Skip to main content
Prodigy I
Dec 21, 2010 9:58 PM UTC

Intermittent bass from S5

Occasionally one of my S5's loses all bass reponse - it sounds like an old tinny transistor radio! It's not the equalization settings (according to my contraller at least) - bass is still showing set at midpoint, and moving it either way changes nothing. And it's not the source - same source linked to another S5 at the same time sounds normal.

But what I found does fix the problem is whacking the volume up and down quickly a few times - it seems to kick the bass back in.

I'm thinking it's probably a hardware fault. But is there anyhting else I should check before contacting Sonos support? (don't want to add to their workload unnecessarily over Christmas!)
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

124 replies

Avid Contributor I
Mar 13, 2013 2:16 PM UTC
I was still thinking about getting one of these but it's very disappointing to see that the problem is still happening. I don't think I want to pay this much money for a product that might not even last 2 years.
Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Mar 13, 2013 3:16 PM UTC
JohnG,

There are a hand full of reports on this thread. We don't know what fraction of the PLAY:5 population this represents. For all we know this could be the entire population of failed units. In that context this is an excellent track record. Out of tens, probably hundreds of thousands of units sold, the above units might be the only failures. Further, all of these failed units could be from the same batch, a production correction has been made, and this issue does not effect current new stock.

I have PLAY:5's at home, in the office, and in my "circle". None of these units have failed. Many of these units are from very early production. If there is a time bomb in "all" units, one would expect that I should have seen an explosion by now.
Translate
Avid Contributor I
Mar 13, 2013 3:30 PM UTC
JohnG,

There are a hand full of reports on this thread. We don't know what fraction of the PLAY:5 population this represents. For all we know this could be the entire population of failed units. In that context this is an excellent track record. Out of tens, probably hundreds of thousands of units sold, the above units might be the only failures. Further, all of these failed units could be from the same batch, a production correction has been made, and this issue does not effect current new stock.

I have PLAY:5's at home, in the office, and in my "circle". None of these units have failed. Many of these units are from very early production. If there is a time bomb in "all" units, one would expect that I should have seen an explosion by now.


I take your point but on the other hand there could be many people out there using defective units and totally unaware that they're affected.
Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Mar 13, 2013 5:52 PM UTC
JohnG,

The true mettle of a company shows when they react to problems. I know a company (not SONOS) that had an almost 100% failure rate of a certain model in the 2-4 year age range. The company took care of their customers and most were happy to buy more of that manufacturer's product. I think that you'll find that SONOS takes care of their customers.

Personally, I assume the best when I purchase a product and I have amazingly good luck. I have friends who assume the worst and they have amazingly bad luck. Manifest what you want.
Translate
Lyricist II
Mar 13, 2013 6:46 PM UTC
JohnG,

The true mettle of a company shows when they react to problems. I know a company (not SONOS) that had an almost 100% failure rate of a certain model in the 2-4 year age range. The company took care of their customers and most were happy to buy more of that manufacturer's product. I think that you'll find that SONOS takes care of their customers.

Personally, I assume the best when I purchase a product and I have amazingly good luck. I have friends who assume the worst and they have amazingly bad luck. Manifest what you want.


It is this that makes me think that Sonos should do the same for Play:5 that have this issue. As the timeframe for failure appears to be fairly wide, some devices fail in warranty and some do not. If the fault was wear and tear then obviously the warranty period is applicable but this problem does not appear to be that.
Translate
Avid Contributor I
Mar 14, 2013 7:19 AM UTC
Further, all of these failed units could be from the same batch, a production correction has been made, and this issue does not effect current new stock.

Going from the excuses that the official line had about the CR200 fiasco only being from a limited batch I really don't think I can believe something like this.

The problem for me is that Sonos never comment and try to reassure people that they've changed something in a product to prevent this from happening again. The total silence from them smacks of arrogance to me 😞
Translate
Avid Contributor I
Mar 19, 2013 9:02 AM UTC
Just want to add to this thread - lost bass on my S5 again. This time it is a refurbished unit that I purchased (€150 + shipping I think) as part of a RMA exchange back in October 2012.

These units have been used in a normal office environment and offices are not known for die-hard partying or loud music so I don't fell I have abused it by playing loud music for hours and hours.

Very disappointed to say the least.
/Mattias

Support incidents logged for reference:
111227-000288, 120417-000605, 120927-000014, 130319-000131
Translate
Contributor I
Mar 26, 2013 4:24 PM UTC
Hi all,

I love SONOS equipment, but my white S5 has just started with intermittent bass, so searching on the Internet, I came across this thread on the SONOS site.

I never play my S5 at high volume (higher than 50%) and it has never been moved.

I have just been reading the various discussions to learn that this is not a minor issue. I will contact SONOS Support, but I suspect that I will have to buy a new one or look at alternate equipment.

This is a real shame and seriously dents my confidence in the product.

My Onyx Hi-Fi amplifier, Technics CD player and Yamaha radio receiver, which I bought 20 years ago all still work perfectly, but my SONOS S5 has a problem after just 2.5 years. I now wonder how good all my other SONOS bits of kit actually are.

I will let you know what happens with SONOS Support.
Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Mar 27, 2013 10:58 AM UTC
Davedsl,

I can point to a certain YAMAHA model that often failed in the first few weeks (sometimes on day one), was repaired, failed again in a different way, and quite often failed a third time in a still different way. It took a few months to track down the root cause. Once the root cause was fixed, the unit was good for 15-20 years. A production change prevented the issue for newly manufactured units. This issue did not bring down the company and I suspect that most of those customers have purchased additional YAMAHA products.
Translate
Avid Contributor I
Mar 27, 2013 11:53 AM UTC
How can we be sure that a production change has occurred in the case of Sonos? There are people with much newer units than the latest person to post who have got the problem too.
Translate