Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Apr 12, 2016 8:19 PM UTC

Bought the Play 5 Gen2 & the Naim Mu So QB, one of them went back..... ( not the Play5! )

Good evening all,

Firstly I'm new on here ( hello all ) so hope this is posted in the right section!

I am not new to HiFi equipment or wireless speakers ( I have had a rather bad habit for the last 20 years ) and have had and sold more stuff than I care to think about, but I am new to Sonos, well until this weekend that is! I wanted to share the following with you as I cannot see anywhere on the forums or the net a Naim vs. Sonos comparison.

Sunday afternoon, following a trip to my local John Lewis I returned home with a Play 5 Gen2 (£389) and the relatively new Naim Qu So QB (£595). I couldn't decide which one to go for and having any sort of meaningful demo was hopeless, Sonos Play 5 was connected to a Play 1, Play 3 and a Sonos soundbar which all seemed to playing at the same time on the Sonos stand, despite me trying to isolate the Play5 and even trying the line in option with the 3.5mm jack I brought with me as a last resort.( plus someone was streaming what sounded like Bangra music at a stupid level in the next isle on a BeoPlay A2, all very annoying ).

I went in to listen to the Mu-so QB and the bigger brother Mu-So (£895) and to be honest the new Zepplin ( sorry all, not the face.......). So I'm stood in front of the Mu-So QB and I'm streaming a few of my tried and tested "test" tracks from Spotify (offline) via Bluetooth and I am thinking to myself "that's not great". I would just like to mention at this stage that I did listen to the QB in Superfi Nottingham about a week ago and they had it hard wired and were streaming Hi Res ( not sure what format ) files to it and I must say whilst I wasn't crazy on the looks, it did sound pretty impressive. Hence the trip to JL to listen to it again but this time via Bluetooth.

For background, I wanted something to replace the Revo Superconnect I have in the kitchen dinner and because I have been really happy with this for 12 months I was initially thinking the new Revo SuperSystem (rrp £550 I think ). I wanted something to fill the room better, I don't always agree with What HiFi but with the SuperConnect they got it spot on IMO, for the size of it the sound is pretty impressive ( to my ears anyway ). 3 or 4 years ago I started out with the Audio Pro all room One ( as my first "proper" wireless speaker, which did sound good and for the money is probably the best I'd heard until now, however if the wind was blowing in the wrong direction the airplay would drop out, app was terrible so in the end like so much of my other stuff I sold it on Ebay ( still have the Revo, 2 sound bars, 2 amps, a 5.1 system, Monitor audio book shelf speakers, Monitor Audio S150, C.Audio Go, plus various headphones, not to mention the system in the garage, I think you all get the picture, and that is after a de-clutter!! )

So back to the QB test, so I'm standing there and all of a sudden a track came on behind me and I "thought blimey that sounds good", I turned around and low and behold it was the Play 5 Gen2. I would just like to say at this point that Sonos had not actually been a consideration despite the excellent reviews for the Gen2. My Boss has his whole house wired up with Sonos, all Gen 1 and whilst I liked the concept I always felt the sound was a bit, muffled sounding, lacking detail and clarity. So after finally turning all the other Sonos speakers off so it was just the Play5 playing, I was seriously impressed with what I was hearing. Now I appreciate that this was hard wired and the QB was via Bluetooth but it was literally night and day! With the Bangra still blaring I decided that the only way to really do a test was at home. Long story short, after ascertaining that I could take both home and return the one I didn't want for a full refund, off I went with a box in each hand ( both are reassuringly heavy ) and £984 lighter, with slight trepidation that I wouldn't get my refund like they promised, made worse as I had put them both on my wife's card!!!

Back home, set both up side by side. QB via Spotify connect, Play5 via Sonos APP and Spotify through that. Demo tracks, tried and tested ones, back to back comparison and I can conclude that the Sonos for me sounds better. The QB sounded slightly muffled again, made me think back to when I first heard my bosses Sonos system. My mate said the same when he popped over the following day, he is a big B&W fan, has had the A5, A7, original Zepplin etc, he always said I should have kept the Audio Pro, but heh ho ). He is getting the new Zepplin on demo from B&W ( he spoke to them today and they said that the A7 is now obsolete ) so if anyone hasn't killed themselves after reading this I'm happy to report back on that when he brings it over at the end of the week to compare to the play5. I did listen to the new Zepplin through the 3.5 jack in JL and it did sound good ( treble slightly harsh I noted ), but better than the QB which I also tried using the 3.5 jack.

Sonos 5 goes deeper than the QB by some way and just has more presence and clarity to my ears, I am amazed by the bass response on the Play5 on some of the tracks I played, Sharpness by Jamie Woon being one of them. ( I will also add that the EQ is on standard neutral setting for the Play5 throughout for the test with loudness on ) on the QB you only seem to be able to turn loudness on/off, no EQ settings I could see on the Naim app ( which does look good and functions well )

I am sure that some of the Naim faithful will tell me that the QB needs to run in ( and I know it does ) but out of the box the Sonos has it beat in every area, and lets face it is £210 cheaper. Hard wired with Hi Res tracks I don't dispute that the Naim might have the edge, but in the real world that's not how I listen to music these days! I have all my music ripped to lossless files but I simply can't be ars*d with all the faffing about. Open Sonos app, Spotify and it's on straight away with Sonos and I like that. Even though I am still getting used to leaving it on at the wall.

