This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Im pretty sure Amazon isn't going to allow a subset of their features to permeate to third party developers. After all, they are selling speakers. They aren't going to allow calling, intercom, etc., features on the PlayOne unless they pay for it. The branding of Alexa on Sonos is deceiving because its not the same feature set as on Amazon devices. Alexa has more functionality on Amazon devices. Like, "lights ons..." only turns on the lights associated with the Echo. But the same goes for the Ecobee switches and thermostats, they have Alexa but its the subset, which for me is pretty useless. More third party developers should complain to Amazon and get a full feature Alexa, since they are essentially marketing for Amazon for free on their boxes.
How come it seems the people that say they I have no issues don't understand the problem? You are familiar with grouping devices to an echo right? So if I say lights out in the bed room, it only shuts off those lights. If I go to the living room and say lights out, it just turns those off. If you say that to Sonos One, it CANT do that. Thats what I mean by feature set. Yes I understand I can say to Sonos One, Alexa turn off living room lights. Thats not a solution to simplicity, thats just having to utter more syllables. Again, the feature set like, call John, you can't do that on Sonos One. You can't say to Sonos One, drop in on Frank, theres actually quite a few features you cant do with Sonos One even though its Alexa enabled.
In all seriousness, you can pretty much get rid off all these problem and complaints if they just added bluetooth to their NEW speakers. Then you can just pair the echo to the bluetooth and voila, Alexa plays and does everything the way it should would thru some decent speakers.
Again, you are commenting without really knowing the issues. If you dont want bluetooth, you don't have to use it. That's pretty much a common statement with the Sonos cheerleaders, if you dont want it ducking then disable the skill.
If they actually shipped with bluetooth, then they wouldn't have a problem interfacing google home or alexa. It would just work with all smart home assistants, but hey...that would be too easy and who wants that?
Sonos should do what they are good at, building good wireless speakers, not turning itself into a software company.
If most people who buy Sonos wanted Bluetooth they would buy a Bluetooth speaker.
How about doing it the right way and have skills that do it properly. Ducking will be resolved. And I assume your saying the Sonos One can’t be added to a smart group. So are you being helpful or not in confirming it can or can not be added smartgroup?
I know what your saying but you just want to now be rude. I wouldn’t want Alexa voice coming through my Sonos speakers in house so would never want them to operate as a Bluetooth extension of Alexa. Defeats completely what I would want from my smarthome integration.
Sonos - no matter what smart guy thinks I do not want you to focus on anything bluetooth in your speakers. Which they don’t have or care to have so mute point.
If you can’t add Sonos One to smartgroup as I guess his guy has tested -then yes please Sonos add this in next update with ducking fix.
And last I saw you didn’t originate this thread and it doesnt belong to you as your personal pet thread so I will comment all I care to comment. Last I noticed it was on open forum.
'Without turning itself into a software company'? Its multiroom firmware / software is what makes Sonos what it is and always has done. In its earliest years it didn't even make speakers.
Please God it will continue its deliberate rejection of Bluetooth
Wow, First I never said it was my pet thread. Second, I never said this was a closed forum. Third, whats the problem with bluetooth? I didn't say get rid of wifi mesh networking and the way it currently works. I'm saying add bluetooth, then guests can come with their music, bluetooth it to a speaker, then it can be multi-roomed, like it does with its line input on the play 5s. If you don't want a home assistant on your speakers then don't pair it. Personally, I would rather have one speaker than a multiples. Right now I have an Echo Dot next to a Google Home next to my Sonos Play 5. The assistant speakers sound like crap compared to Play5. Its unbelievable how suggestions are immediately rejected by people that don't understand the technology. And, yes I do this also because I bought an adapter....