Skip to main content
Only1jayray
Avid Contributor I
Oct 23, 2017 7:36 PM UTC

Sonos One as rear surround

If I use 2 sonos ones as surround speakers with my playbar can I still use the Alexa function as I could as a stand alone speaker... or should I just use play 1s and my existing echo dot?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

14 replies

Airgetlam
Oct 23, 2017 7:54 PM UTC
Yes, and yes, if you want to save some money, just get an Amazon Echo Dot. Either will work.
Translate
Bruce
Contributor I
Oct 24, 2017 4:24 PM UTC
Hi Guys, I've setup my Sonos Playbar and Sub with two Play One's. In doing so I replaced my Play:1's for the Play:One's. As far as surround goes everything is like it should be. However, Alexa is a different story :(

Using one of the Play One's as a separate speaker with Alexa no problem, works perfectly (except Spotify, but that is a known issue). Pairing my two Play One's as a stereo pair, Alexa is kind of confused when I ask something.

So I unpaired them, removed Alexa from one of the One's and paired them up again and that seemed to do the trick.

However, adding this stereo pair to my Playbar and sub as my surround speakers, Alexa simply will not work. She keeps saying she cannot understand at the moment and I should try later.

Is this a known issue? Or just a misstep on my side? If you guys know, please help ッ

Thanks!

Kind regards,
Jerry
Translate
Airgetlam
Oct 24, 2017 4:55 PM UTC
Jerry,

You've confused me a bit with the various names you've used, but I think you're having problems with a pair of Sonos Ones that you're using as surround speakers, bonded with a PLAYBAR and SUB.

Since I don't yet have a Sonos One (only several Dots), I can't comment on your issue specifically, but I would encourage you to also submit a system diagnostic, and post the number here, for the folks at Sonos to look at. That might help them track down why it doesn't seem to be working while they're surrounds.
Translate
Bruce
Ryan S
Retired Sonos Staff
Oct 24, 2017 6:25 PM UTC
Once you've set up those Sonos Ones as surround speakers, say "Alexa, discover devices." Then try it out. If that's giving you trouble still, disable the Alexa skill for Sonos and add it back.
Translate
Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
Contributor I
Oct 25, 2017 7:43 AM UTC
Ryan S. Thanks for your reply. I have tried that and removing Alexa works fine, but then the option for Alexa is gone in the app for good it seems. Neither in the Sonos app nor in the Alexa app :(

I have asked Sonos online if there is a step by step instruction on how to setup this correctly.

Thanks again.
Translate
Contributor I
Oct 25, 2017 10:10 PM UTC
Why in the world would Sonos require that both speakers need to be One's to pair for rears? It makes no sense to have to replace both your rears with Alexa speakers? Why would you need two Alexa capable speakers 15ft from each other? I had existing Play 1's as rears and than purchased a new ONE to hopefully be able to swap a Play 1 out so i could add Alexa into the bunch only to find out this can't be done. I feel like this is crazy and wonder why this wasn't thought of before. They need to fix this or else you are just buying an Alexa with a Sonos sticker on it. Am I crazy? Or are they working on this?
Translate
Oct 25, 2017 10:25 PM UTC
They are different speakers. The One is not a Play:1 with Alexa. You have the option of buying a Dot
Translate
Lyricist I
Dec 26, 2017 10:42 PM UTC
They need to fix this or else you are just buying an Alexa with a Sonos sticker on it. Am I crazy? Or are they working on this? I came here with the same issue. I have 8 Sonos speakers and want an Alexa in the living room. Thought for sure I can swap one of my Play:1's for a ONE seamlessly. Unbelievable!
Translate
Contributor II
Oct 10, 2018 9:45 AM UTC
Hi guys. Did anyone have any luck with this? I currently have two Sonos Play:1's as surrounds. I'd like to replace one of them with a Sonos One so I can have Alexa in the living room, so my surrounds would then consist of a Sonos Play:1 and a Sonos One. Is this possible?
Translate
Oct 10, 2018 11:17 AM UTC
Hi guys. Did anyone have any luck with this? I currently have two Sonos Play:1's as surrounds. I'd like to replace one of them with a Sonos One so I can have Alexa in the living room, so my surrounds would then consist of a Sonos Play:1 and a Sonos One. Is this possible?Only with a third party app. But just buy an Echo Dot to add Alexa.
Translate