Recommendations on Optical Audio Switcher for Playbar?



Show first post

44 replies

Hello. I need some advice. I bought this unit and have it set up but no sound.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00Q6BYAYY/ref=pe_385721_135448361_TE_3p_dp_1

I have my sky box, my android box and DVD plugged in via HDMI. This splitter is then connected to the tv via HDMI. Then the optical cable goes from the box to the sonos play bar. We have no sound coming out and do not know where we are going wrong. Do not know if we have bought the wrong splitter etc.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated as we would like to be able to benefit from a true 5.1 experience across all platforms and not just from the TV.

The TV is a Samsung Smart TV about 2 years old.

Also what is the difference between the one that I bought and this one below

https://www.amazon.com/Monoprice-105557-Toslink-Digital-Coaxial/dp/B003L14WB8?ie=UTF8&psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_details_o02_s00_i00
Ozboyz

Presumably the only outputs on your 'switcher' are the HDMI-OUT and the digital coax ... I guess everything else is an 'IN'.

If the HDMI-OUT goes to the TV, then the playbar will need to be connected to the TV toslink-out port, but older Samsung TV's tend to only output PCM 2.0 stereo...perhaps see what your documentation says for your TV, or ring the Samsung support desk.

I do not think you have bought the correct 'switcher' looking at it briefly, but I can't be sure without seeing the accompanying documentation.

Really the same applies to the other switcher too that you are comparing ... There's nothing to show that the toslink port on that device is a DD 5.1 output/pass-through .. Indeed, it too, could be an input port.

I don't have a Sonos PlayBar myself, but hopefully someone else here will provide a link or suggestion as to a good HDMI switcher with DD5.1 toslink output that will work in your situation.
Ozboyz, perhaps look at the devices mentioned earlier in this thread, or I think this is the type of HDMI switcher you are after ... albeit it's a bit more expensive:

http://www.amazon.com/Portable-Monoprice-TOSlink-Consumer-Electronic/dp/B00LJPD7LY
Thanks Ken. We changed the optical cable and we are now getting sound. Played a DVD and our sonos app showed that it was putting 5.1 through to the play bar. Waiting to see if there is a chanel on tv that is out putting 5.1 to compare that too. Not being a technical person does not make it easy. Previous experience was with an amp that did all the sound for us but opted for sonos for the wi-fi functionality. I'm sure we will sort it out.
Ozboyz ... It sounds promising if you are seeing DD5.1 already... Fingers x'd - hope it works out for you.
Userlevel 2
Badge +2
New Sonos owner here (Playbar, Sub, Play 1 surrounds) and I'm a bit hung-up on the optimal connectivity solution. I need to connect an Apple TV 4, Xbox One via an HDMI splitter/optical audio extractor in order to get 5.1 to my Playbar from all the devices. I've read up on the Monoprice and Octava options but neither seems to meet my needs. Does anyone know of an HDMI switch or setup that fulfils these criteria?
- CEC enabled HDMI switch (so Apple TV turns on/off with TV set)
- "Auto-switching" HDMI switch (so I just need to power up the Xbox or Apple TV and the input will auto-select without the need for a separate remote).

I realize the Xbox is not CEC compatible, which is why HDMI auto switching would be nice. But I would also like to retain the CEC function of the Apple TV being able to power on/off the TV set.

Would my best bet be something like this Monoprice CEC compatible HDMI switch (auto switches via CEC, not sure if this will work for the Xbox override?) http://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=6259
PLUS an optical audio extractor like this in order to feed 5.1 audio directly from the switch to the Playbar:
https://www.amazon.com/J-Tech-Digital-Premium-Extractor-Converter/dp/B00BIQER0E/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1466021671&sr=1-1&keywords=J-Tech+Digital+®+Premium+Quality+1080P+HDMI+To+HDMI+%2B+Audio+%28SPDIF+%2B+RCA+Stereo%29+Audio+Extractor+Converter+%28Support+Apple+TV+4+Gen%29

Thanks in advance for any suggestions!
Userlevel 2
Badge +2
UPDATE: Found this switch on Amazon which seems like it fits the bill perfectly for my needs. Anyone tried it?
https://www.amazon.ca/gp/product/B00MSAU8XO/ref=ox_sc_act_title_3?ie=UTF8&psc=1&smid=A3GEYN3RYNFMBE
Someone recommended an automatic 2 input optical audio switcher in one of the original playbar threads. It was from monoprice and the link is dead, and a search on monoprice makes it look like it's discontinued with nothing else up in its place...


The most important part of this question for me still hasn't been addressed in this thread from three years ago. All of the amazing switches people are recommending come with their own little remote control.

