Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
May 31, 2018 3:57 AM UTC

Sonos Grandfather or Hardware Trade-in Programs

Back in April, Sonos sent out its official AirPlay 2 support e-mail. I headed straight to the blog post to confirm the rumors about having to buy new speakers to get what I've wanted since I purchased my $2,000 Sonos theater sound system less than 2 years ago (PlayBar, Sub, & set of Play:1s). Alas, it was true. After contacting Sonos support, I learned I can't simply replace one of my Play:1s with a Sonos One—surround sound won't work properly—cha-ching, another $400 in less than 2 years of buying a $2000 sound system!

Now, I understand the need for new hardware to support AirPlay 2, however, Sonos has missed the boat for an existing customer appreciation hardware upgrade program. As a former Product Marketing Manager for a technology company, I've dealt with with both software and hardware upgrade issues for existing customers. And, obviously, it's much less costly to upgrade software. However, since my days in Product Marketing, hardware manufacturing methods have continued to improve which has led to significantly lower manufacturing costs. To that end, if Sonos really wants to "Value" its customer base, then how about one of two hardware upgrade programs:

• A Grandfather Hardware Discount Program: Those Sonos customers who purchased a complete theater sound system with a minimum purchase of a PlayBar, Sub, and a set of Play:1s within 2 years of the release of the Sonos One speakers get a 20 - 30% discount on the purchase of a new set of Sonos One speakers. This discount has to be a "REAL" discount. The typical 10% discounts don't get anyone's heart started nowadays.

• A Hardware Trade-In Program: Sonos offers Sonos Ones at a 40% - 50% discount with the trade-in of an existing set of Play:1s. And, to make it easy for those customer who may have discarded their Play:1 boxes, they can return their existing Play:1s in the Sonos One boxes—they seem to be very similar in size. This is a win-win because existing customers get a much more gently priced set of Sonos One's and Sonos can sell the used Play:1s as refurbs.

I was planning on purchasing another Sonos theater sound system for my master bedroom, however, unless Sonos really reaches out with a hardware upgrade program like on of those I just detailed, I will be buying a different brand from now on.
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

45 replies

May 31, 2018 6:22 PM UTC
Sonos could not afford to pay what people can get on eBay. What happens to the trade ins by the way? Landfill?
Translate
May 31, 2018 6:25 PM UTC
Or maybe Sonos could put them on eBay?
Translate
Stuart_W
World-Class Superstar
May 31, 2018 6:33 PM UTC
Have I stepped into a parallel universe?

I used to think that the complaints that Millennials were entitled was nonsense but then this sort of thread comes along.

And as John B says what does the OP expect Sonos to do with the replaced units?

I'm simply not buying it. I've had the same "issues" with buying tech gear over the years. You do your research and close in on your chosen product. You find during that search rumours of said product being updated or replaced with a unit which has a dilithium drive. You don't want or even need that but suddenly you covet the dilithium drive version. So you wait. And you wait. Before you know it you'e had six months without the thing your really wanted/needed half a year ago for the want of a feature you don't needed nor even wanted. And I have been there where I bought a TV, PVR, camera and a few months later a new version came out that was "better". Until it came out I was that happy pig rolling in mud. Bt now, now I'm a really unhappy bunny because my PVR doesn't put recordings in a folder! No, that didn't happen. I just shrugged and cried on enjoying my product.
Translate
Arc + Sub (Gen 1) + 2 x Play 1/ Stereo Play 3s/ Era 100 Stereo in Kitchen, One Stereo in Bedroom, Play 1 stereo pair in Study, Play 1in Bathroom, Sonos Move 2
May 31, 2018 6:38 PM UTC
The gaping hole in this suggestion is that it hugely overstates the economic value of Airplay to the average Sonos user (which in my case is very close to zero). If we cared about Airplay we wouldn't have bought Sonos in the first place. For many of us the same is true of voice control - although that can be added with a Dot anyway.
Translate
melvimbe
May 31, 2018 6:39 PM UTC
jgatie: As hard as it is for you to believe, I was told by a Sonos technical rep back in 2016 that Airplay support would be coming, but he couldn't provide a timeframe. Also, did I state anywhere in my post that I wanted a refund? Nope! How about actually reading posts in detail before you make a reply. In full disclosure, I really want to keep my Play:1s and install them on my pool porch and simply replace them with Ones in my theater setup—while having AirPlay 2 support. I've been told by Sonos that will work. However, another poster on this forum does not believe that will work, so here we go again. I'm simply stating that if Sonos really wanted to show they truly value its customer base, they could've offered some type of decent discount program back in October when they released the Sonos Ones.

Maybe it's just me, but I don't think trying to get information about upcoming products and features from the tech support is the best way to go. Technically, they represent the company, but there main job is to solve customer issues, not make official announcements. No offense to anyone who does tech support like that, but I'm not basing my purchasing decisions on your word alone. Besides, Sonos is pretty good about making announcement when they are comfortable with making information official.

