Skip to main content
Enthusiast II
Sep 14, 2018 5:54 PM UTC

Planned Obsolescence

Should we be concerned? I think we should be.

Yesterday owners of the Sonos Dock were emailed telling them that from October onwards, with their next software update, that the Dock will no longer be supported and made obsolete and no longer work within the Sonos system. Earlier in the year owners of the CR-100 controller were also told that their controller would no longer be supported and no longer work. Two Sonos products in less than a year have been made obsolete. Let me repeat that, in less than a year 2 Sonos components have been planned by Sonos to be made obsolete. You can understand if the product failed due to its age but a software update planned and intended to make the components obsolete is quite worrying. And where does that leave Sonos owners who were earlier adopters of the technology? And where does that leave all Sonos owners?

Yesterday The "Sonos Support Team" tweeted that "Supporting the Dock within the modern Sonos system is no longer sustainable due to the age of the Dock's technology." Let's think about that for a second ...

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the first gen Play 5 was released as the zp120 before the Dock, so when will Sonos announce that it is no longer sustainable due to the age of its technology? And what about the Connect and the Connect Amp, both released earlier than the Dock, surely their lifespan, due to their age, will come around too? What technology separates both the Connects and the first gen Play5 from the Sonos dock that makes them future proof? We have all become accustomed to the disgusting planned obsolescence from technology companies (and I can say that as Sonos have planned to make the Dock obsolete from October onwards) in the vain hope to sell you the product again, but this is the first time a speaker company has adopted it which makes me very fearful indeed. I've suddenly become disillusioned for the future of the Sonos products that I have purchased off them in good faith because in all likelihood, I fear, it is only a matter of time before Sonos emails me to tell me that what I have is old technology and will no longer be supported and no longer work but I can always buy the new incarnation.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    22 replies

    ChasBadsAuthor
    Enthusiast II
    Sep 15, 2018 1:24 PM UTC
    Silly me, isn't that a USB port on the new Sonos Amp, just for you, 600 dollars or pounds to enable us to do what we can do today and not tomorrow, I rest my case
    Translate
    jgatie
    Sep 15, 2018 1:30 PM UTC
    Sigh. That's HDMI.

    Nice try though. :8
    Translate
    ChasBadsAuthor
    Enthusiast II
    Sep 15, 2018 1:33 PM UTC
    Ok, sorry, retracted
    Translate
    melvimbe
    Sep 15, 2018 1:34 PM UTC
    Ok, it is not planned obsolescence, but it is planned software to obsolete a component with their next software update to make that component unusable, happy now, the conclusion is the same.

    Conclusion is the same, but the motivation is not. Actually, the conclusion isn't exactly the same because bricking the dock doesn't result in motivating customers to go buy more Sonos products which planned obsolescence does.


    This is not rocket science, it just plays music, what innovation is there to be gained? If they offered a unit with bluetooth connectivity or some other wireless connectivity I could understand, hey wait, I imagine that will be the next release, so buy it.


    Your made up scenario has no relevance. Sonos has never done such an act in their entire history, and there is no reason to believe that's their plan now. The CR100 had no replacement that Sonos could sell you. The alternative controller is android or iOS apps, both of which are free. You could possibly make an argument that Sonos could gain sales in devices with aux input by bricking the dock, but they also provide the free option to play music tracks directly from your android, iOS device, or other local library. So getting an aux input isn't at all necessary.

    As well, if you had a replacement product you wanted to sell, why would you not even announce the product before you brick the dock? It would make much more sense to release the product at least 6 months in advance to allow customers the opportunity to switch over without leaving them with no functionality for a period of time. And Bluetooth? Sonos has avoided it for many years now, hard to see them switch now. Besides, it would not satisfy many of the ipod customers since most (all?) ipods don't support Bluetooth.

