Skip to main content
Flaku
Trending Lyricist I
Dec 4, 2020 8:33 AM UTC
Answered

PS5/SONOS ARC/X900. lpcm not loud enough

Lpcm sound is considerably quieter than Dolby Digital plus 5.1 or other modes, annoying

 Is that normal or not?

Or maybe work in progress?

Is lpcm the best option for my setup , gaming on ps5?

Thanks everyone for helping in advance

Peace 

Dawid

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Rowena B.
Rowena B.Answer
Retired Sonos Staff
Dec 8, 2020 8:03 PM UTC

​Hi @Flaku, 

Welcome to the Sonos community and thanks for reaching out to us. Let me share some information to help you out. 

LCPM ​is an uncompressed audio format that provides high-quality audio to our eARC supported home theater devices. It supports up to 8 channels (5.1 and 7.1 surrounds are the most common). Getting audio depends on the physical source device playing the content and the format or output must be set to one of our supported home theater audio formats. Some players and game consoles use DTS audio format which is not supported by Sonos. Some have the ability to transcode DTS into a format that Sonos supports, such as Dolby Digital 5.1. You may also check this article about unsupported audio on home theater speakers for reference.

To take a look at your Sonos system, it would be great if you can submit a diagnostic and include the confirmation number in your response. I'd appreciate it too if you can provide us the make and model of your TV so that we can look up the information.

If you need help with any other information, please be sure to let us know. We’ll wait for your reply.

Help others find useful content by clicking the like button and selecting the best answer to your question.

126 replies

Corry P
Sonos Staff
Oct 23, 2023 8:52 AM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

Your Arc will basically be playing what it is told to play - if LPCM sounds different to other formats (soft and muddy), it’s because your Apple TV (or TV) is delivering it that way. Different hardware is decoding whatever came before LPCM (it’s unlikely that the source media contained a LPCM track), and that must be the reason for things sounding differently.

If volume is the only difference, however, I can only suggest altering the volume with the controls.

I hope this helps.

Translate
"Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen." - Albert Einstein
Oct 23, 2023 2:52 PM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

Your Arc will basically be playing what it is told to play - if LPCM sounds different to other formats (soft and muddy), it’s because your Apple TV (or TV) is delivering it that way. Different hardware is decoding whatever came before LPCM (it’s unlikely that the source media contained a LPCM track), and that must be the reason for things sounding differently.

If volume is the only difference, however, I can only suggest altering the volume with the controls.

I hope this helps.

This thread is 2 years old and people are having issues with their ARC and many different devices while playing LPCM. 

It can’t be the Apple TV because other sound bars don’t sound low/muddy when paying LPCM. 

Very frustrating as we’re 2 years into a thread with various people saying the same thing and nothing being done about it.

Translate
Enthusiast II
Oct 23, 2023 3:06 PM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

Your Arc will basically be playing what it is told to play - if LPCM sounds different to other formats (soft and muddy), it’s because your Apple TV (or TV) is delivering it that way. Different hardware is decoding whatever came before LPCM (it’s unlikely that the source media contained a LPCM track), and that must be the reason for things sounding differently.

If volume is the only difference, however, I can only suggest altering the volume with the controls.

I hope this helps.

This thread is 2 years old and people are having issues with their ARC and many different devices while playing LPCM. 

It can’t be the Apple TV because other sound bars down sound low/muddy when paying LPCM. 

Very frustrating as we’re 2 years into a thread with various people saying the same thing and nothing being done about it.

If you are using Apple TV,  like I said earlier, go to Paramount+ and play Arrival. Go to the 30 minute mark amd listen for five minutes or so. You will be getting 5.1 PCM (you can't get LPCM through streaming). It's rocking well on my system as far as punch and volume. Granted, this is one of the few examples I can find of this, which points back to provider and the studios recording.

Translate
Corry P
Sonos Staff
Oct 23, 2023 4:05 PM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

This thread is 2 years old and people are having issues with their ARC and many different devices while playing LPCM. 

It can’t be the Apple TV because other sound bars down sound low/muddy when paying LPCM. 

Very frustrating as we’re 2 years into a thread with various people saying the same thing and nothing being done about it.

Well, I suppose it depends upon what you mean by “low/muddy”. If someone calls in saying their Sonos Arc sounds quieter when playing LPCM, the understandable response will likely be to turn up the volume - movies are mixed at differing volumes. We’re not going to record this as a report of a bug, because it isn’t one. With compressed formats, we need to decompress them prior to playback and I have been told that as a part of that process we increase the gain - something that doesn’t happen with LPCM as it does not need decoding (I think I mentioned this earlier in this thread). This, however, only addresses LPCM often being quieter than other formats, and not it being “muddy”, so I again encourage you to get in touch if “muddy” doesn’t just mean quiet - in fact, I wouldn’t even mention the volume except as a side-note. “Degraded audio quality” would be the phrase I would use.