There is a downside for me with the Play5 Gen2 however, I can't pretend that I am happy with the Sonos App and the Spotify integration. Like many have said already my Playlists are all over the place with Spotify through the Sonos APP, ( I have loads of them and spent many hours collating them ) plus no iplayer Radio ( I have read on here that it might be coming soon, fingers crossed ) isn't great for me either as I do like to listen to catch up, but I suppose I can do that in my office when working from home which is where the REVO is going. I am also considering a short - medium term work around for airplay to use the native Spotify app and iplayer either with Airport express or the much cheaper Chromecast Audio. ( I read if you disable compression you won't lose audio quality ) but I just can't get my head round wiring in with 3.5mm jack, it's not what I bought it for ( maybe I should have read more about Sonos before I bought it ) but as I said already Sonos wasn't even on my radar until Sunday. I'm not Sonos bashing for the record and have signed up to help out with any new Beta's to try and help things along as I honestly feel the guys have done a fantastic job with the Play5 Gen2, I really think for the money it is a great speaker and it hasn't dropped out yet which is encouraging considering my kids are caning the fibre constantly streaming movies on their ipads. It's just a few niggles as mentioned that are taking the shine off for me, Spotify being the main one to be honest.

As I sit here typing this listening to the speaker I really want to stick with it and hope for future upgrades to iron out the problems as I'd like to add another play 5 after we extend the kitchen, but there is still a little part of me that is considering taking it back. But what then, the Denon Heos offering, the Bluetone range....?

Thanks for reading and I hope it proves to be of interest to some of you.

P.S. I like that fact that there is interaction with people from the Sonos team on the forum, makes me think that Sonos are actually bothered about what their customers think!

JB
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    25 replies

    Trending Lyricist I
    Apr 14, 2016 7:55 PM UTC
    No problem Ryan, thanks for your comment. looking forward to hearing when the higher res Bbc radio streams will be available through tunein. That plus a few tweaks on spotify to get the playlist folders to display instead of a long list of albums and I'm perfectly happy! Catch up bbc radio would be the cherry on the cake.
    Translate
    Lyricist II
    Feb 18, 2017 11:38 AM UTC
    Hi JB,

    I feel compelled to reply to your post given my recent experience with the naim QB. My post is along the lines that you mentioned “the Naim faithful will tell me that the QB needs to run in..”. I fall into this category having used naim equipment for the over 20 years now. However, in my defence I have recently packed my eldest off to university with a couple of Play 1’s which I think sound superb.

    I bought the QB three weeks ago for the kitchen. The QB was an easy decision for me, given that I have a naim streamer in my main system and this now gives me multi-room.

    My experience with all naim kit that I have bought over the years, almost without exception, is that it takes 2-3 weeks to come on song. Performance fresh out of the box is usually a big disappointment and this is often still so after a few days of use.

    I did wonder if it might be different with the little QB. It hasn’t been. Out of the box and even after a week, it sounded boxy, as you say muffled, with confused bass and generally unengaging. I too would have sent it back if this hadn’t changed. Happily, now after a few weeks, it is really starting to sing! High highs, low lows, very musical and engaging. I’m very happy and it’s not going back. :-)

    I haven’t heard the Play 5 and can’t offer any comment and that’s not the purpose of my note. I feel sure it’s a fine piece of hi-fi equipment from the accounts I’ve read. Rather to say that to really make a fair assessment you need to hear it in your own home and crucially, if it’s brand new, give it time to run in. With naim equipment this can be weeks not days.. otherwise you’re just not hearing it perform as it was designed to..

    That said, it’s all about the music…happy listening with your Play 5!!

    Rich.
    Translate
    Feb 18, 2017 11:51 AM UTC
    Rather to say that to really make a fair assessment you need to hear it in your own home and crucially, if it’s brand new, give it time to run in. With naim equipment this can be weeks not days
    I have no Naim experience in all my audiophile meanderings, but with my extensive range of other kit used I realised in time that running in was the process by which the brain gets used to the new sound that is almost always the result of a speaker change.
    I agree with all you have said on the home being the ideal place to assess the sound quality of Sonos kit, but I have found that the running in thing for Sonos is on the same lines as it was every other new speaker I have laid my hands on and used. It isn't that the speaker does anything different in time, it is that one gets used to how it sounds. At most, a new speaker may need a few hours to get its moving parts to settle down, but for electronic kit like amps, there is nothing to run in. Audiophiles of course will claim that even speaker cables need time to run in and give of their best!
    Translate
    jgatie
    Feb 18, 2017 2:46 PM UTC
    In my youth, I worked at a high end audio/video/media store. I was in the computer department, but was great friends with the commission sales people in a/v. I learned a lot about sales techniques and strategies at that job. One of the worst things to have on your sales record was a high percentage of turnover, or returned items. Coincidently, it was the "expert" opinion of these a/v sales people that the break-in period for high end electronics just happened to correspond with the period of time that a returned item would not count against ones sales record. 😉
    Translate
    Lyricist II
    Feb 18, 2017 4:33 PM UTC
    Hi,

    Blimey – I’ve never posted onto an audio forum thread before, be it on a naim or sonos forum or anywhere else.. I expected it to be quietly ignored.. thanks for the quick response guys..