    Like others above said, whether Sonos is making the right decision from a moral or business point of view is one thing. I don't think it's fair to assume motivations by Sonos that don't fit the facts.
    Translate
    Danny
    ChasBadsAuthor
    Enthusiast II
    Sep 15, 2018 1:43 PM UTC
    Well morally wrong to brick a purchased item after just 8 years that is for sure and business point of view too, now disillusioned with the system if they can brick whatever they choose to whenever they want.
    Translate
    Lyricist I
    Sep 15, 2018 8:34 PM UTC
    Speaking for our family, loosing the play function of the DOCK is going to be really annoying. We still operate older APPLE products daily in our exercise room. Reaching for an IOS, ANDROID, or firing up a PC is not what we want to do.

    Being that I am the guy responsible for household IT and the related, I am not really interested in moving equipment close enough to connect by wire. I'm quite certain that my better half is not going to go for it either.

    I am also having a difficult time understanding exactly how maintaining functionality of the DOCK will keep SONOS from future innovation.

    If I had a vote, it would be a big NO on this update.

    Respectfully,
    Translate
    ChasBadsAuthor
    Enthusiast II
    Sep 16, 2018 11:04 PM UTC
    Actually a question to Ryan S after fears created by the recent announcement after Sonos have retired 2 devices this year already, but how long will it be that my Sonos Connect and my four first gen Play:5's will no longer be supported by Sonos, please reassure me because I think Sonos need to after their behaviour this year.
    Translate
    MikeV
    Sep 17, 2018 12:55 AM UTC
    The ZP100, which is the predecessor of both the Connect AND Connect:Amp (it had both line-level and amplified outputs) is still functional as a Sonos device, and I'd expect a device that old to be removed from service well before a product that is still being sold today.
    Translate
    The S in IOT stands for Security.
    Trending Lyricist I
    Dec 20, 2018 11:37 PM UTC
    Should we be concerned? I think we should be.

    Yesterday owners of the Sonos Dock were emailed telling them that from October onwards, with their next software update, that the Dock will no longer be supported and made obsolete and no longer work within the Sonos system. Earlier in the year owners of the CR-100 controller were also told that their controller would no longer be supported and no longer work. Two Sonos products in less than a year have been made obsolete. Let me repeat that, in less than a year 2 Sonos components have been planned by Sonos to be made obsolete. You can understand if the product failed due to its age but a software update planned and intended to make the components obsolete is quite worrying. And where does that leave Sonos owners who were earlier adopters of the technology? And where does that leave all Sonos owners?

    Yesterday The "Sonos Support Team" tweeted that "Supporting the Dock within the modern Sonos system is no longer sustainable due to the age of the Dock's technology." Let's think about that for a second ...

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but the first gen Play 5 was released as the zp120 before the Dock, so when will Sonos announce that it is no longer sustainable due to the age of its technology? And what about the Connect and the Connect Amp, both released earlier than the Dock, surely their lifespan, due to their age, will come around too? What technology separates both the Connects and the first gen Play5 from the Sonos dock that makes them future proof? We have all become accustomed to the disgusting planned obsolescence from technology companies (and I can say that as Sonos have planned to make the Dock obsolete from October onwards) in the vain hope to sell you the product again, but this is the first time a speaker company has adopted it which makes me very fearful indeed. I've suddenly become disillusioned for the future of the Sonos products that I have purchased off them in good faith because in all likelihood, I fear, it is only a matter of time before Sonos emails me to tell me that what I have is old technology and will no longer be supported and no longer work but I can always buy the new incarnation.
    Translate
    Trending Lyricist I
    Dec 20, 2018 11:48 PM UTC
    I've had Sonos Connects for two of my 4 stereo systems at home for the better part of 7 years.

    Obsoleting equipment is so typical of Sonos. I had them obsolete the Controller, which still works better than a "mobile device," because it is dedicated. Now Sonos will only support Apple and Android mobile devices and appear to be phasing out their desktop application. Also, they have no plans for improving quality and upping the bitrates either.

    The Sonos strategic marketing plan is to appeal to the masses, which is a great strategy for making money. Unfortunately improve quality of sound or widen accessibility is not part of that plan for Sonos. The scope of Sonos products is appealing to a narrower and more sustainable segment for Sonos. Again it is good for Sonos, but not always good for the current user base. I read that as change to tolerate the lowering of the bar or . . . leave.

    Leaving is my solution. A better immediate solution is Bluesound. https://www.bluesound.com/
    I will continue to search.:D
    Translate