None of them offer AUTOMATIC switching between live sources. This is CRUCIAL. My wife needs to text me every time she turns the projector on to watch movies with her family when I'm not home now. The LAST thing we need is a third remote.

Has anyone found something that will automatically switch between sources as they are toggled on and off? I need the Playbar to pick up my Apple TV when it turns on, after the PS4 is turned off.

AUTOMATIC is the magic word in this original post that Google keeps deciding makes it necessary to show in the results of my endless searches. 😃
Yea, I understand your frustration. Until a week ago, I assumed they had automatic ones as well, until I did some research, since I don't own one or use one myself. As a stopgap measure, I could recommend using a Logitech Universal remote, which would allow you to change the inputs on all devices as needed? It has a high WAF ( I installed one for a friend ), and it does a great job of managing all of the random extra things that go with having a more complex setup. Takes a minute or two to figure out Logitech's programming interface, but it really is quite flexible, and then would have the benefit of allowing your wife to deal with things without texting you.

Yea, it's an extra expense, but might be worth it to remove the frustration from your life.
After a ton of googling...
2-in / 1-out: https://www.lindy-usa.com/2-way-automatic-toslink-digital-optical-audio-switch-70405.html
4-in / 1-out: https://www.amazon.com/TOSLink-Automatic-Switcher-Authority-1177A-1/dp/B01FWTR30S

The first company also has a 4-in / 1-out, but it's not automatic : https://www.lindy-usa.com/4-way-toslink-digital-optical-audio-switch-70416.html

I don't have any of these yet, but am thinking of grabbing the Lindy 2-way shortly.
Badge
This TV definitely passes Dolby Digital via the optical out on the back "Sony Bravia 55XE9305 LED HDR 4K Ultra HD Smart Android TV, 55" with Freeview HD, Youview & Ultra-Slim Design". I have it working with my SKY Q and Apple TV boxes which are connected to HDMI on the TV.
Hi all - will this setup work:

4 devices into HDMI Switch
HDMI from Switch (travelling about 20ft where TV and Playbar sit) to a HDMI SPLITTER (1 HDMI IN = 1 HDMI out + Optical out)
HDMI from Splitter to TV for Video
Optical from Splitter to Playbar

What do you guys think?
Userlevel 5
Badge +12
I use kwmobile EDID feeders, you need one per HDMI port. This lets all devices pass 5.1 through the TV HDMI's to TOSlink and you use your TV exactly as normal (VERY important to me!).

The reason TV's struggle is because they handshake with the Blu-ray players etc and report themselves as a STEREO device, the Blu-ray/ Set Top Box etc will then only feed a stereo signal to the TV and hence the Playbar..
Userlevel 2
Badge
AUTOMATIC is the magic word in this original post that Google keeps deciding makes it necessary to show in the results of my endless searches. :D
As Airgetlam mentions, get a Logitech Harmony remote, hands down. The new ones can even control the Sonos features itself.

As a thought for more advanced switching going up to a TV, I'm surprised that nobody's come across the Outlaw 975: https://www.outlawaudio.com/products/975.html

It will pass the audio over HDMI directly to the TV, and lets you switch not just HDMI, but a variety of other sources as well. It's the flexibility of an AVR, without the bulk of one and the amplifiers of one. Plus, you can use its preamp outs to run things like built-in rear speakers. Probably the most flexible switching system out there that's less than $1,000. 🙂
Badge
Hello Folks,

Question:

If I purchase the toslink adapter to accommodate multiple sources, ( cable, dvd, PS4, Xbox ) do I need to manuall switch the adapter to the corresponding source I wish to use?
If so, do they have make an automatic adapter that recognizes what source you are activating?

Thanks.
I've never seen one that has auto-switching capabilities, but I'll admit I don't go looking very frequently. I think one issue that forestalls the possibility is that many people keep certain devices on all the time, so there's no signal to let the switch know which one is to be "on" at any point.

Perhaps you may want to peruse either Amazon.com, or do a google.com search?
Badge
Good point with the swtich’s function if a device if left on all the time.....

It just seems that the need to constantly switch between devices seems so outdated or behind technical capabilities.
Believe me, if I needed a device like that, what you're proposing would absolutely be at the top of my list. But I just don't think it's possible. But the saving grace for me, at least, is that I use Logitech's Harmony remotes, so I could build in the command to do the changes of HDMI channels right into the process.
Badge
That’s smart.... at the end of the day, and to some guest, it’s doesn’t feel practical to have to always adjust the box to the corresponding unit.

It’s just seems like there should be a more convenient way. I tried a HDMI box which will convert to one toslink cable but some of the units weren’t giving full 5.1 surround. In order to achieve this, I have to get the toslink adapter and the above comments explain the rest.

Unless I’m missing something, this is the only way.

Thanks again.

Reply