Skip to main content
Jul 25, 2022 11:43 AM UTC

2 sub setup poll, come have your say!

Hi all new to the forum, but far from new to Sonos.

Fantastic products that are bloody addictive 

 

I've been speaking to Sonos direct about this was advised to come here and hopefully some of there engineers and software developers are lurking around here. 

 

My question is who here would love to see Sonos add a feature in the app for individual sub gain/volume and sub frequency.

 

For those that have 2 subs in there HT setup this proposal to Sonos will allow the users more fine tuning setup, in return suiting different rooms and distances etc etc and also if this is possible have a sub frequency option so we can adjust the frequency to our taste and liking and setups 30/40hz and up they sound like there preset @ 80hz min

I feel very strongly about both of these should be in the app so the user has full control.

 

It's not the case of one size fits all, I believe this would be welcomed worldwide from a Very large volume of users

a simple yes or no reply would work great.

I'd like to get and gain world wide movement on this to get these features added the more users show interest greater chance we have of Sonos considering it,

 

Spread it far and wide to all Sonos users and enthusiasts 

 

P.s. if a poll can be started can someone help me thanks 

 

 

 

 

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

21 replies

Senior Virtuoso
Jul 25, 2022 2:42 PM UTC

 

My question is who here would love to see Sonos add a feature in the app for individual sub gain/volume and sub frequency.

 

For those that have 2 subs in there HT setup this proposal to Sonos will allow the users more fine tuning setup, in return suiting different rooms and distances etc etc and also if this is possible have a sub frequency option so we can adjust the frequency to our taste and liking and setups 30/40hz and up they sound like there preset @ 80hz min

 

I don’t know how many users would need or appreciate a control by frequency, or a 10-band (or however many) graphics equaliser, if that’s what you’re asking? There is a (crude) EQ setting, and a Sub boost capability under settings. What more are you suggesting? 

Translate
Senior Virtuoso
Jul 25, 2022 2:55 PM UTC

Sorry - I re-read your post. You’re suggesting separate frequency controls for each sub. 

Translate
Jul 26, 2022 12:42 AM UTC

No sorry nothing alike, I'm suggesting and requesting for seperate gain/volume controls for each sub instead of single control like it is now under sub audio in the menu

and also add frequency control for the sub if this is  possible for both subs under single control or individual would be the cherry on top.

 

A 10 band eq for the rest of the system would be really neat but can't see Sonos ever going for that, as that would be suited to the more advanced users again this would be the second cherry on top, to have. Basic eq like it does now and advanced option for a 10 band for the more serious enthusiasts 

 

My apologies In advance my writing is one my poorest skills in life unfortunately 

Translate
UKMedia
Jul 26, 2022 8:00 AM UTC

I think the main issue here is that the Sonos set-up with two subs is not a true 5.2 configuration.  The two Subs are just duplications of a single channel.  As a result, I suspect that what you are asking for would entail a major piece of work.

Translate
Remember: Sometimes Red Wine helps :)
Jul 26, 2022 12:15 PM UTC

Oh ok, I wasn't aware not a true 5.2 most likely explains the single gain/volume adjustment, certainly may hamper the whole idea now 

Thus would be a hardware issue not a software issue correct 

Translate
melvimbe
Jul 26, 2022 12:56 PM UTC

I could very well be wrong, but I always thought that there wasn’t really any true sub channel in home theatre codecs.  The channel was really just made up audio in the front channels that are below the frequency range of the front channel speakers.  So if your front speakers can handle much of the lower range, you’re still getting the bass (or a lot of it) without even having a sub.

Forgetting home theatre audio for a second, when playing music, it comes in stereo, just two channels.  When you add a sub to the setup, it’s not as if a 3rd bass channel is pulled from the source, your system just sends the lower frequencies of the source to the sub instead, for better performance of the overall system. Your individual system should be setup with sending the right frequencies to the speakers and sub based on the capabilities of the speakers/sub.  I don’t think HT audio works any differently.

That said, I don’t see any value of allowing power users to adjust the frequency range that speakers and sub are responsible for.    Since it’s all Sonos gear, the system knows where the crossovers should be at best.  If  we were talking about an amp with unknown passive speakers with specific freq range, and unknown sub and it’s range….then there would be a need to manually adjust to get the best coverage.

 

As far as gain, that essentially exists already for one sub.  Would there be a benefit of adjusting gain between two subs depending on individual taste and where they are physically located?  Not sure on that one.  I can see possibly if a sub is placed far away from the seating area, then gain could be higher than a sub placed right behind seating area, but I really don’t know if there is an advantage to that at low sub frequencies.

 

 

 

Translate
Danny
buzz
Grand Maestro
Jul 26, 2022 2:02 PM UTC

In the 5.1 audio formats “.1” is a low frequency effects channel that carries thumps and bumps inserted by the content producer.

