Skip to main content
Contributor I
Dec 3, 2015 1:50 PM UTC
Question

Trueplay Bass Distortion on Play:1

I recently set up Trueplay on a couple of Play:1s that I own. When testing out the post-Trueplay calibration sound I discovered bass distortion once I dialed up the speaker to about half-way on the volume bar (my EQ had bass and treble right in the middle and Loudness was turned off). At first I thought it was an issue with my speaker, but turning off Trueplay removed the distortion issue. The best way to describe the distortion is that it is a deep popping bass sound like occurs intermittently (maybe once every couple of seconds, but that depends on how bass heavy the song is).

Anyone else having this issue with a Trueplay-tuned Play:1?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

161 replies

Nando010
Chromatic Producer I
Feb 20, 2017 10:23 AM UTC
I find truplay works and sound fantastic with the 5.1 setup, playbar, 2 play 1s and the sub. I have two play 5s and when truplay is turned on you can hear it tone down the bass and makes it sound flat, which doesn't sound as good,the same as the 2x2 play 1s setup i have upstairs. so i have truplay turned off for my stereo pairs.
Translate
Feb 20, 2017 10:34 AM UTC
truplay is turned on you can hear it tone down the bass and makes it sound flat, which doesn't sound as good,
Almost every room response DSP does this; but since people most are used to a bloated bass, it sounds flat to start with. In time one gets used to what is a more balanced sound signature and the true play off mode feels artificial. At times all that is needed is to bump up the Sub output level a little from the centre position at which Trueplay tuning leaves it.

But if personal preference remains for True play off, Sonos also makes this very easy to accomplish. End of the day, whatever floats your boat is best for you.
Translate
Nando010
Chromatic Producer I
Feb 20, 2017 4:39 PM UTC
truplay is turned on you can hear it tone down the bass and makes it sound flat, which doesn't sound as good,
Almost every room response DSP does this; but since people most are used to a bloated bass, it sounds flat to start with. In time one gets used to what is a more balanced sound signature and the true play off mode feels artificial. At times all that is needed is to bump up the Sub output level a little from the centre position at which Trueplay tuning leaves it.

But if personal preference remains for True play off, Sonos also makes this very easy to accomplish. End of the day, whatever floats your boat is best for you.


Yes it is down to personal preference,the difference is night and day with my play 5s.The Quality is definitely better with truplay off on mine.
Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Feb 25, 2017 12:16 AM UTC
My Play:1 distorts religiously and predictably.
It is odd some people have this problem and others don't.

Very odd. I have 4 units bought at different times since early 2014 and all perform very well.

I found that there are close to 3000 reviews on Amazon, and even in the eighty odd one star reviews that are very critical of the feature set, something like this doesn't find a mention.

Something definitely smells.


I exchanged mine and will hook it up later and report back.

I can 100% promise you I am not making this up. Any song with any kind of bass produced a crackling noise from the speaker. If I turned loudness on or turned the bass up, it was worse.

On some hip hop songs I have to turn the bass down to 1/4 and regular pop songs can distort/crackle at the default levels.

I agree its not a more prevalent issue in the reviews. If this new unit (from bestbuy) crackles, then I will try it in another house or office. This is a brand new house and maybe there is some odd issue with the electrical current. Makes no sense I understand, but this was hands down the worst audio product i've ever purchased.

Curious to see if the new one cracks and pops.

I know in new residential construction there are some different electrical codes and standards in place. No idea if this is the problem but i'd say there is some chance it is. Since Sonos is headquartered in the land of no-new-construction-ever, I don't see this problem ever being resolved. The noises I heard were real and they were real annoying.
Translate
Feb 25, 2017 1:44 AM UTC
Any song with any kind of bass produced a crackling noise from the speaker.
Curious to see if the new one cracks and pops.

I know in new residential construction there are some different electrical codes and standards in place.

That points to a speaker defect and not a Trueplay driven issue that this thread is about.

