Skip to main content
Jul 11, 2018 2:30 PM UTC

Discontinuing service and software updates for older legacy Sonos speakers?

I just read this about your recent SEC filing:
https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/11/17559380/sonos-airplay-2-support-software-update-download

“We expect that in the near to intermediate term, this backward compatibility will no longer be practical or cost-effective, and we may decrease or discontinue service for our older products,” says Sonos in a recent SEC filing.

When will you let customers know about which products will be affected by this discontinuation plan? Clearly you know internally since you say in the near to immediate term this policy is going ahead. I presume for example the first gen Play 5 you no longer sell will be affected and the old Sonos Bridge.

The problem for those of us using speakers with online services such as Spotify probably means once API changes are made by the service provider, we'll almost certainly be shut out from using those services with our older Sonos speakers.

There's nothing particularly shocking about this. I'm curious what the plan is though and when we'll be told.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    122 replies

    Lyricist III
    Jan 21, 2020 8:40 PM UTC

    it will 

     

    The big question is whether you will still be able to add new hardware to the system after May ...eg a new room or a playbar …….  or a software update after moving home …… or (who knows?) and still connect to the legacy system.  If not I will have to rething my sonos future, and will be looking elsewhere.  

     

     

    @Ryan S from Sonos stated in the main announcement thread that you will be able to add new hardware to systems that are frozen out of updates.  

     

    it will be interesting to see how this might work,  ie. will the software in the new items be regressed to the level of the old items or what?  Will there be a downloadable “legacy” iphone and android app and a version for Windows?   I’m currently on a very old software version (due to keeping  cr100s still working) but what happens when I buy 2 new speakers?  Will there be a “legacy” download …. and which version?    Still pissed off at losing windows PC control over updates on the separate system I have in another property - not nearly as useful as the old version (and crazy since the PC is needed to control the NAS drive system and Itunes which holds the songs) 

     

    ah well.

     

    What the alternative options to waste my money on?  any thoughts?

     

    David in Brighton

    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Jan 21, 2020 8:59 PM UTC

    the same worries  here, looking at over £2000 to “update” to the same functionality I have now.  I dont use voice activated (amazon or google) so no benefit to me at all ……..  

    Same thing with me. I use my system only for listening the music in different rooms. I dont need or want any unsecure voice controls there. 

    You can do it also with the speakers from the 70's. So its not a big thing to ask that you can continue listening the music with your expensive system which you have owned only few years. 

     

    From the original mail: "Over time, this is likely to disrupt access to services and overall functionality."

    It doesn't say that you cant use coming new features if those are not possible because of technical limitations. It clearly tells that over time it will distrupt overall functionality! And you cant get new updates for the system if you have some old speakers and some which are Gen2.

    Of course you could make updates also in the future for the old verions. Just take off that kind of things which are not possible because of technical limitations (for example voice control) and different update for the systems/speakers which dont have any limitations. 

    PR disaster?

     

     

     

    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Jan 21, 2020 10:33 PM UTC

    I bought my 3 Play:5’s in 2017 - 3 yrs support on a household product that should last 20 or more years.. Paid a premium because I believed that SONOS was a quality product. SONOS no longer standing behind their older products (after 3 years!!!!) is an excellent indicator what the reality is. Lack of memory? Can’t do modern things - like what? Listen in and collect personal data for our data collection overlords?

    Just play high fidelity music from the internet (and local sources) and be able to sync it in groups.. something I thought the original speakers could do but now can’t apparently or won’t be able to in the future. Also my 2017 Connect is listed as “old” and the 2018 Connect is listed “modern”.. I have to replace the Connect with the new device which is even more expensive so the “30%” tradeup discount is insulting.

    I realize of course that future devices may in fact handle video etc so yes of course there probably should be another tier of devices (I like the “classic” idea! :thumbsup_tone5::thumbsup::thumbsup_tone2: ).

    Hopefully there are some EU anti-consumer laws that can help cause here in the US it seems we just don’t care.

    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Jan 21, 2020 11:00 PM UTC

    I have a house full of Sonos and if I start not being able to use my four Play:1’s because I also have Play:5 Gen 2’s, I’m going to go from a maven to recommends Sonos to a maven who trashes Sonos. 

    Translate
    Airgetlam
    Jan 22, 2020 12:40 AM UTC

    The announcement makes no assertions about PLAY:1s.

    Translate
    Bruce
    Enthusiast I
    Jan 22, 2020 12:40 AM UTC

     

    I could answer your questions, but I choose not to because you’ve spent most of this thread insulting me.

    And Sonos employees are marked as such. 

    Just so you know I don’t take that as an insult from you.  It’s your choice.  No insults from me. Just an opinion that doesn’t accord with yours.  And if anyone threw any insults it was you I’m afraid by posting a reply which could easily be interpreted by anyone else reading as implying that I had used a profanity in my post that I said had been taken down for some odd reason.  And if you can’t see that then you won’t understand why you come across as a bully either (as someone else here pointed out).  I can accept you probably don’t intend this but why not reflect on it?  It’s not just me who found your responses somewhat ‘off colour’.

    Translate
    Enthusiast I
    Jan 22, 2020 12:47 AM UTC

    Sonos is not a speaker, so expecting it to be like a speaker is nonsense. Sonos is an integrated multi-room music streamer, with significant reliance on an external ecosystem which includes things like cloud services, streaming services, voice services, etc. To expect 13+ year old technology to operate within this ecosystem in perpetuity is not only unrealistic, it is foolish. To expect it to be like the old pair of Advents you bought back in 1972 is downright absurd.

    Furthermore, to expect Sonos to continually support every software/firmware release which occurs prior to an older unit no longer being supported is also unrealistic. Sonos is a for profit company, and how much profit is to be made if they waste manpower on a configuration which will eventually lose most if not all functionality, for a forever dwindling user base, who by definition will never buy another Sonos device? Answer: Not much.


    And I suppose you don’t see how adressing someones concerns like this is insulting? The phrase ‘The pot calling the kettle black’ comes to mind.

    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Jan 22, 2020 12:48 AM UTC

    The announcement makes no assertions about PLAY:1s.

    I understand that. But if they can stop supporting my Connect, and make me choose between updating my app and firmware or keeping my Connect, then they can do that to my Play:1s, as well.

    I can live with losing one Connect. But losing four great speakers that are performing perfectly would be too much. I think Sonos should be careful about forcing these decisions on its customers, because customer loyalty has been one of its strengths and this policy could quickly destroy that.

    Translate
    Airgetlam
    Jan 22, 2020 12:54 AM UTC

    Every maker of ‘smart’ devices faces this dilemma. If a device has a CPU and memory, at some point, one or the other won’t be enough to run the software. I can’t use my ‘386 computer with Win10, I can’t run iOS 13 on my original iPhone. It’s not great, but it’s part of what we get with smart / software driven devices. At least Sonos is just freezing the software updates to these devices, and not just bricking them. You can continue to use them. 

    Translate
    Bruce
    Enthusiast I
    Jan 22, 2020 12:58 AM UTC

    Every maker of ‘smart’ devices faces this dilemma. If a device has a CPU and memory, at some point, one or the other won’t be enough to run the software. I can’t use my ‘386 computer with Win10, I can’t run iOS 13 on my original iPhone. It’s not great, but it’s part of what we get with smart / software driven devices. At least Sonos is just freezing the software updates to these devices, and not just bricking them. You can continue to use them. 


    ...but not as a system?  Becuase all units in the system need to be using the same software…?  Or have I misunderstood?

     

    Translate