Skip to main content
Contributor I
Dec 30, 2013 7:56 PM UTC

Big difference between Play:1 and Play:3

Hello all,

I am thinking about buying a Sonos Play:1.
Now I just I would order one and start listening....but they're sold out everywhere (in Holland that is).

So now I am reading countless reviews just because I have some extra time ( 😉 )....and thinking what would be the best thing to do.

Is there a big difference between a Sonos Play:1 and the bigger Play:3 ? Main usage would be in my living room (30m2) streaming from my Synology NAS and Internet Radio. I've got an Ultimate Ears Boombox as well, but don't like the size and the Bluetooth dropouts. Also I think i'll love the connectivity from Sonos.

What do you guys think?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

23 replies

Avid Contributor I
Dec 30, 2013 8:19 PM UTC
I live in the Netherlands too, and last Friday I ordered a white Play1 from Sonos. The next day it arrived.
I might have had the last one, but yould could give it a try and order.
And as you might know, ordering from Sonos gives you 60 days of returning time.
So you could even order both and after that take a decision.
Translate
cremerhmAuthor
Contributor I
Dec 30, 2013 8:38 PM UTC
Tx for the suggestion, will consider it!
(en leuk om meteen van een nederlander reactie te krijgen 😉 )

But for now I would like to make the best decision. I've got an order for the Play:1 (with an free bridge) , but should the Play:3 have a (far!) better sound, than I will invest the extra €100,- ....

The Play:1 should come available somewhere in the next 2 weeks they told me. Play:3 is in stock.

So if someone has an opinion about both sound quality and volume I would like to hear it!
Translate
World-Class Superstar
Dec 31, 2013 9:33 AM UTC
So if someone has an opinion about both sound quality and volume I would like to hear it!

Of course we all have opinions on sound and/or quality of Play:1 vs. Play:3. But if I were you, I wouldn't expect those opinions to be of any help while deciding what to purchase. It's all very subjective and personal and the only thing that really helps is listening for yourself, in your own environment.
Translate
Prodigy I
Dec 31, 2013 9:58 AM UTC
Well, I'll have a go.

I really do like my Play 1. It has clarity and definition. However, on its own, I really am starting to fall out of love with it. I have played with the EQ etc., but it just lacks roundness in comparison with the P3 I have in my office.

I am sure that I would feel differently if only had a P1, but the fact is I hear as much difference between the P1 and P3 as between the P3 and P5.

No surprise. I suspect this is just as it is supposed to be. The P1 is an entry level product in Sonos terms.

Others have stated that a stereo pair of P1's sounds good and I may try that. Alternatively, I may sell the P1, juggle other devices downwards and get a Connect AMP to go with my new SUB I got for Christmas !!
Translate
Contributor III
Dec 31, 2013 10:40 AM UTC
Hi,

I have a 20 sq. m living room and I would say a standalone Play:1 is not enough. As stated previously, this is an entry-level product and while it does perform really good in its range of speakers, I think it's more adequate for a bathroom, kitchen, small bedroom.

Also, I do confirm that 2 Play:1's sounds definitely better. You could say "Obviousy, it's bound to be" but it does sound better in a way it surprises you compared over a unique Play:1.
Last week, I had a friend at my place and I demoed my Playbar, SUB, 2*Play:1 and while he had owned a Play:5 and turned to Libratone for full AirPlay support, he recently turned to Android and now reconsidering back SONOS products.
He was obviously not impressed with a unique Play:1 (because he were comprising it to its former Play:5 and Libratone equivalent) but he definitely looked surprised and pleased by the addition of another Play:1 in stereo. Adding a SUB to this and he was pretty convinced.

Now, owning a Play:5 and having it previously in my living room prior to my Playbar purchase, my recommendation, in a 30 sq. m living room, would be to either go for a Play:5 or maybe 2*Play:3s.
Now, my Play:5 is in my bedroom (12 sq. m) and while it still sounds really good, it is an overkill in that situation.
As for the 2*Play:3s, I do not own any, just making an educated guess. 2*Play:3s would also give you a stereo feel that is very enjoyable.

Having my Playbar and 2*Play:1s in my living room, I do enjoy more the sound coming out of my Play:1s in stereo while listening to music that coming out from my Playbar because you don't have that feeling of being surrounded by sound although I don't use them very often for that purpose because of the lack of flexibility from SONOS to switch from one configuration to another. But, it's on their roadmap.
Translate
Legnum Nick
Prodigy III
Dec 31, 2013 11:50 AM UTC
I have just bought a play:3 as part of my initial sonos set up. I listened to he play:3 and play:1 in the hifi shop I bought the items from. In my opinion the 3 has a more dynamic sound and better bass response that made it worth spending the extra on. I can't comment on your room size - I have the 3 in my kitchen which is about 15m2.
Translate
Avid Contributor I
Dec 31, 2013 5:06 PM UTC
I have to agree. The Play:3 has a much fuller sound than the Play:1 (same for Play:5 to Play:3). And a pair of Play:3s sounds great (and really great with a Sub).
Translate
cremerhmAuthor
Contributor I
Jan 1, 2014 10:49 AM UTC
Went for a listening session yesterday, and noticed immediately that the sound of the Play:1 was both missing and adding something to the music that I didn't like. Felt it was missing a bit dept in the high tones (if that makes sense) and added a echo/surround that I dislike.

The Play:3 sounded very well (for my budget). Good base, nice middle an high. Sounds very well balanced, not as balanced as the Play:5 though but than one is just to expensive and big for my needs.

So I went for the Play:3!!
@home it wasn't immediately a WOW , but when I was listening a bit longer .... it became a WOW most definitely!

Probably will add an Play:1 in the (near) future for smaller rooms.

Tx for all you're input!
Translate
World-Class Superstar
Jan 1, 2014 11:03 AM UTC
Thanks for the feedback, enjoy your Sonos!
Translate
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 3, 2014 2:53 PM UTC
JMHO:

2 play5 > 2 play3 > play5 > 2 play1 > play3 > play1

I don't know where the playbar would fit in here though. 🙂
Translate