Skip to main content
Contributor I
Feb 28, 2018 3:56 PM UTC

HomePod vs Play 5

I’ve given up waiting for Audible support as after a few years it seems increasingly unlikely it will ever arrive. This isn’t a rant about that, there’s plenty of existing threads on the topic. So sadly...

I’m thinking of ebay’ing my Sonos One and Play 5 and instead getting a couple of HomePods. Has anyone with a Play 5 had the opportunity to compare them? I understood it wasn’t close in terms of audio quality but a recent article I read suggested there wasn’t much in it?

Thanks very much 🙂
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

20 replies

Renowned Enthusiast II
Feb 28, 2018 8:07 PM UTC
Are you an Apple Music subscriber and fairly deep into the Apple ecosystem?

Do you want to be able to use voice control on your music service asssumibg it’s Apple Music?

Are you ok with using airplay to stream most anything else.

If the answers to all of the above is yes proceed to get your HomePods.

If not keep your Sonos.
Translate
(1) Play 1, (1) Play 3, (2) Play 5s Gen 1, (1) Play 5 Gen 2, (1) Connect Amp powering a pair of Wharfedale Diamond 10.1, (2) Echo Dots.
Belly M
Feb 28, 2018 8:13 PM UTC
In the house we have Sonos including the One , Bluesound Pulse Flex and the Apple HomePod.

Compared to the other two the HomePod has deeper, clearer bass and fills the room easier. However the mid and treble are in my opinion poor, Airplay 1 is practically useless and its only useful for Apple Music. Luckily my son bought it otherwise I would have taken it back to the store.

In my opinion the Bluesound Pulse Flex has better audio quality and has the flexibility of Bluetooth(works way better than airplay), headphone socket and preset buttons. The Sonos One scores points at being almost as good as the Pulse Flex but 1/3 cheaper.

The Play 5 (gen 2) is waaaayyy better than the HomePod.

All of this is in my humble opinion 🙂
Translate
clevadogAuthor
Contributor I
Feb 28, 2018 9:11 PM UTC
Thank you both for your replies. Yes, we have Apple Music. Voice control would be nice, but certainly isn’t an essential. We only use our Sonos for Apple Music and Audible via line in at the moment, but the latter doesn’t work very well streaming from the Play 5 to the Sonos One. It stutters, sometimes doesn’t play and is annoying to control from a different room.

That said, if the sound really isn’t great on the HomePod then I’m not happy to make the jump as I really love the sound on the Play 5. I’ll have a look at the Pulse Flex though, thank you 🙂 I know Sonos are talking about Airplay in the future which would solve the problem, but it’s not clear whether that would include existing Sonos devices, so it’s a bit of a gamble sticking around just for that.
Translate
clevadogAuthor
Contributor I
Feb 28, 2018 9:12 PM UTC
Ahh! I ticked my own response as the best reply. What a muppet! How do I undo that!?
Translate
Belly M
Feb 28, 2018 9:13 PM UTC
The Sonos One will get Airplay 2, as will all current Bluesound devices. Beyond that and when nobody knows.
Translate
clevadogAuthor
Contributor I
Feb 28, 2018 9:21 PM UTC
Cheers. Sorry, it looks like I can't undo my idiotic accidental acceptance of my reply as the "best answer". :8
Translate
Ryan S
Retired Sonos Staff
Feb 28, 2018 10:14 PM UTC
Ahh! I ticked my own response as the best reply. What a muppet! How do I undo that!?
I fixed that for you. I gave the answer to Belly.

I know it's something that you've heard before, but I would like to add that Audible is coming to Sonos soon. I wish I could give you a date, but it's been a moving target for a while and I don't want to promise something that isn't 1000% accurate at this point. I look forward to being able to tell everyone it's ready.
Translate
Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
Mar 1, 2018 12:05 AM UTC
I understood it wasn’t close in terms of audio quality but a recent article I read suggested there wasn’t much in it?

For every article that swings one way, there will be one that does the opposite.The sensible way to decide is based on features and price because these are objective things that can be relied on even from reviews. As long as the sound quality is in the ball park, the brain gets used to and even starts liking the one it hears over a time as short as a few days. The way to make sure of the ball park thing is via a listening test at home, to music you like. If that isn't possible, in the store.
Translate
clevadogAuthor
Contributor I
Mar 1, 2018 7:52 AM UTC
Thanks for sorting that Ryan. I do appreciate there’s nothing more you can say regarding Audible. I wasn’t trying to spark another Audible debate, just that with alternatives emerging that already have this capability we’ve started wondering whether we should start looking elsewhere. It’s certainly not a decision I’d take lightly.

Kumar: Thanks for the reply. It’s sound quality I’m most concerned about really. With the UK price rises for Sonos, I think I can actually get a really good price for them second hand that would go a long way to paying for a couple of HomePods (or alternatives). I think you’re right about going and listening in store. But I’m sure home with the music you listen to all the time is the best comparison. I doubt Apple will be generous enough to lend me one though. Lol.
Translate
Mar 1, 2018 8:05 AM UTC
Doesn't Apple/dealers offer the return policy of the type that Sonos does, that allows such a test?
Translate