On playback this division can be maintained in a 5.1 speaker arrangement, but only if there is a separate subwoofer channel and speaker. If there is no separate subwoofer it is customary to mix the thumps and bumps into the front L/R. In systems with an available subwoofer, but the front speakers are too small to provide effective bass, it is customary for the playback system to remove the low bass from L/R and send it to the subwoofer along with the thumps and bumps.

In terms of playback adjustments, the equipment manufacturers are caught between a rock and a hard place. One crew of listeners wants adjustments to determine exactly how the channels are divvied up with all sorts of  level, time, and equalizer adjustments. These guys (they almost always seem to be males, but I have seen a few females in this group) always think that they are better judges of “best” sound than producers and other “experts”. The other crew is fleeing from “complicated” and does not appreciate all of the adjustments. SONOS is science based and tends to cater to the “uncomplicated” group. In terms of a business model, there are legions more “uncomplicated” potential customers than “experts”.

Both crews have members who can yell very loudly in an effort to promote their view of the situation. With respect to providing secret menus for “experts” to tinker with, once the existence of these menus is discovered, these models are dumped into the “complicated” bin.

Translate
melvimbe
Jul 26, 2022 2:45 PM UTC

In the 5.1 audio formats “.1” is a low frequency effects channel that carries thumps and bumps inserted by the content producer.

On playback this division can be maintained in a 5.1 speaker arrangement, but only if there is a separate subwoofer channel and speaker. If there is no separate subwoofer it is customary to mix the thumps and bumps into the front L/R. In systems with an available subwoofer, but the front speakers are too small to provide effective bass, it is customary for the playback system to remove the low bass from L/R and send it to the subwoofer along with the thumps and bumps.

 

 

Thanks for this explanation.  So there is an actual “.1” channel, but that does not mean that what you hear from your sub is only the  “.1”  audio.  And that makes absolute sense given the capabilities of various setups.

 

In terms of playback adjustments, the equipment manufacturers are caught between a rock and a hard place. One crew of listeners wants adjustments to determine exactly how the channels are divvied up with all sorts of  level, time, and equalizer adjustments. These guys (they almost always seem to be males, but I have seen a few females in this group) always think that they are better judges of “best” sound than producers and other “experts”. The other crew is fleeing from “complicated” and does not appreciate all of the adjustments. SONOS is science based and tends to cater to the “uncomplicated” group. In terms of a business model, there are legions more “uncomplicated” potential customers than “experts”.

Both crews have members who can yell very loudly in an effort to promote their view of the situation. With respect to providing secret menus for “experts” to tinker with, once the existence of these menus is discovered, these models are dumped into “complicated” bin.

 

An additional argument for ‘uncomplicated’ is that Sonos understands that potential customers may experience Sonos is in someone elses home first.  If the owner is making odd adjustments that sounds good to them and no one else, potential customer won’t be able to tell if it sounds bad because of custom adjustments or because Sonos speakers just sound bad.   Assuming potential customer is in that ‘uncomplicated’ bucket.  As an analogy, if you’re used to automatic transmission, it’s hard to tell if a manual transmission vehicle drives poorly, or if the driver isn’t very good.

I’m not saying this is official Sonos as a company’s  reasoning on the decision, just that it’s something I’ve seen mentioned before.

 

Translate
Danny
Jul 27, 2022 12:26 PM UTC

It appears I have alot to learn still reading these replies this is my first time away from dedicated HT setups and am used to having the ability of everything  being adjustable, and would of assumed Sonos being a mid range brand it would cater more then what the app has for the noobs to the more advanced users, but that said as stated it's been set and balanced so even grandma can use it, dont get me wrong I love the Sonos gear but things would be different next time I would go back to the more dedicated HT systems and suffer with the lack of space as nothing beats it full stop. since I've moved I was forced to down sized and just didn't have room for a proper HT anymore since having other Sonos speaker's consisting of play bar, subs,ones, fives and symfonisk being impressed with them since knew I had to down size  so I sold all my gear that paid for the arc and subs and ones, for what it is and the size, it's nothing but impressive!! The Sonos gear in my humble opinion 

 

 

   but for now having the ability change individual sub gain/volumes would be golden I believe for others also in small spaces in larger room this wouldn't be applicable, I have a small lounge room front sub is good distance 2.5m but the rear sub is about 200mm off of my lounge and every movie either I have no bass at all or just one sub and manually then the other off or have my kidneys punched in 

Also ability to turn one sub off would be golden. 

Really interesting replies guys 

 

Where's all the Sonos engineers and developers would love to here one of them chime in, c'mon guys stop lurking and chime in   

 

 

 

 

 

Translate
Senior Virtuoso
Jul 27, 2022 3:18 PM UTC

Considering your original post, there’s not been many 2-sub owners that have echoed your desire to have these features. 
 

Sonos spends a lot of time (and therefore money) fine-tuning the sound of their speakers and systems to be as good as practical. In some ways, it’s not surprising that they don’t want users upsetting that tuning too much. 

Translate