In regards to starting a discount program back in October, I'm not following your logic here. Sonos didn't know back then what speakers were going to work with it what were not. I could be wrong, but I don't think even Apple knew what the required specs were going to be. In a way, they did offer a discount program because the price on the play:1 dropped $50 soon after the Sonos One was released, but that wasn't because of airplay 2.

Maybe it's just me, but I always thought that the initial Sonos announcement was about a contractual agreement between Sonos and Apple then any kind of statement about what the final function and features would be.
Translate
Danny
Sonosjunkie
Prodigy III
May 31, 2018 6:42 PM UTC
Ok people, let me provide this clarification—could not edit my post after I submitted it (many forums offer this, but this one does not). I did quite a bit of research prior to my purchasing my Sonos sound system. In addition, I contacted Sonos support and asked about AirPlay suppprt (not AirPlay 2 because it was still an unknown) and was told it would be coming (that was in July of 2016). I also asked about HDMI supporting surround sound (Cable TV box HDMI connection to TV—using optical out from TV to PlayBar). To that end, I did my homework, but was misled into believing the system I wanted to purchase would support AirPlay, but that support never came.

So, Mr. BMW: if u were told by BMW the car you were going to buy for your wife would later have CarPlay support with just a simple firmwate update and that update never came, you would've been a quite disappointed when full CarPlay support was available in next year's mode only.


If Sonos in some ‘official’ capacity stated specifically that the system you were purchasing would support Airplay then I can understand your frustration. If you have wvidence of that then I’d expect you have solid grounds for a claim. I purchased the exact same setup PB+Sub+2xP1s less than three months ago, I was hoping for Airplay 2, but knew about the potential limitations so figured it would be a nice to have, I’m not expecting a fefund. Ironically had I purchased from directly from sonos I could have sent them back. But I did not recall any firm commitments for any of those devices to receive Airlay2. I’ve added an AppleTv which can act as a bridge to Airplay for the legacy kit so not too bothered. I’m more interested in the new HDMI device and await the 6th with some hope. Tech moves on. Carplay is not all that either so I’m not that fussed either way 🆒
Translate
Lounge: 5.1 Arc HT (2x Subs and 2xP5 rears) with LGOLED77CX. Kitchen: 2xOneW, 2xP3w with SubW. Bedroom: 2xP1s. Office/Studio: 2xP5w. Snug 2xP1s. Garage: 2xOneW. Also 3x Moves.
jgatie
May 31, 2018 6:53 PM UTC
Nope. Still not buying it.
Translate
Chris
Lead Maestro
May 31, 2018 6:56 PM UTC
I can’t believe A Sonos phine rep in 2016 said airplay was coming. A Best Buy rep yes. But if it happened that person didn’t have a clue what they were talking about. If you really need airplay I would install one of the server side work arounds to make all airplay enabled.

Regarding surrounds. We have long had suspicion that pairing a non-capable and capable may be an issue. Look at how Sonos was firmly planted on not pairing Sonos One and Play:1. They may have know at that time pairing the 2 would loose future stuff from working (like in this case airplay).
Translate
Respect the Queue (2)Move (3)Beam (1) Era100 (2)ARC (1)SonosOne (1)Playbar (4)Play5 (4)Play1 (3)Play3 (1)Port (2)Connect (1) Roam (2) Ace (1)Connect:Amp (4)Sonos Amp (1)Sub + (9) Echo + Smartthings; (2)Play)
Sonosjunkie
Prodigy III
May 31, 2018 6:56 PM UTC
Nope. Still not buying it.

He’s already bought it. I think it was a discount that was being saught for an upgrade 😉
Translate
Lounge: 5.1 Arc HT (2x Subs and 2xP5 rears) with LGOLED77CX. Kitchen: 2xOneW, 2xP3w with SubW. Bedroom: 2xP1s. Office/Studio: 2xP5w. Snug 2xP1s. Garage: 2xOneW. Also 3x Moves.
Ken_Griffiths
May 31, 2018 6:58 PM UTC
Baseman1968: where did you hear about the One speakers may not have AirPlay 2 support when set as rear speakers? I had 2 very lengthy conversations with 2 separate Sonos technical reps and was told this would support it. I figured I double my Sonos conversations this time so I wasn't misled a second time.
I didn't hear it. But I know that you can't use the rear speakers to create a Sonos net, because they are connected to the PLAYBAR via a 5 GHz net. Therefore I don't see AirPlay working like that.

Actually this conversation above has had me thinking, as I have always thought you can't (easily) group bonded speakers unless you decouple them first.

The Sonos blog announcement only talks about sharing/grouping the three specified Sonos AirPlay devices with their older legacy speakers, like a Play-3 for example, via grouping, but how do you group a Sonos One that is already bonded to a PlayBar?

The announcement seems to say (by omission) that the PlayBar is not AirPlay compatible, so I guess that means the Sonos One will need to be decoupled first and then grouped for AirPlay purposes.

Perhaps I'm just not reading these two 'official' documents correctly?

https://www.sonos.com/en-gb/airplay

https://blog.sonos.com/en-gb/airplay2-coming
Translate