Also, as mentioned previously by myself and others, LPCM generally isn’t something you’ll find - no streaming service will supply it, and I would have to see visual proof of it being on a Blu-Ray before I was inclined to believe any such report, so we necessarily come to the fact that any LPCM stream you see reported in the Sonos app has come from either a) the live audio of a games console outputting LPCM specifically while playing a game or b) the result of a device further up the media playback chain decoding the actually-supplied, compressed audio stream in whatever format into LPCM before the Arc ever receives it, in which case it’s not really for us to do anything about it - anything we do do will adversely affect people who don’t have the same equipment as you.

I can’t comment on soundbars from other manufacturers, but if you’ve done a side-by-side comparison with LPCM and other formats and found Arc to definitely be inferior with LPCM specifically, then I would ask that you contact our technical support team and tell them as much, as I’m sure our engineers would like to see/hear some video proof and diagnostics. If you are going by what other people report, remember that you are on the internet and things should be taken with a few grains of salt - but that just means that it’s them that should be getting in touch rather than you. If true, we’d love to know. 

Personally, I watch a fair bit of content, and I find myself adjusting the volume for nearly every piece - with YouTube videos, I’ll be at anything from 10 to 16 volume (I put this down to the inexperience that YouTubers have with audio engineering, as compared to professionals working in a TV studio, for example). With TV programs (mostly Dolby Digital or AAC stereo), 12 is common. With movies, however, it can vary from 12 to 30. I usually only need to go as high as 30 if the source format is Dolby TrueHD, but it is not in any way every TrueHD movie that needs to be that high - just the occasional, random one. 18 is more common, but then I often want movies to be a bit louder anyway. Full disclosure - I have an Amp, which does not support LPCM or Atmos, and my nVidia Shield transcodes unsupported formats on-the-fly (but without altering the volume).

I hope this helps.

Translate
"Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen." - Albert Einstein
Enthusiast II
Oct 26, 2023 5:21 PM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

This thread is 2 years old and people are having issues with their ARC and many different devices while playing LPCM. 

It can’t be the Apple TV because other sound bars down sound low/muddy when paying LPCM. 

Very frustrating as we’re 2 years into a thread with various people saying the same thing and nothing being done about it.

Well, I suppose it depends upon what you mean by “low/muddy”. If someone calls in saying their Sonos Arc sounds quieter when playing LPCM, the understandable response will likely be to turn up the volume - movies are mixed at differing volumes. We’re not going to record this as a report of a bug, because it isn’t one. With compressed formats, we need to decompress them prior to playback and I have been told that as a part of that process we increase the gain - something that doesn’t happen with LPCM as it does not need decoding (I think I mentioned this earlier in this thread). This, however, only addresses LPCM often being quieter than other formats, and not it being “muddy”, so I again encourage you to get in touch if “muddy” doesn’t just mean quiet - in fact, I wouldn’t even mention the volume except as a side-note. “Degraded audio quality” would be the phrase I would use.

Also, as mentioned previously by myself and others, LPCM generally isn’t something you’ll find - no streaming service will supply it, and I would have to see visual proof of it being on a Blu-Ray before I was inclined to believe any such report, so we necessarily come to the fact that any LPCM stream you see reported in the Sonos app has come from either a) the live audio of a games console outputting LPCM specifically while playing a game or b) the result of a device further up the media playback chain decoding the actually-supplied, compressed audio stream in whatever format into LPCM before the Arc ever receives it, in which case it’s not really for us to do anything about it - anything we do do will adversely affect people who don’t have the same equipment as you.

I can’t comment on soundbars from other manufacturers, but if you’ve done a side-by-side comparison with LPCM and other formats and found Arc to definitely be inferior with LPCM specifically, then I would ask that you contact our technical support team and tell them as much, as I’m sure our engineers would like to see/hear some video proof and diagnostics. If you are going by what other people report, remember that you are on the internet and things should be taken with a few grains of salt - but that just means that it’s them that should be getting in touch rather than you. If true, we’d love to know. 

