Skip to main content
Enthusiast I
Feb 22, 2018 3:26 PM UTC

Comparison of stereo pairs: Play 5 gen. 2 vs Play 1 (without sub)

I’m a little hesitant to share these observations, given that my previous contributions to this community consisted mainly of flip-flopping on the issue of a single Play 5 gen. 2 vs a stereo pair of Play 1s, but I thought this might be interesting to some here:

Whilst there’s lots of discussion here regarding a stereo pair of gen. 2 Play 5s vs a pair of Play 1s with a sub, I don’t think I’ve ever seen a comparison between the Play 5 pair and a Play 1 pair without the assistance of the sub. Whilst I realise not many will be choosing between these two options, given the cost difference, I did happen to get the chance to compare these two set-ups directly yesterday: Set up as stereo pairs in the same room/location, both with Trueplay tuning applied.

The main take-away from the comparison? To be honest, it was quite how amazingly good the Play 1s are relative to their tiny size and price. Of course, on the whole, the Play 5 pair was significantly better but the difference was smaller than I would have supposed and with some music (where the extra power, weight and bass of the Play 5 were not relevant) there was no discernable improvement at all: Bach’s cello suites sounded every bit as lovely on the Play 1s as on the Play 5s. Similarly, tracks with a single vocalist and sparse background instrumentation sounded just as good on the little Play 1s as on their big brothers. Whilst I’m still very happy that the pair of Play 5s are the ones staying resident in my living room, given that a pair of Play 1s costs barely more than a third of the cost of the Play 5s, I think this is a spectacular achievement for the smallest and cheapest Sonos speaker.
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

21 replies

pwt
Virtuoso
Feb 22, 2018 3:34 PM UTC
I'd say that's a pretty accurate summary.

I operate a PLAY:1 pair, a PLAY:5 pair, and a PLAY:5 pair + SUB. All these setups are well into audiophile territory, despite what many would confidently assert.
Translate
4 x P:5 | Sub | 4 x P:1 | 3 x Connect | 2 x Boost | Connect:Amp | 2 x One | Amp | Move | Port | Era 300
Feb 23, 2018 1:29 AM UTC
Whilst I’m still very happy that the pair of Play 5s are the ones staying resident in my living room, given that a pair of Play 1s costs barely more than a third of the cost of the Play 5s, I think this is a spectacular achievement for the smallest and cheapest Sonos speaker.
I agree and I believe that the play 1 remains even today the best product in the range. At the present reduced prices it becomes even more compelling value, to do cheap and cheerful on its own, all the way to serious audiophile quality sound in the 1 pair + Sub configuration. And as surround speakers for the HT solution.

If it had a line in jack, it would have been the complete speaker because it would then have been able to overcome even the limitation of not having bluetooth. And it could have seen use as the perfect wired companion for the Dot, two years before Sonos released its still half baked Alexa integration, having lost huge market share in the interim to other speakers that worked well to enhance the sound quality of the Dot to even beyond that of the Echo. I believe that the decision to deprive it of the line in jack to protect play 5 sales was a poor one for this and many other reasons, that would have allowed much higher sales of the little champion. It may even have allowed Sonos to retain employees that were laid off two years ago after the hit Sonos took from Echo+Dot.
Translate
0b5cur1tyAuthor
Enthusiast I
Feb 23, 2018 7:59 AM UTC
I agree and I believe that the play 1 remains even today the best product in the range. At the present reduced prices it becomes even more compelling value, to do cheap and cheerful on its own, all the way to serious audiophile quality sound in the 1 pair + Sub configuration. And as surround speakers for the HT solution.

If it had a line in jack, it would have been the complete speaker because it would then have been able to overcome even the limitation of not having bluetooth.


If, as I presume, you also mean relative to its price/size, I think I would agree with you that it’s Sonos’ best single product (and visually most attractive). Of course in absolute terms the Play 5 is a better speaker and I think, in my own space and with the range of musical genres I listen to, I would still prefer one Play 5 to a pair of Play 1s but it’s a very close run thing (and also significantly more expensive now). Happily, the Play 5 pair now gives me the best of both worlds.

Agree with you also about the line-in, though in my case it’s because I want the reassurance of still being able to plug in a music source directly to the speakers.
Translate
Feb 23, 2018 9:42 AM UTC
I suspect that in some situations, a 1 pair + Sub will outshine a 5 pair. And run it close in most others, at about the same price point.
Which is why I rate the 1 unit as highly as I do, for its versatility. Sure a 5 pair+ Sub will do even better, but the 5 unit won't sit in many places where the 1 can comfortably do so.
Translate
0b5cur1tyAuthor
Enthusiast I
Feb 23, 2018 9:59 AM UTC
I suspect that in some situations, a 1 pair + Sub will outshine a 5 pair. And run it close in most others, at about the same price point.
Which is why I rate the 1 unit as highly as I do, for its versatility. Sure a 5 pair+ Sub will do even better, but the 5 unit won't sit in many places where the 1 can comfortably do so.


Oh, I don’t doubt that with the addition of the sub, a pair of Play 1s will be as good as a pair of Play 5s, maybe even better. I haven’t been able to compare these setups, sadly, but seem to recall opinion is pretty evenly split among those who have been able to do so?

In my particular case it’s a non-issue as it would be awkward to place a sub near/between the speakers in my tiny living room, whereas I can reasonably accomodate the Play 5 pair. I do also appreciate the aforementioned line-in option.
Translate
Lyricist I
Feb 23, 2018 8:18 PM UTC
Your post is extremely helpful as i was wondering what the feeling was between the 2 obviously the 5's are better but your description of how much or little was the exact info i was looking for.

I have the Playbar and a Sub in my front and have been debating on what rears Its a big room with a 75" Sony 4k. The price of the 5's make me cringe. so i thought about 3's , with your post 1's are a strong possible.

Thank you for the excellent information.
Translate
Lyricist I
Mar 10, 2018 10:55 AM UTC
Hi to all, this is my first post here and I am new to SONOS but familiar in their products for years...
Have both setups at the same room (pic in attch.)
Play 1 pair best that money can buy in that size of speaker
Play 5 hm.... People who have them will also just say hmmm with that little devil smile because of power, clearity of sound and earth shaking bass. Next year the SUB is must have. My room is 40m2 and it is is overkill with those setul but I don't mind...
Regards
Sasa
Translate
Mar 13, 2018 1:01 AM UTC
I'd say that's a pretty accurate summary.

I operate a PLAY:1 pair, a PLAY:5 pair, and a PLAY:5 pair + SUB. All these setups are well into audiophile territory, despite what many would confidently assert.


Nope. Audiphiles don't buy Sonos.
Translate
Mar 13, 2018 1:08 AM UTC
Audiophiles also don't buy Chromecast Audio; in general what they buy or don't buy is a reflection of them and has nothing to do with the objective merits of any product. This, by definition.

The thing is that some will be more generous than others in how audiophiles are defined, as pwt has been in the quote above.
Translate
Mar 17, 2018 6:50 PM UTC
Audiophiles also don't buy Chromecast Audio; in general what they buy or don't buy is a reflection of them and has nothing to do with the objective merits of any product. This, by definition.
The thing is that some will be more generous than others in how audiophiles are defined, as pwt has been in the quote above.


Yeah, no.
They don't buy Chromecast audio because they have heard really good sound quality and now the Chromecast sounds terrible with that tiny little dac.
Sonos is OK but not anywhere near audiophile territory for the same reason. They are fine for secondary speakers though.
Translate