Skip to main content
Jul 2, 2014 4:22 PM UTC

Add "Prevent Updates" to System Updates Options

I would like to see an additional option in advanced settings to "Prevent Updates". This would be used by people who have a significant investment in older controllers or some other reason not to use the latest firmware and want to prevent an accidental upgrade. The key difference for this setting from just unchecking the "Automatically check for updates" box are as follows:

- The new option will remove the "Update Now" button from showing on any controller.

- The new option will cause zone players or controllers that may have required repair to take on the current system firmware revision when added back to the system rather than forcing an update to the latest firmware version. (Note this is not the same as rolling back firmware which Sonos says it will not support)

-The new option will block any third party app or controller from initiating an update unless you go into advanced options and explicitly turn off the "Prevent Updates" flag.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    25 replies

    Jul 6, 2014 9:27 PM UTC
    I'm kind of surprised that nobody is interested in retaining the old firmware version.
    Translate
    Local music library with carefully constructed playlists - no shuffling!, Integration with Homeseer Automation, No touch screen devices, No streaming services, No Apple products ever
    Trending Lyricist I
    Jul 9, 2014 12:42 PM UTC
    I am.  I have auto updates disabled, but now I need to reconnect a dropped speaker, Sonos is trying to force an update before allowing me to search for/add the speaker back to my config. I haven't updated because the last update destroyed my home auto system, so I now have a orphaned speaker.
    Translate
    exdirtfarmer
    Enthusiast II
    Jul 16, 2014 3:15 AM UTC
    I like this idea. I am very interested in maintaining my current firmware and software.

    They seem to be able to restore a system from Beta to Production version, so the technology would be there to restore a system to a 5.0 state if they had the will. Why can't they start another software install "stream" with just 5.0 in it instead of Beta?

    They seem to refuse to acknowledge the need.

    It sad that I will have to use a firewall to stop the update from happening, and hope that I don't have to restore a speaker from sonos or I will be hooped as User482341 has had happen.

    These recent updates are so significant that I am really beginning to question my investment.  The "My way or the Highway" Sonos attitude has me looking at other ways to get things done in the future.
    Translate
    Powered by Firmware/Software 8.4 with Classic Blue Desktop Controller + CR100 + Ipod Dock + Homeseer 3 Sonos UPNP Plugin by dcorsus
    Lyricist III
    Feb 1, 2018 5:24 PM UTC



    - The new option will cause zone players or controllers that may have required repair to take on the current system firmware revision when added back to the system rather than forcing an update to the latest firmware version. (Note this is not the same as rolling back firmware which Sonos says it will not support)




    This needs to happen.

    I'm a bit shocked this thread is three years old. I've been having significant usability problems for the last year because updating or adding a new controller to the network means that EVERYTHING gets updated which means being forced into updating all controllers right away or I lose functionality.

    To say that the way Sonos does the update procedure is inconvenient to advanced users, or users with larger networks, is an understatement. I should be able to update a single controller and have other controllers still function regardless of how old their version of the app is running. I can't have laptops and mobile devices and tablets running 8.0 and 8.1 and 8.3 on the same network? Are you kidding me? That's lazy and it breaks my network and breaks the routine I have with my devices in my home. My devices, my network, my home.
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Feb 1, 2018 5:28 PM UTC
    https://consumerist.com/2017/08/23/sonos-holds-software-updates-hostage-if-you-dont-sign-new-privacy-agreement/
    Translate
    jgatie
    Feb 1, 2018 6:32 PM UTC
    This is a three year old thread with a total of 6 posts from 4 users. I highly doubt the idea is going to be looked at with that kind of "overwhelming" support. :8
    Translate
    Chromatic Producer I
    Feb 6, 2018 11:21 PM UTC
    This is a three year old thread with a total of 6 posts from 4 users. I highly doubt the idea is going to be looked at with that kind of "overwhelming" support. :8

    And why does that make you happy?
    Oh, I know. People who don't want to be forced to update are "oldfashioned".
    And you are not.
    Yeah, that's it!

    You will learn some day that this update hysteria will be yesterdays (bad) news. It's just stupid.
    Especially when you can't reverse the process if there's a problem.
    You have probably removed Ctrl-Z from your keyboard too.
    Translate
    jgatie
    Feb 7, 2018 4:36 AM UTC
    It doesn't make me happy or sad. Just stating an observation on the popularity of this request and the likelihood of it being implemented. Sorry if you equate an objective observation with such a fierce emotion as hatred.
    Translate
    Chromatic Producer I
    Feb 7, 2018 7:37 AM UTC
    Your smiley implied this made you happy.

    It's also very common in practically all communities that persons who states obvious disadvantages with the current always-update-all-the-time paradigm are pointed out as oldfashioned and that there's no use complaining.

    That might be true for now but I'm pretty sure we who see the drawbacks will be right in the long run. This madness of constantly changing functionality and updates can't go on for decades. Even if a post with not enough followers on a Sonos community makes you believe otherwise.
    Translate
    Ken_Griffiths
    Feb 7, 2018 9:02 AM UTC
    Time I raised my head above the parapet ...

    Would this 'turning off of updates' not then allow the CR100 devices to continue to be used? Despite the very clear warning from the company that their ageing in-built lithium batteries, if left on charge, are now considered a potential fire hazard. The CR100 devices are well past their use-by date and were withdrawn a long long time ago from production and sale.

    It is quite a foolish step surely to continue to use them against all the advice and possibly put your family and home at risk, albeit a small risk, right now or at some stage in the future? I personally don’t think it’s worth it and Sonos are right to do all they can to keep their customers safe by disabling the controller through firmware update. I can’t criticise them for doing that, as it shows they are acting responsibly and before such risks may occur.

    A much better argument, I think, would be around the level and type of compensation perhaps? ...and whether it should be applied to each CR100 device, rather than a group of devices. Maybe that argument would have more credibility, if the user has retained the original bill of sale for each of their devices and not simply purchased them used, or pre-owned.

    I’m personally quite happy with the £100 being offered for my two old controllers, which will provide a discount against further Sonos equipment,

    I have now switched off my two CR100's for safety reasons and very shortly they will be heading off to the waste disposal site. More fool anyone who is choosing to ignore the advice and continue take a risk with their in-built lithium batteries, or those who chose to change their batteries themselves with possible cheap foreign imports.

    My CR100’s are off and staying off. I would suggest others here do the same, there are plenty of other cheap and safer ways to control our Sonos products these days using the Sonos App given away for FREE, on a variety of platforms.
    Translate