Personally, I watch a fair bit of content, and I find myself adjusting the volume for nearly every piece - with YouTube videos, I’ll be at anything from 10 to 16 volume (I put this down to the inexperience that YouTubers have with audio engineering, as compared to professionals working in a TV studio, for example). With TV programs (mostly Dolby Digital or AAC stereo), 12 is common. With movies, however, it can vary from 12 to 30. I usually only need to go as high as 30 if the source format is Dolby TrueHD, but it is not in any way every TrueHD movie that needs to be that high - just the occasional, random one. 18 is more common, but then I often want movies to be a bit louder anyway. Full disclosure - I have an Amp, which does not support LPCM or Atmos, and my nVidia Shield transcodes unsupported formats on-the-fly (but without altering the volume).

I hope this helps.

Hello Corry,

I understand that you might be getting tired of this thread, but it also makes clear that many users are really struggling with this issue. You mention that LPCM is generally not used by streaming services or found on Blu-rays. While it's true that it's rare, there are Blu-rays with an LPCM track. You'll mostly find these on music Blu-rays. Attached is a link to a sample file that I've made from a Justin Timberlake Blu-ray which has 3 audio tracks:

  1. Dolby Digital with a bitrate of 0.6 Mbps
  2. PCM 2.0 with a bitrate of 2.3 Mbps
  3. PCM 5.1 with a bitrate of 6.9 Mbps

To clarify, this is a 1:1 sample of a Blu-ray without modifying the video or audio.

I play this file with a media player with bitstream passthrough. So there's no conversion taking place to LPCM. The audio is as it is, and the Sonos Arc plays it as it is.

You mention that you don't own a Sonos Arc yourself, but I assume you can find one or know someone who has one. If you've listened to this sample and don't hear that the LPCM track(s) sound significantly worse than a Dolby Digital track with a fraction of the bitrate, then I don't know what else to say.

I don't know if I'm allowed to share this link here. If not, you can remove it, but please forward it to one of your engineers first. It can't be that everyone in this thread is imagining this.

Here's the link to the file (3.5 GB)"

 

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1y7fglFGFXvf7obTTe1W5PCqHDBYfwF7S?usp=sharing

 

I hope this helps!

Translate
Enthusiast II
Oct 26, 2023 6:41 PM UTC

Hi @bignicknicknick 

This thread is 2 years old and people are having issues with their ARC and many different devices while playing LPCM. 

It can’t be the Apple TV because other sound bars down sound low/muddy when paying LPCM. 

Very frustrating as we’re 2 years into a thread with various people saying the same thing and nothing being done about it.

Well, I suppose it depends upon what you mean by “low/muddy”. If someone calls in saying their Sonos Arc sounds quieter when playing LPCM, the understandable response will likely be to turn up the volume - movies are mixed at differing volumes. We’re not going to record this as a report of a bug, because it isn’t one. With compressed formats, we need to decompress them prior to playback and I have been told that as a part of that process we increase the gain - something that doesn’t happen with LPCM as it does not need decoding (I think I mentioned this earlier in this thread). This, however, only addresses LPCM often being quieter than other formats, and not it being “muddy”, so I again encourage you to get in touch if “muddy” doesn’t just mean quiet - in fact, I wouldn’t even mention the volume except as a side-note. “Degraded audio quality” would be the phrase I would use.

Also, as mentioned previously by myself and others, LPCM generally isn’t something you’ll find - no streaming service will supply it, and I would have to see visual proof of it being on a Blu-Ray before I was inclined to believe any such report, so we necessarily come to the fact that any LPCM stream you see reported in the Sonos app has come from either a) the live audio of a games console outputting LPCM specifically while playing a game or b) the result of a device further up the media playback chain decoding the actually-supplied, compressed audio stream in whatever format into LPCM before the Arc ever receives it, in which case it’s not really for us to do anything about it - anything we do do will adversely affect people who don’t have the same equipment as you.

I can’t comment on soundbars from other manufacturers, but if you’ve done a side-by-side comparison with LPCM and other formats and found Arc to definitely be inferior with LPCM specifically, then I would ask that you contact our technical support team and tell them as much, as I’m sure our engineers would like to see/hear some video proof and diagnostics. If you are going by what other people report, remember that you are on the internet and things should be taken with a few grains of salt - but that just means that it’s them that should be getting in touch rather than you. If true, we’d love to know. 

Personally, I watch a fair bit of content, and I find myself adjusting the volume for nearly every piece - with YouTube videos, I’ll be at anything from 10 to 16 volume (I put this down to the inexperience that YouTubers have with audio engineering, as compared to professionals working in a TV studio, for example). With TV programs (mostly Dolby Digital or AAC stereo), 12 is common. With movies, however, it can vary from 12 to 30. I usually only need to go as high as 30 if the source format is Dolby TrueHD, but it is not in any way every TrueHD movie that needs to be that high - just the occasional, random one. 18 is more common, but then I often want movies to be a bit louder anyway. Full disclosure - I have an Amp, which does not support LPCM or Atmos, and my nVidia Shield transcodes unsupported formats on-the-fly (but without altering the volume).