Nonetheless...the new one should not behave the same way, Sonos does not need special kind of mains power to work, just the normal stable kind that is utility provided, as long as that means that old, and well established quality standards have to be met before a construction is released for residential use.
Translate
Lyricist I
May 13, 2017 11:39 AM UTC
I have the exact issue of "popping" on bass for my Play 1's (2 of them) and Play 5. Is there any actual answer on how to fix this yet??
Translate
Lyricist I
Aug 23, 2017 8:01 AM UTC
I have had this problem for some time, two Play 1's but only one experiencing poor bass response or 'clipping' even at relatively low volumes. This happens whether using TruePlay tuning or not and with identical EQ settings on both units. Not sure if this is the case for anyone else but the solution was very simple for me. The unit affected was on the worktop in the kitchen, within close proximity to the power socket. As such I coiled the power cord and cable tied it in a nice neat bundle out of sight behind the unit. It occurred to me that the only difference between the kitchen unit and the unaffected living room unit was this cable arrangement. I've uncoiled the cord and done another TruePlay retune and hey presto, nice deep bass (deep for a Play 1 anyway) with no clipping/popping even at much higher volumes. The units now seem very much aligned in terms of sound quality. I assumed units like these would be shielded from electrical interference but clearly not where a cable is coiled and so close to the rear of the unit. Hope this is of some help to others.
Translate
Enthusiast I
Aug 24, 2017 7:55 PM UTC
I have had this problem for some time, two Play 1's but only one experiencing poor bass response or 'clipping' even at relatively low volumes. This happens whether using TruePlay tuning or not and with identical EQ settings on both units. Not sure if this is the case for anyone else but the solution was very simple for me. The unit affected was on the worktop in the kitchen, within close proximity to the power socket. As such I coiled the power cord and cable tied it in a nice neat bundle out of sight behind the unit. It occurred to me that the only difference between the kitchen unit and the unaffected living room unit was this cable arrangement. I've uncoiled the cord and done another TruePlay retune and hey presto, nice deep bass (deep for a Play 1 anyway) with no clipping/popping even at much higher volumes. The units now seem very much aligned in terms of sound quality. I assumed units like these would be shielded from electrical interference but clearly not where a cable is coiled and so close to the rear of the unit. Hope this is of some help to others.

How strange! I have several Play 1's (although bonded in a pair with a Sub) but the one which has the distorted bass issue has an identical set-up to yours. I tried your trick and amazingly it has sorted the issue! I uncoiled the cable and moved the speaker away from the socket and did a retune. After the retune, I coiled the cable back up and moved the Play back to its original position and it continues to play without any distortion. Thanks for the advice.
Translate
Aug 26, 2017 6:56 AM UTC
Just to add to the thread, I have always had the bass distortion issue with my Play 1's. I have had 4 Play 1s over the past 3 years and currently own 2 units which were purchased about 3 months ago. The speakers were / are positioned in different ways and in different locations. Trueplay tuning (done it many many times) always resulted in bass distortion (bass popping and clipping even at low volumes). My only solution to the problem was and remains: Turn off Trueplay. I do not get bass distortion once I disable Trueplay on the Play 1. This is a shame of course because Trueplay works great on my Play 5. I am using the manual EQ to tweak the Play 1 sound.

I find the default Sonos sound (Play 5 Gen 2, Play 1) to be very bass heavy anyway. This is exacerbated if the speaker is close to walls but the bass bloat remains even if the speaker is placed well away from walls and in big rooms. Loudness (on by default) adds to that problem. I managed to get a more balanced sound by reducing the bass by quite a few clicks (between 3-5).

So to summarise, like others, I have always had the Trueplay bass distortion problem with all my Play 1 speakers (past and present). I have accepted that unfortunately this is not going to be fixed but I can achieve good sound by disabling Trueplay and manually tweaking the EQ.
Translate
Sep 2, 2017 7:21 AM UTC
Just a quick follow up to my previous message.

Good news: I have managed to use Trueplay on the Play 1 without resulting in bass distortion. I am not sure why it works after my previous attempts. I had not tried Trueplay for 2 months but tried it again last night and it seems to work. It reduces (to some extent) the bass bloat which is the default Play 1 sound but the real magic is with the midrange and vitality of the sound. The bass bloat need further manual EQ adjustment after Trueplay (2-3 clicks additional reduction in bass) but the great news is: No more bass distortion :-)

I love the resulting sound.

My advice is to try again and to repeat the process a few times. Also, if you have any case (no matter how minimal) on the iPhone try removing it.

Cheers
Translate