays: when the user takes his Sonos Play: loudspeaker with him 😉 and connects it to a mobile 3G/LTE router this could help saving bandwidth.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    36 replies

    Prominent Collaborator I
    Aug 4, 2014 8:51 PM UTC
    Hi Andy,

    I totally agree with you, the best solution to this problem would be if it was possible for the Sonos user to choose the streams by themselves.

    Just for info underneath is a part of a longer e-mail I have send to Sonos approximately 6 weeks ago.

     

    Proposal for improving the Tunein, sound quality.

    I feel that the Tunein sound quality on Sonos from the Danish National Radio “DR” is really bad.

    National Danish Radio is streaming their broadcasts in two qualities, 96 kbps and 192 kbps, and Sonos constantly choose the low 96 kbps quality.
    On different Danish hi-fi forums I can see that I am not the only Sonos user who has noticed this.


    Before I have used the Tunein app on my iPad with a cheap Bluetooth receiver connected to my Hi-Fi.

    And the DR sound quality was much better on this set up, when I select 192 kbps than on my new Sonos system, because Sonos only chooses to play DR with the 96 kbps stream.

    Perhaps you would say that this is a Tunein problem and not a Sonos problem, but I think it is a Sonos problem.

    I therefore propose that you on the controller app make it possible to change the Tunein streaming quality.


    I think that on all other streamers that uses Tunein such as Philips, Bluesound etc. you as a user has the possibility to choose the streaming quality.

    And this coming year the competition on the streaming market is getting harder. It will bring for example. Denon Heos, Panasonic Home AV Allplay, Samsung WAM, LG Wireless Audio Systems etc. and it seems they all use Tunein to play radio stations.
    Therefore if Sonos do not allow the customers to get the best radio sound quality, this will be a big Sonos problem

    My suggestion is that the costumer should have the possibility, to somewhere under Advanced Settings, to be able to save the Tunein streaming quality for the saved preset/my radio stations

    .
    Then when you select a radio station from My Radio Stations it will play the station with the stream you by yourself have chosen.

    This would give Sonos an advantage over the completion, because on Bluesound etc. you have to choose the streaming quality every time you change a radio station.


    If the streaming quality is saved under each preset it will save the user many keystrokes and Sonos will always play the radio stations with the highest possible streaming quality you by yourself have chosen.



     

    PS: for now it seems that the problem with DR has been solved, therefore if you only have read this post, then please read this thread from the start.
    Translate
    Trending Lyricist I
    Aug 7, 2014 4:53 PM UTC
    After emailing the BBC to ask them to re-order their streams, I got the following response:
    Thanks for contacting the BBC iPlayer Support Team.
    I understand you would like us to re-order our streams used for BBC Radio 1-3 to allow the higher quality stream to come first.
    We're aware that a non-BBC station has made a similar change along these lines previously.
    Your suggestion has been used to inform a report which is sent to the BBC iPlayer radio team, including the head of BBC iPlayer Radio
    There's obviously no guarantee that they will do anything, but I suppose it's good that they appear to be at least looking into it.

    If anyone else listens to BBC stations on their Sonos, it might be worth you also emailing them - the more people that ask more likely it is that they will do something.  I used the following URL to contact them (I selected "Make a suggestion"):

    https://iplayerhelp.external.bbc.co.uk/tv/forms
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Sep 17, 2014 9:06 AM UTC
    I hope that this can be implemented.  I listen to BBC 6 music and Sonos selects their lower bit rate, but i don't have a Windows or Mac PC, so can't add the url for the higher bit rate.
    Translate
    Lyricist I
    Oct 10, 2014 8:44 AM UTC
    Sounds like a good idea, except for those of us stuck on prehistoric rural broadband where defaulting to the highest bitrate would probably cause problems. User selected bitrate and being able to hear the radio at all would be preferable to unattainable high quality.
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Oct 10, 2014 8:57 AM UTC
    Thanks for your comments, Felicity.  That's actually what we're asking for, user selectable bitrates, so that users can choose their preferred speed/quality.
    Translate
    Enthusiast II
    Nov 6, 2014 11:34 AM UTC
    How do people know what bitrate the radio station is being played at? Sonos doesn't tell you, so are you going by the perceived audio quality or is there a tool ?
    Translate
    Contributor I
    Nov 6, 2014 12:33 PM UTC
    Just the audio quality. It's very noticeable.
    Translate
    Enthusiast II
    Nov 6, 2014 12:35 PM UTC
    sorry, i meant how does one see the audio quality (bitrate) currently. How do I know what bitrate my radio stations, even manually added ones are currently using?
    Translate
    Trending Lyricist I
    Nov 6, 2014 12:41 PM UTC
    sorry, i meant how does one see the audio quality (bitrate) currently. How do I know what bitrate my radio stations, even manually added ones are currently using?
    Have a look at this forum post, this is the method that I use:

    http://forums.sonos.com/showthread.php?t=39657
    Translate
    Contributor I
    Nov 6, 2014 1:04 PM UTC
    sorry, i meant how does one see the audio quality (bitrate) currently. How do I know what bitrate my radio stations, even manually added ones are currently using?
    I've not got access to Windows. Luckily when I did I added the 6 music stream. It didn't appear again after moving house until I added my Connect. So I have 6 music streaming now at decent quality
    Translate