I hope this helps.

Hello Corry,

I understand that you might be getting tired of this thread, but it also makes clear that many users are really struggling with this issue. You mention that LPCM is generally not used by streaming services or found on Blu-rays. While it's true that it's rare, there are Blu-rays with an LPCM track. You'll mostly find these on music Blu-rays. Attached is a link to a sample file that I've made from a Justin Timberlake Blu-ray which has 3 audio tracks:

  1. Dolby Digital with a bitrate of 0.6 Mbps
  2. PCM 2.0 with a bitrate of 2.3 Mbps
  3. PCM 5.1 with a bitrate of 6.9 Mbps

To clarify, this is a 1:1 sample of a Blu-ray without modifying the video or audio.

I play this file with a media player with bitstream passthrough. So there's no conversion taking place to LPCM. The audio is as it is, and the Sonos Arc plays it as it is.

You mention that you don't own a Sonos Arc yourself, but I assume you can find one or know someone who has one. If you've listened to this sample and don't hear that the LPCM track(s) sound significantly worse than a Dolby Digital track with a fraction of the bitrate, then I don't know what else to say.

I don't know if I'm allowed to share this link here. If not, you can remove it, but please forward it to one of your engineers first. It can't be that everyone in this thread is imagining this.

Here's the link to the file (3.5 GB)"

 

Moderator edit - link removed to avoid copyright issues

 

I hope this helps!

It seems the sample isn’t quite right. I’ll try to upload a new one once I get the chance. Cutting just a piece out of large MKV isn’t as easy as it sounds. Apologies. 

Translate
Enthusiast II
Oct 27, 2023 8:10 AM UTC

I uploaded a new Sample at the same link 

Moderator edit - link removed to avoid copyright issues

I hope you'll take the time to listen to it or forward it to your enginering team. 

To clarify, my setup is Arc, Era 300 as surrounds and Sub (gen 2).

 

Translate
Corry P
Sonos Staff
Oct 27, 2023 8:25 AM UTC

Hi @Whistler 

I confess I didn’t really think of music BluRays - thanks for setting me straight!

I’ll see if I can get someone with an Arc to give that file a listen - thank you for the effort you obviously put in to do that.

 

Translate
"Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen." - Albert Einstein
Enthusiast II
Oct 27, 2023 8:34 AM UTC

Hi @Whistler 

I confess I didn’t really think of music BluRays - thanks for setting me straight!

I’ll see if I can get someone with an Arc to give that file a listen - thank you for the effort you obviously put in to do that.

 

Hi Corry, 

No problem!  Needless to say you need to play this on a device that does bitstream Passthrough and not for instance a Apple TV 4K that converts everything to LPCM by default to hear the difference between the tracks.

 

Translate
Corry P
Sonos Staff
Oct 27, 2023 12:02 PM UTC

Hi @Whistler 

I passed the link to a colleague and asked him to read these last few posts on this thread for context.

He played the file with Kodi on a nVidia Shield to his Arc, but was unable to discern any difference between the Dolby Digital and LPCM tracks besides the volume.

He did notice, however, that the two tracks were not identical. The LPCM track appears to have had a filter of some kind applied to it:

Top is Dolby Digital centre channel, bottom is LPCM centre channel​

As we were unsure as to why he couldn’t hear a difference, he extracted just these centre channel tracks to FLAC and sent them to me - I couldn’t hear a difference either.

So, although we were both unable to discern any audible differences, there does appear to be a difference in how the two tracks were mastered. We have to assume therefore, that either there is no significant difference, or there is, but only when using the equipment that you are using and it’s due to the difference in mastering - with Passthrough/Bitstream, this should not be happening, however, though it’s not unknown for “Passthrough” to be an inaccurate description of what’s happening when it comes to some TVs.

He also tested with both Night Mode and Speech Enhancement disabled and enabled, but still no difference was perceivable.

So, long story short, we cannot confirm your findings. At this point, as far as we are concerned, everything appears to be working as intended and we don't consider this to be an issue.

All we can suggest is that if things sound worse when listening to LPCM, don’t use LPCM - I don’t mean to be flippant, but I’m not sure what else to say at this point.

I have removed your links to the file to avoid copyright issues.

I hope this helps.

Translate
"Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by age eighteen." - Albert Einstein