Skip to main content
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

12 replies

ratty
Jan 29, 2021 10:45 AM UTC
  1. Yes, this will still look weird if allowed, but perhaps Sonos need to be so anal as to not even offer it as an option. Especially so in the case of units like Play 1 and Sonos One, or in the generations of 5 units after the first generation 5. In this case, stereo pairs will not even look weird. If someone wants to exercise the option of stereo pairing a 5 and a 1, let them, they know it looks weird and are presumably fine with that.

The acoustic signatures of Play:1 and One are different. As I understand it, the acoustics of Five were tuned to be similar to Play:5/g2.

However, in both cases the internal computing/networking platforms are quite different. Leaving aside the acoustic aspect there could one day be features which work on the later model but not on the earlier one. This would leave an unmatched stereo pair in a strange position. 

 

Another key point to consider is regression testing before firmware release. If a unit was allowed to pair with anything else then such testing would become an N-squared problem, instead of order N. After a short while it could simply become uneconomic to support every combination.

Translate
Jan 29, 2021 11:12 AM UTC

The acoustic signatures of Play:1 and One are different. 

However, in both cases the internal computing/networking platforms are quite different. Leaving aside the acoustic aspect there could one day be features which work on the later model but not on the earlier one. This would leave an unmatched stereo pair in a strange position. 

 

Another key point to consider is regression testing before firmware release. If a unit was allowed to pair with anything else then such testing would become an N-squared problem, instead of order N. After a short while it could simply become uneconomic to support every combination.

It would be interesting to see the results of the Play 1 and One in a strict DBT in a domestic listening environment to see if they can be picked out.

I have no idea about the nuts and bolts that you refer to of course, except for easily understanding that a unit that cannot play on S2 will not pair with one that does. If the problems are N squared as you say, there is obviously a trade off to be considered from a commercial point of view.

Translate