Skip to main content
Avid Contributor I
Oct 30, 2013 3:48 AM UTC

1 Play5 vs pair of Play 1s

I have Play 5s in several bedrooms. I was thinking about adding a Play1 for two bathrooms. As I've read about pairing Play 1s for stereo playback, I'm wondering if anyone has a view about whether they would rather listen to one play 5 in a room or a pair of play 1s?
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    30 replies

    Renowned Enthusiast II
    Oct 30, 2013 11:24 AM UTC
    Depends on your needs; volume, best stereo image, size/space available etc.

    If you need volume and/or better base a Play 5 will be better but for stereo image a pair of Play 1s would work best.

    Just my 2d worth!
    Translate
    7x CR100, 2x CR200, 5x SP100, 1x ZP80, 7x ZP100, 1x iPod Dock, 1x Boost, 4x Play 1, 3x Play 3, 2x Play 5, 1x PlayBar & 1x Sub.
    Lumute
    Trending Lyricist I
    Oct 30, 2013 10:28 PM UTC
    I was wondering the same, what about a pair of play 1's vs a play 3?
    Translate
    Avid Contributor III
    Oct 30, 2013 10:38 PM UTC
    Something else to think about: Play:1 is better suited for bathrooms than Play:5 ('Humidity Resistant').
    Translate
    Renowned Enthusiast II
    Oct 31, 2013 1:31 PM UTC
    what about a pair of play 1's vs a play 3?
    Kind of the same answer. A Play 3 is smaller with a lower "top volume" and bass output level compared to a Play 5 but is louder and larger than the Play 1s, still with the same limitations regarding stereo image.

    So if volume is not key or small footprint (and/or humidity tolerance) are, then a pair of Play 1s might well be better than a single Play 3 or Play 5.

    Of course if the stereo image on a Play3/5 becomes an issue you can always add another to gain the best of worlds - good stereo and thumping volume!
    Translate
    7x CR100, 2x CR200, 5x SP100, 1x ZP80, 7x ZP100, 1x iPod Dock, 1x Boost, 4x Play 1, 3x Play 3, 2x Play 5, 1x PlayBar & 1x Sub.
    Avid Contributor I
    Oct 31, 2013 3:54 PM UTC
    I don't have any experience with the Play:1s, but I have stereo paired some Play:3s to compare back and forth with a single Play:5. The stereo separation was really noticeable and appreciated, but the difference in bass was very substantial. It was more than I expected and enough to make me personally prefer the single Play:5 for that big living room. I would think the difference to the Play:1s would be even bigger.

    What I haven't tried is adding the Sub to the pair of 3s. I might play with that this weekend.
    Translate
    Trending Lyricist I
    Oct 31, 2013 4:59 PM UTC
    Of course, this is all subjective, but personally I would argue that a pair of Play:1 is better than a single Play:3. A single Play:1 compares quite well in sound quality to a Play:3. Because of its size and form, the Play:3 has a better sound "projection" throughout a room, but with the stereo image of the two Play:1, the limitations in sound "projection" of the smaller model kind of cancel out.

    On the other hand, the Play:5 really has a larger and richer sonic texture than the Play:1, even Play:3 (especially concerning bass).
    So in the case of a pair of Play:1 versus a single Play:5, it is really a matter of what's more important to you.
    Real stereo imaging creates a real atmosphere and listening pleasure. But again, the sound quality of the Play:5 is just better.

    Just my two cents 😛
    Translate
    Marty999Author
    Avid Contributor I
    Nov 8, 2013 5:19 AM UTC
    Thanks for all the replies. Very helpful. For my high quality listening, I have connects via stereo amp or connect amp to full size stereo speakers in multiple rooms. The single Play 5s sound good in the kids bedrooms, but they don't care about the quality, so single speaker is fine. I'm intrigued by a pair of Play 1s in a small office setting -- giving the stereo effect, but with no need for fuller sound.

    Nice to have so many choices and helpful feedback!
    Translate
    Nov 8, 2013 10:31 AM UTC
    Another advantage of any pair is to be able to break them up for expanded coverage to another zone/ room when needed for background music where loud or stereo isn't a must.
    Translate
    AZ1958
    Contributor I
    Nov 11, 2013 10:37 PM UTC

    Another advantage of any pair is to be able to break them up for expanded coverage to another zone/ room when needed for background music where loud or stereo isn't a must.


    yes, the small Play1 is more convinient for carrying/placing around in the house, and don't forget its relative waterproof design.
    handy for use in garden or bathroom

    I am a experienced HiFi audio listener , and my opinion is that all the SONOS speakers do have great sound, but they are not real high-end hifi sounding (like my old-skool HiFi stereo setup).
    they all very good but "coloured" sounding, and the bigger the enclosures, the bigger the influence (colouration) of these enclosures is on the sound. therefore I like my 2 little PLAY1's in stereo setup, with EQ neutral Bas, and 80% increased Treble settings, loudnes off....
    Translate
    Contributor I
    Nov 12, 2013 9:13 PM UTC
    I have 2xPlay5 in one room, 1x Play 3 in another...and a Playbar which I've just added 2xPlay1 as surround pair.

    The Play 1's sound great pumped up to the max as surround...BUT also sound great in regular stereo when listening to music. I like Dub, Dubstep, Dance....and the bass on the Play 1's is solid and expansive. Try listening to track 1 on James Blake's new Mercury prize winner - the Play 1's deliver!


    PS - I also have an acoustically treated recording studio with 2 x Quested V2108s so I have a good reference point...the Play 1's sound good and are worth the mnoey 🙂
    Translate