Skip to main content
Dec 19, 2016 8:34 AM UTC
Question

Sonos power consumption

Hi,
i'm new to SONOS community and going to get my first Sonos Play:1 very soon as Christmas gift.
I've a couple of questions about the product i was not able to found in the forum (sorry if i miss them in case already asked/answered)

1) i found that power consumption of Sonos Play:1 is 3.8W when in idle mode, no music playing (+0.3W if connected by ethernet). Is it possible to put the speker in sleep mode and wake it up by a WOL magic packet?

2) as i plan to not use the wifi, is it possible to disable the WIFi functionality of the speaker?

Thanks
Simone
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

29 replies

Prodigy II
Dec 21, 2016 6:43 PM UTC
4W in idle mode which is...erm...erm....£5 a year cost assuming you do not use your speaker at all. Vs the cost of the speaker...erm...
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 21, 2016 8:17 PM UTC
Guys,
at the end the 2 watts more or less was just a part of the story*.
To tell it fully, its a couple of weeks i became interested in such audio systems, found Sonos as the number one initially, and i subscribed this forum being convinced at last to buy the first piece, a Play 1. I was also impressed by the sound quality as i tested it at the media shop. But, understanding how the system works, mainly relying on a wireless network that is kept ALWAYS active just to maintain itself, made me think twice about that.
In the mean time, thanks also to this forum, i discovered there were other similar systems. No much difference in the connection philosophy, all those products are categorized as wireless speaker even if the right name, IMO, should be network speaker. Maybe they have a better appeal if focus is on the wireless part, and i think everyone can agree that most users rely on that because they lacks wired connections between house zones. But, it's also obvious, at least to me, that cable is a best choice for several reasons, when available, and i'm trying to replace all wireless in my house with cables. Where i was able to do that, i noticed great performance increase in terms of speed, reliability and power, that's why i'm trying to limit wireless usage, and Sonos system goes exatly opposite way (even if they have ethernet, they do not reccommend/allow to disable wifi)
Finally, last couple of days i spent some time at the media shop comparing the sonos and yamaha, and surprisingly i found that the sound produced by wx-030 was tasting better to me than sonos play 1 and play 3, and at less price! Play 5 was another category but it's another category also in terms of price, so out of the game for now.
Adding the fact that the musiccast control is fully customizable thanks to their API, and summing all aspects above, i made my choice. Time will tell me if i invested my money in a reliabie, reputation, cutting edge engineering product, or if it will be a complete failure.

Just to summarize reasons of my choice in few lines:

Yamaha vs Sonos
- Sound quality (weight 45%): the winner is yamaha (comparison made by myself at the media shop, personal opinion)
- Price (15%): the winner is yamaha (it's a fact)
- Open API to control the system (15%): the winner is yamaha (full api to control every function/device/audio source).
- Wired/Wireless enable/disable option (10%): the winner is yamaha, natively allow to enable disable wired/wireless
- Power consumption (10%): the winner is yamaha (numbers from datasheets, website and forums, few watts, but enough to win)
- System expansion capabilities (3%): winner is Yamaha (personal feeling looking at product portfolio)
- Design (2%): winner, sonos for the play 1, but yamaha wx-030 looks better than play 3. Materials looks good for both vendors (personal opinion)

Aspect with 0% weight that didn't have a role in my decision:
- previous history of products/brand (i would have choosen Sonos just for its reputation, if i didn't start comparing it with others)
- mobile app usability
- reliability (i thrust both to have made a robust product)
- support (just to notice that Yamaha quickly reply to my requests, no answer from sonos that simply ignored me)
- risk that product disappear from the market (unknown at this time)

End of the story...

*BTW, even if it's not a matter of kilowatts, they became kwh considering 2W x number of devices x hours x days x years ( x number of customers...), more if including also 2 watts saved here and there from all other appliances that should stay enabled/suspended 24/7... And, if WOL was implemented, 2 watts saving increase to 3.7W x device x ..... Summing that all you save more than 2W...
Translate
jgatie
Dec 21, 2016 8:57 PM UTC
So you went on and on about power usage, when it was really all about irrational fears of deadly WiFi rays?

Well, I guess that decides it. But I can't leave your analysis as stands, without correcting a glaring error:

Full API: Sonos has recently announced its own full API for not only control by third party Home Automation systems, but also via Alexa voice control. No other system has this. Winner: Sonos

Also, putting 0% of a purchasing decision to the history of a brand, usability, reliability, or whether or not their products have the nasty habit of disappearing from the market belies any logic. Is this trully what you meant to say? If so, it seems the deck was stacked from the start; with all the areas in which Sonos excells conveniently given no weight in the decision. Good luck with your Yamaha.
Translate
Ryan S
Retired Sonos Staff
Dec 21, 2016 9:19 PM UTC
- support (just to notice that Yamaha quickly reply to my requests, no answer from sonos that simply ignored me)

Sounds like you've done a lot of individual analysis which is always a good way to go. We're here if you have any questions but when it comes to some questions we like to let the community answer as we think a community recommendation is the most important thing.

