Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jan 15, 2017 12:03 PM UTC

Play 1 sound quality

Have just invested in a Sonos set up for the first time, and took the plunge with a pair of Play 1's, figuring that every single review without exception said they sounded fantastic. I'm slight underwhelmed to be honest. They're on wall brackets about 8 foot apart, have run Trueplay & the sound quality is not blowing me away. Listening to radio stations on tune in does sound pretty damn good, but streaming spotify/Google play music, it sounds a bit flat and undynamic. Anything with a bit of complexity, there is no detail, the bass is a dull thud and it all sounds a bit muddled.

I did so much research before buying and reviewers and consumers alike rave about the crystal clear sound and finding details they've never heard before etc. Am not finding any of that. I'm far from an audiophile, I just like clear dynamic sounds from my system

Any thoughts? Run trueplay again?
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    29 replies

    Contributor I
    Jan 16, 2017 11:40 AM UTC
    It's all subjective isn't it? I guess what I'm missing is the 'crunch' of well recorded rock/metal. An example is the new album by Gojira - extremely well recorded and clear, but sounded muddy on Sonos. But having said that, was listening to another metal album and it sounded fantastic, even Mrs Ninja was nodding her head when she came in & she's not a metal fan. Think I need to experiment more. Volume is definitely a factor as well - can't decide if quiet = best or not
    Translate
    Jan 16, 2017 1:28 PM UTC

    I'm always interested in hearing the results of double blind ABX testing... Subjective opinion is - well, just that...

    Point me to even one for speakers; where each speaker pair being compared was placed in exactly the same place, sound levels matched by instruments, switchover between one and the other was close to instantaneous and the exact same recordings were played.

    Last I heard was that Harmon Kardon has a mechanised set up that moves speakers around to do just this, in their anechoic chamber, for new speaker development. But I haven't seen a single reported blind ABX test for speakers by any one so far.
    Translate
    Jan 16, 2017 5:14 PM UTC
    Point me to even one for speakers; where each speaker pair being compared was placed in exactly the same place, sound levels matched by instruments, switchover between one and the other was close to instantaneous and the exact same recordings were played.

    That's rather my point - there is no science whatsoever to back up your over the top claims for the Sonos kit, merely subjective opinion... which we all know is very, very flawed...
    Translate
    Jan 16, 2017 5:18 PM UTC
    ....extremely well recorded and clear, but sounded muddy on Sonos. But having said that, was listening to another metal album and it sounded fantastic...

    If the Sonos kit sounds fantastic on some tracks, it implies that there's nothing much wrong with the Sonos kit itself...

    As you say, more experimentation required 😃
    Translate
    Contributor I
    Jan 16, 2017 6:28 PM UTC
    Well home from work & listening to the soundtrack to Hell or High Water on spotify. It's mainly mellow country/blues & it sounds excellent. Warm sound, but the subtleties in the music come through. Go figure 😃
    Translate
    Jan 17, 2017 12:39 AM UTC
    there is no science whatsoever to back up your over the top claims for the Sonos kit, merely subjective opinion... which we all know is very, very flawed...
    As of course is yours; equally subjective and equally flawed being subject to all the known psychological biases that afflict you if you are a human being.

    That said, check the Butterworth FQ response measurements of the 1 unit that contain some science, however imperfect you may think that to be.

    Bottom line: those that like the way well set up Sonos kit sounds are happy to move on to the listening to all the music it provides access to, along with the convenience of use that is a huge bonus. And some that do have a subjective good opinion of its sound quality that is based on many years of listening to high end, hifi stereo kit from different brands that runs to much larger budgets than Sonos kit; among others, I am also fully satisfied that paying higher amounts for "HiFi" brands is no assurance of better sound, and can often be the opposite.
    Translate
    Jan 17, 2017 2:06 AM UTC
    Go figure :D
    Recording/mastering quality is the source - pardon the pun - of these differences. Reinforced by your earlier statement that some metal tracks also come across well rendered by the unit.
    Translate
    Jan 17, 2017 6:34 PM UTC
    And some that do have a subjective good opinion of its sound quality that is based on many years of listening to high end, hifi stereo kit from different brands that runs to much larger budgets than Sonos kit...

    Same old talk, still no evidence....
    Translate
    Jan 18, 2017 12:10 AM UTC

    Same old talk, still no evidence....

    LOL. Ditto.
    Translate