Skip to main content
Avid Contributor I
Apr 9, 2017 8:52 AM UTC

Trueplay Difference Metric?

I was playing around inside my speakers and found Trueplay info and the difference metric. What does this mean?

My speakers reading are

Play 5 - 7.7
Play 1 kitchen - 10.9
Play one bedroom - 6.5

I'm too curious what can I learn from this info? Is 0 no change? What does it go up to? How can I see what EQ has been applied? And no I am not changing anything in the browser login so don't worry ?

And while I'm on Trueplay topic:

Is any IOS device better than the other as far as measurements go? Is an iPad mic worse/better than the IPhone?

As far as the waving goes, do you also point at the ceiling and floor too or just the walls from top to bottom?

Do you only face the room boundaries or do you cross the middle of the room too? What % of the time should be spent in the main listening area?

Should we sit down in the listening area?

What gives the best results?

There really needs to be a more comprehensive instruction manual for Trueplay. The 30 sec demo in the app is useless, she suddenly goes from one spot to the other side of the room.


Thanks
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    25 replies

    ratty
    Apr 9, 2017 11:51 AM UTC
    The 'bass popping' behaviour with a Trueplay tuned PLAY:1 has been reported before. There are a few threads.

    This appears to occur when TP reinforces the bass due to speaker/room layout. One suspects that the bass is already heavily EQ'd to give the small speaker decent bass extension and the TP enhancement is sometimes sufficient to drive the signal into clipping. It sounds a bit like a drive unit hitting the limits of its excursion. Since it's independent of volume level any clipping must occur upstream.

    Sonos seem to take the line that there must be a hardware fault, but I've witnessed this behaviour on multiple units when placed and tuned in a specific location.

    This problem used to be so severe that I would disable TP for the PLAY:1s in question. Sonos have obviously made some DSP improvements over time, since I can now use TP without encountering the issue except on very extreme material.
    Translate
    Apr 9, 2017 12:32 PM UTC
    The 'bass popping' behaviour with a Trueplay tuned PLAY:1 has been reported before.
    Consequence of clipping/over excursion caused by attempts to boost null room responses? Something that room response DSP usually stay away from attempting, restricting correction to smoothing peaks.
    But if Sonos has largely fixed this, OP should not see it happening all the time.
    Translate
    ratty
    Apr 9, 2017 12:43 PM UTC
    Consequence of clipping/over excursion caused by attempts to boost null room responses?
    One suspects so, at least in TP's initial incarnation. As I say, Sonos appear to have quietly addressed it in a subsequent firmware version. On another thread I speculated that this resolution may not be totally unconnected with the soft-knee limiter detected in CONNECT.
    Translate
    TroykmAuthor
    Avid Contributor I
    Apr 9, 2017 8:41 PM UTC
    The 'bass popping' behaviour with a Trueplay tuned PLAY:1 has been reported before. There are a few threads.

    This appears to occur when TP reinforces the bass due to speaker/room layout. One suspects that the bass is already heavily EQ'd to give the small speaker decent bass extension and the TP enhancement is sometimes sufficient to drive the signal into clipping. It sounds a bit like a drive unit hitting the limits of its excursion. Since it's independent of volume level any clipping must occur upstream.

    Sonos seem to take the line that there must be a hardware fault, but I've witnessed this behaviour on multiple units when placed and tuned in a specific location.

    This problem used to be so severe that I would disable TP for the PLAY:1s in question. Sonos have obviously made some DSP improvements over time, since I can now use TP without encountering the issue except on very extreme material.


    This is exactly what's happening to my play 1. Sonos told me its an "environmental issue" and to not use trueplay. This is of course absurd. Trueplay is supposed to correct for the room the speaker is in and im being told the room layout is what's causing Trueplay to not work correctly.

    As ive said this only happens in the kitchen. Put the same play one in any other room and its fine. Put the bedroom play 1 in the kitchen and it suffers the same fate. So its definitely not a hardware fault. Its all trueplay.

    I should add that Trueplay works perfectly in the bedroom and the lounge room so its not a user error nor do i not like the result - in fact i love the result in the other rooms which is why i want it to work in the kitchen.

    After all in this video made by sonos they talk about just how good trueplay is for the kitchen. How ironic that i cant get it to work correctly and the very company that makes it told me not to use it in that room.

    https://youtu.be/8QgJHUy93T0
    Translate
    Apr 10, 2017 1:29 AM UTC
    If you don't post a diagnostic here, all you will get is words.
    Translate
    TroykmAuthor
    Avid Contributor I
    Apr 10, 2017 7:03 AM UTC
    Diagnostic 7283151
    Translate
    Apr 10, 2017 10:06 AM UTC
    Over to you now, Sonos🆒
    Translate
    Ryan S
    Retired Sonos Staff
    Apr 10, 2017 8:07 PM UTC
    Good suggestions everyone. The diagnostic isn't calling out any major flaws, but a few things I'd just like to check. First off, if you just turn off Trueplay for that speaker, you don't hear any clipping issues, correct? Playing the same songs, at the same volumes?

    Have you tried moving it into a different position in the same room and tuning again?
    Translate
    Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
    TroykmAuthor
    Avid Contributor I
    Apr 11, 2017 5:29 AM UTC
    Hi Ryan

    Yes, it you turn off Trueplay there is no clipping or distortion of any kind. Yes I have moved it around the kitchen and it still distorts in the bass to various levels - it's better in some location, worse in others but always there. At no point is the play 1 enclosed in any way, always on a bench or shelf with open air on three sides. Yes on the same songs, same volumes, same notes in the song. It does however not happen if the volume is below 1/3of max. As soon as you go above 1/3, even just one click on the iPhone for volume up, it starts.

    When I say distortion in bass, it's mostly when the kick drum is used in a song. That's when it's worst.

    For example, during the song "setting the world on fire" by Kenny Chensey, it does it on the songs first kick drum, then the next 2 are fine then on the 4th it does it again and on like that. This is not the only song however, it's all songs.

    When you say "no major flaws" I take it there is something there you have seen?

    Thanks
    Translate
    Ryan S
    Retired Sonos Staff
    Apr 11, 2017 4:56 PM UTC
    When you say "no major flaws" I take it there is something there you have seen?

    There's always something in a diagnostic, wireless spikes, a little more noise than we'd like to see... in this case, nothing that I saw would cause this, and not enough of anything worth chasing. The system seems to be operating just fine.

    This sounds like a strange issue with audio in that room. Since multiple PLAY:1s have had the same issue, in different positions, and it goes away with Trueplay off, we've narrowed down just about all the variables. You may just be running into a problem with that room where Trueplay tuning isn't accounting for something.

    The only other suggestion I could offer now would be to try using a different iOS device, perhaps the different microphone will help.

    And of course, I have to ask, does it sound good without Trueplay on? If so, I'd say don't worry about it. Leave Trueplay off and just enjoy. The PLAY:1 was designed to sound great, if it does that without Trueplay, don't try to fix what isn't broken.
    Translate
    Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.