As to the power consumption itself, you've got all the right information so far, so we don't need to correct anything there. We're always looking to improve regarding this, and as already mentioned, the latest products to have come out have our best yet power rating.

Let us know if you have any questions, and if you wind up picking up something else, we really hope you're happy. No matter what, we just want everyone to be able to enjoy their music.
Translate
Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
onesimAuthor
Dec 21, 2016 9:21 PM UTC
No fear about Rf rays, i work with rf each day and probably i've absorbed more radiations than everyone in this forum (now everything is clear, you may say :D:D:D).
Just knowledge about how it works and how inefficient it can be compared to cable/fiber :D
More wireless means more interferences and more probability to have inefficient, unreliable communications. Even if, apparently, you see it working well.
Translate
jgatie
Dec 21, 2016 9:26 PM UTC
No fear about Rf rays, i work with rf each day and probably i've absorbed more radiations than everyone in this forum (now everything is clear, you may say :D:D:D).
Just knowledge about how it works and how inefficient it can be compared to cable/fiber :D
More wireless means more interferences and more probability to have inefficient, unreliable communications. Even if, apparently, you see them working.


My apologies, then. We have had many posts inquiring/complaining about the unsupported option to turn off wireless, and prior to yours they were all from folks who feared WiFi death rays beaming through their homes. Sorry I assumed the worst.

As i said, good luck with your choice.
Translate
onesimAuthor
Dec 21, 2016 9:30 PM UTC
Let us know if you have any questions, and if you wind up picking up something else, we really hope you're happy. No matter what, we just want everyone to be able to enjoy their music.

Finally, the one and only eligible to answer my questions :D

Any plan to redesign play 1 and play 3 to update performances at least as it seems they re on play 5?

What about the idea of WakeOnLan function? Is it really of no interest for the totality of your customers? (assuming that current hw support it and it can be implemented by fw upgrade)
Thanks
Simone
Translate
Ryan S
Retired Sonos Staff
Dec 21, 2016 9:33 PM UTC
No fear about Rf rays, i work with rf each day and probably i've absorbed more radiations than everyone in this forum (now everything is clear, you may say :D:D:D).
Just knowledge about how it works and how inefficient it can be compared to cable/fiber :D
More wireless means more interferences and more probability to have inefficient, unreliable communications. Even if, apparently, you see it working well.


Just a note to add here, though Sonos players are intended to have the wifi on all the time, if a player has a connection to the network through a wired source it'll default to use that to get the audio data. The wireless is still active and available for other devices to connect to it, but the player itself is using the wired connection for the purposes of playing audio. Players use STP to determine the quickest and most direct path to the network and their music sources. A wired path is almost always going to win out for STP.
Translate
Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
onesimAuthor
Dec 21, 2016 10:19 PM UTC

Well, I guess that decides it. But I can't leave your analysis as stands, without correcting a glaring error:

Full API: Sonos has recently announced its own full API for not only control by third party Home Automation systems, but also via Alexa voice control. No other system has this. Winner: Sonos


Ok, that can be a draw when the API will be released.

Also, putting 0% of a purchasing decision to the history of a brand, usability, reliability, or whether or not their products have the nasty habit of disappearing from the market belies any logic. Is this trully what you meant to say? If so, it seems the deck was stacked from the start; with all the areas in which Sonos excells conveniently given no weight in the decision. Good luck with your Yamaha.

I mean that i don't bother the brand, reliability and success because my feeling is that both companies are step ahead on those topics. I do not expect to get low qualities clones from unknown vendor whatever the product is Sonos or Yamaha.

And about other aspects i've weighted in my list, i do not pretend to make them as a bible, just thoughts sometimes confirmed by documented info, sometimes just personal taste. As said, i'm just looking at those kind of products since a couple of weeks, and in any case i'm not an expert with the knowledge/experience to declare a final winner. But i want to have something in my hands soon so i've to choose, and my choice is driven by evaluations derived by discussions in this forum and others forums, reviews, and also device testing at the shop
Translate
jgatie
Dec 21, 2016 11:26 PM UTC
The API is operational as of version 7.0.

As to the other, if I knew that one of the companies I was considering had two previous forays into the market ending up disasterous failures, it wouldn't give me good feelings about their current product, especially compared to the reputation of Sonos. All the tick boxes in the world mean nothing when the company drops the product after a short time. The company history of support, reliability, and viability of their products is far above any one particular feature in my book. But that's just me, other's mileage may vary.
Translate