Skip to main content
Sonosjunkie
Prodigy III
Apr 22, 2019 3:31 PM UTC

B&W Formation

https://www.bowerswilkins.com/en-gb

Anyone noticed this announcement? Thoughts?
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    43 replies

    chicks
    Apr 23, 2019 8:38 PM UTC

    Bowers & Wilkins sold to Silicon Valley start-up for undisclosed sum


    Wow! Well, at least they didn't sell out to a Chinese company. Interesting. Yet another great old British brand that's no longer British.
    Translate
    Stanley_4
    Grand Maestro
    Apr 23, 2019 10:21 PM UTC
    I'm waiting to hear what the Sonos patent lawyers have to say about these. Similar to the earlier Denon offering, they sound like a good idea now but will they still after the lawyers get done gnawing the corners off.
    Translate
    Apr 24, 2019 1:49 AM UTC

    Wow! Well, at least they didn't sell out to a Chinese company. Interesting. Yet another great old British brand that's no longer British.

    China is too close to our borders for us to ever be a fan of the Chinese, but there are a lot of Chinese companies now that are world class, and there is no saying that the brand would have definitely suffered under Chinese ownership. As far as I know, Quad is Chinese owned for many years now. And as another example Chinese smart phones are giving the Koreans a run for the money in Indian smart phone market, that is the second largest in the world, China being the biggest. Apple is a non starter in both places.
    Actually, I can't see the brand doing great under the ownership of a silicon valley start up.
    Translate
    melvimbe
    Apr 24, 2019 1:36 PM UTC
    I'm waiting to hear what the Sonos patent lawyers have to say about these. Similar to the earlier Denon offering, they sound like a good idea now but will they still after the lawyers get done gnawing the corners off.

    I thought about that possibility, but if B&W was bought in 2016 with smart speakers in mind, and they know Sonos will litigate to protect patents, I'd assume they took these 2/3 years to develop their own mesh system. I'm a little curious to see how well it works. I am completely guessing, but I wouldn't be surprised if they are using 5.0Ghz for the mesh network. I've noticed that none of the reviews and news articles talk about this at all, and don't even appear to review how well the network works, just speaker performance. The visual diagram B&W puts out has all the speakers in 2 rooms only, relatively small space. Then there is no mention of any sort of buffer delays, which is also not surprising, but something I'd expect to be found in reviews of the bar.

    We'll see.
    Translate
    Danny
    ratty
    Apr 24, 2019 1:53 PM UTC
    5GHz.
    https://www.cepro.com/article/bowers_wilkins_formation_wireless_multiroom_audio
    https://www.soundandvision.com/content/formation-wireless-technology-explained

    Much is made of sync accuracy and latency, but I have to confess I have never, in many years, been aware of soundstage drift between Sonos L&R stereo pairs.

    Speculating wildly, the playback sync mechanisms may differ between in-room and multi-room. It could be that in-room the devices are synchronous or at least plesiochronous. Sonos of course operates over any asynchronous medium, by the exchange of timestamps. Interesting stuff.

    Just as a reality check, sound takes about 1ms to travel a foot in air. Move your head slightly off the centreline, and even with two perfectly sychronised sources you'll easily inject hundreds of microseconds of offset between the channels at the listening position. And that's before room acoustics work their mischief.
    Translate
    melvimbe
    Apr 24, 2019 2:36 PM UTC
    https://www.cepro.com/article/bowers_wilkins_formation_wireless_multiroom_audio
    https://www.soundandvision.com/content/formation-wireless-technology-explained

    Much is made of sync accuracy and latency, but I have to confess I have never, in many years, been aware of soundstage drift between Sonos L&R stereo pairs.


    So yes, everything is 5 GHZ. That makes me think that there is going to be issues if you're going to use the speakers in opposite ends of the house with nothing in between. I'm surprised that they aren't offering a Boost like product to bridge the gap(s) and strengthen their network.

    The fact that they are planning on licensing their wireless platform could actually mean more competition for Sonos. Right now, it seems like they are only licensing it for use in single room HT setups, but if/when they are used in multiroom, with more affordable speakers...
    Translate
    Danny
    spydrwebb
    Prodigy I
    Apr 24, 2019 3:03 PM UTC
    At those prices, though, is it really competing with Sonos? Even Bluesound looks very affordable given B&W current MSRPs.
    Translate
    Beam, Sub, 2 x P:1 -- 5.1 (video) / 2 x P:3 (music) / 2 x gen1 One (music) ----> ever evolving setup, as they say...
    Stanley_4
    Grand Maestro
    Apr 24, 2019 8:34 PM UTC
    I thought about that possibility, but if B&W was bought in 2016 with smart speakers in mind, and they know Sonos will litigate to protect patents, I'd assume they took these 2/3 years to develop their own mesh system. I'm a little curious to see how well it works.

    Sonos not only patented the technology that they use but a fair amount of stuff that could be used to work around the core patents. Something like 630 issued patents, and 570 applications.

    https://www.sonos.com/en-us/legal/patents

    Things will be interesting.
    Translate
    chicks
    Apr 25, 2019 2:50 PM UTC
    This article gets it right, at least at the bottom

    https://www.cnet.com/news/bowers-wilkins-formation-high-end-formation-wireless-system-sonos-sairplay-2/

    Creating a new wireless multiroom standard seemingly out of thin air can be fraught with peril. In the face of competition from Sonos and Google, systems such as Qualcomm's AllPlay and LG's Music Flow have fallen by the wayside. Formation is less of a "Sonos-killer" though, as its appeal to the high-end makes it more of a Bluesound or Naim mu-so competitor.
    Translate
    buzz
    Grand Maestro
    Apr 25, 2019 3:47 PM UTC
    5GHz.

    Much is made of sync accuracy and latency, but I have to confess I have never, in many years, been aware of soundstage drift between Sonos L&R stereo pairs.

    Speculating wildly, the playback sync mechanisms may differ between in-room and multi-room. It could be that in-room the devices are synchronous or at least plesiochronous. Sonos of course operates over any asynchronous medium, by the exchange of timestamps. Interesting stuff.

    Just as a reality check, sound takes about 1ms to travel a foot in air. Move your head slightly off the centreline, and even with two perfectly sychronised sources you'll easily inject hundreds of microseconds of offset between the channels at the listening position. And that's before room acoustics work their mischief.


    Head movements while listening will introduce a sort of spatial jitter. Perhaps the audiophile community will coin a term for this.

    Using paired speakers, if one plays a mono source and sits quietly with a sandwich and a drink, one can detect a gentle adjustment of the SONOS sync once in a while. However, if one blinks, one will probably miss the adjustment. I'm pathologically sensitive to this sort of phenomenon. In my opinion this is an audiophile rant about a theoretical possibility, rather than a real world problem. If the audiophile wants absolutely perfect theoretical imaging, they might consider using a head clamp. Unfortunately, small head movements are part of the localization process.
    Translate