    I’m just saying what believe to be going on from my experience – I certainly don’t profess to be an expert. Certainly my brand experience is pretty limited.. as you'll begin to see below.. On the odd occasion when I've tried something different I've regretted it. Although not so with my daughters Play 1's.

    Kumar re electronics - I have had just the same experience with changes in electronics (not speaker cables I hasten to add), not only from new, but when I’ve had my amps re-capped – this running with the same pair of speakers I’ve had for the last 15 years.. (albeit having had the tweeters and crossovers replaced a few years ago).

    You make an interesting argument “that one gets used to how it sounds”, one that is difficult to argue against, perception it everything – right? I’ve certainly not had the means to scientifically measure any differences.

    Does anyone from Sonos comment on these threads? If so it would be interest to know if there is measurable difference between brand new equipment and equipment that has be used for weeks and months. Also, something I’ve often pondered – if there is, which I believe (perceive) there to be, how’s is this dealt with during product development?

    If I don’t hear anything I might make this my first post onto the naim forum.

    Rich the impostor.
    Translate
    jgatie
    Feb 18, 2017 5:55 PM UTC
    Sonos are first and foremost a company staffed by engineers. Given their objective stance on audiophile nonsense like Hi-res, I would suspect they would go the scientific route and say that although there is some evidence that physical components like speakers could "break in", the likelihood of it being audible is slim to none.
    Translate
    Ryan S
    Retired Sonos Staff
    Feb 18, 2017 6:49 PM UTC
    The speaker break in time you guys are talking about does exist to a degree. Mostly it is just the suspension and sometimes a bit with the cones. The material of the speaker cone also can loosen up a bit sometimes, adding a slightly lower tone. But all that depends on a lot of factors.

    Personally I'd say a good bit is just getting used to the new sound more than anything. But there are some technical bits to the audio changing a little over time too sometimes.

    As far as Sonos goes, we meticulously designed our products to not need to be broken in. That way you get consistent results from the time you pull it out of the box or 10 years down the line. Also, that way you can take a PLAY:1 home and pair it with another a year later and they'll sound the same and be a perfect match for stereo.
    Translate
    Mark good posts by pressing the like button, and select the best answer on questions you've asked to help others find solutions.
    Lyricist II
    Feb 18, 2017 7:24 PM UTC
    Ryan, Thanks that's interesting and settles that I guess.. for Sonos equipment at least :)

    I'm tempted to ask about the Hi-Res comment, but I fear jgatie has me on the hook and is just enjoying reeling me in.. :)

    So I wont and I'll bow out gracefully.

    Cheers guys..
    Translate
    Feb 19, 2017 1:28 AM UTC
    The material of the speaker cone also can loosen up a bit sometimes, adding a slightly lower tone.

    Also, that way you can take a PLAY:1 home and pair it with another a year later and they'll sound the same and be a perfect match for stereo.

    To the latter, after the little loosening you refer to?:)
    IMO, the results of that, if any, aren't audible. More seriously, this also points to speaker signature being dependent on things like cabinet design, speaker cone configuration/specs, design of crossover/DSP used, and less on exactly which internal components are used; if it was the latter, every component change because of sourcing issues would affect the sound signature.

    Alan Shaw, the designer/owner of Harbeth speakers, makes the same point on his forum where he says - no running in required to obtain the designed sound from any of his speakers.

    But audiophilia drives strange beliefs and behaviours, with enough people to exploit every one of these; like the sellers of CDs containing sound designed to expedite the running in process:-).

    As to the thread, the OP has said is that he prefers the Sonos sound signature to the Naim one. Some will go the other way in this subjective preference of course, but those that do prefer the Sonos sound will not see their preference changing just because the Naim has run in, or because it is being fed Hi Res via wired connections. The caveat to the latter: provided that the Sonos is getting the same recording/master in a 16/44 format, wireless or wired.
    Translate
    SHARKB8T
    Prodigy I
    Feb 19, 2017 1:52 AM UTC
    ...
    I'm tempted to ask about the Hi-Res comment, but I fear jgatie has me on the hook and is just enjoying reeling me in.. :)



    Wait wait WAIT!!! Don't leave !! We need many more people with this much wisdom on this message board :D

    Thanks to the OP for the post and Ryan for your additional comments... an interesting read...
    Translate