Skip to main content
Contributor II
August 5, 2018

Is Sonos a Speaker company or a music streaming serivce?

Is Sonos a Speaker company or a music streaming service?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

19 replies

August 7, 2018
Lol. Between troubleshooting posts and those of this type, the forum is getting dull.
Contributor II
August 7, 2018
Other than that it is not a streaming services provider, why does this matter?

Because the OP wanted to stir things up with an oft cited (and even more oft shot down) conspiracy theory that Sonos somehow makes money from streaming services instead of from selling hardware.

*Yawn*

Just another day on the Sonos forum.
I'm really not trying to breathe life into any conspiracy theories. I haven't been a member of this forum long enough to be party to any of that. I was merely asking a question because I have suddenly been unable to access music stored on my PC hard drive in track order as recorded on the CD, only alphabetically. If i use Google Play i can access the the music in track order and can also cast the music to the Sonos speakers in track order.
Contributor II
August 7, 2018
a)It's a speaker company that uses WiFi to stream music to its speakers, the source of which can be locally stored media or that provided by online streaming services.

b)Or it's a WiFi household streaming service that can only be listened to by the speakers it sells.

a) sounds more authentic to what it sells.
Thanks. I'm having trouble with the "locally stored media" portion. It seems both the Sonos Android and PC apps will list and play locally stored music in alphabetical and not track order. If I use Google Play as the source the music is listed and plays in track order not alphabetically. I can also cast the music directly to the speakers from Google play and they will be in track order. Have you ever experienced anything like this? (Also, if I create a playlist from the music stored on my PC they will play in the order I created them)
ratty
August 7, 2018
It seems both the Sonos Android and PC apps will list and play locally stored music in alphabetical and not track order.
An acknowledged bug. Some reports suggest it could be limited to WMA files. Others correlated the problem with the use of track number tags of the form "number/total", e.g. "02/11".
jgatie
August 7, 2018
I'm really not trying to breathe life into any conspiracy theories. I haven't been a member of this forum long enough to be party to any of that. I was merely asking a question because I have suddenly been unable to access music stored on my PC hard drive in track order as recorded on the CD, only alphabetically. If i use Google Play i can access the the music in track order and can also cast the music to the Sonos speakers in track order.

Well then maybe you should have stated that in the OP, instead of the vaguely accusatory contents of your post and title.
Contributor II
August 7, 2018
I'm really not trying to breathe life into any conspiracy theories. I haven't been a member of this forum long enough to be party to any of that. I was merely asking a question because I have suddenly been unable to access music stored on my PC hard drive in track order as recorded on the CD, only alphabetically. If i use Google Play i can access the the music in track order and can also cast the music to the Sonos speakers in track order.

Well then maybe you should have stated that in the OP, instead of the vaguely accusatory contents of your post and title.
I received a nice email from Sonos Customer Care re: case #00160822 that suggested, among other things that I submit a diagnostic on my system. I did that, to no avail, and it was further suggested I reach out to members in this forum. My question was an earnest attempt to understand the problem I'm having. If you perceived it as "vaugely accusatory" I'm not sure there's anything I can or should do about that.
Contributor II
August 7, 2018
It seems both the Sonos Android and PC apps will list and play locally stored music in alphabetical and not track order.
An acknowledged bug. Some reports suggest it could be limited to WMA files. Others correlated the problem with the use of track number tags of the form "number/total", e.g. "02/11".
Thanks. I noted and passed on to Sonos that I did find at least three CDs recorded in MP3 format that were unaffected by this. Somewhat perplexing but thanks for your input.
melvimbe
August 7, 2018
My question was an earnest attempt to understand the problem I'm having. If you perceived it as "vaugely accusatory" I'm not sure there's anything I can or should do about that.

Yours is the first post I've read where the poster was seeking the answer to a problem by means of asking a completely unrelated question.
Danny
jgatie
August 7, 2018

I received a nice email from Sonos Customer Care re: case #00160822 that suggested, among other things that I submit a diagnostic on my system. I did that, to no avail, and it was further suggested I reach out to members in this forum. My question was an earnest attempt to understand the problem I'm having. If you perceived it as "vaugely accusatory" I'm not sure there's anything I can or should do about that.


You are having a very specific problem with the listings of your local library, you ask "Is Sonos a Speaker company or a music streaming service?" in order to get help with that very specific problem, and you are surprised people find it vague and accusatory? Really?

Also, now that we know your problem, does your question not imply/accuse that Sonos was once one thing (a speaker company) and may now be another (a streaming company), with an assumed assertion that your problem (local library bug) has been ignored because Sonos concentrates more on streaming than it does on local libraries? Otherwise, what exactly do music streaming services have to do with your specific problem?

So c'mon man, you really weren't that vague. We all got the inference, at least admit that's what it was.

PS - If you did not relay the reference # of your diagnostic, Sonos has no way of connecting it to you. If you didn't, submit another and post it here.