Skip to main content
Contributor III
Aug 22, 2023 12:47 PM UTC
Answered

Optical connection

I have a Panasonic TV and Sonos Beam plus Sub Mini and two Ones at the rear.

Due to the failure of the HDMI ARC port on the TV I have had to connect the Beam to the TV using the optical port and the provided adaptor.

Will there be any difference in audio quality and what will be the downside of not having CEC (or Viera)?

PS I am still able to use the remote for volume even though it says "speakers off" when adjusting volume.

 

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
Airgetlam
AirgetlamAnswer
Aug 22, 2023 12:53 PM UTC

Two small changes. 

Optical is a one way connection, not two way, so normal CEC command processes won’t work, so you’ll need to set up your remote for IR use, and program the Sonos to read that, in the controller itself.

Also, the maximum bandwidth available across optical is Dolby Digital, so you won’t get the more advanced Atmos content. But beyond that, exactly the same. 

Bruce

15 replies

ratty
Aug 22, 2023 12:52 PM UTC

If you want to banish the speakers message from the TV you may need to use a remote that’s programmed for a different make of TV, e.g. Sony or Samsung. You’d teach the Beam to recognise those IR codes instead.

Translate
Airgetlam
AirgetlamAnswer
Aug 22, 2023 12:53 PM UTC

Two small changes. 

Optical is a one way connection, not two way, so normal CEC command processes won’t work, so you’ll need to set up your remote for IR use, and program the Sonos to read that, in the controller itself.

Also, the maximum bandwidth available across optical is Dolby Digital, so you won’t get the more advanced Atmos content. But beyond that, exactly the same. 

Translate
Bruce
CaptJohnAuthor
Contributor III
Aug 22, 2023 1:41 PM UTC

Thanks for the reply.

What is meant by ‘normal CEC command processes’?

The only command I would be interested in is volume control of the Sonos audio and that seems to work anyway even though the legend ‘loudspeakers off’ appears on the screen when activating volume on the remote. I gather that this means that the TV speakers are off (which I have selected in the TV menu).

Translate
ratty
Aug 22, 2023 2:00 PM UTC

What is meant by ‘normal CEC command processes’?

The two-way command communication between TV and soundbar that takes place over HDMI, alongside the audio/video data. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_Electronics_Control 

Optical is a unidirectional audio data feed.

 

The only command I would be interested in is volume control of the Sonos audio and that seems to work anyway even though the legend ‘loudspeakers off’ appears on the screen when activating volume on the remote. I gather that this means that the TV speakers are off (which I have selected in the TV menu).

The TV is seeing the IR volume commands from the remote at the same time as the Beam. As noted, this can be fixed by programming a remote to control a different make of TV, then training the Beam with those codes instead.

Translate
CaptJohnAuthor
Contributor III
Aug 23, 2023 9:56 AM UTC

Even though I have lost the CEC (Viera) capabilities by using the optical connection from the Beam to the Panasonic TV instead of HDMI (ARC) I can still control the volume of the Sonos system using the TV remote control.

Surely this goes against the principle of CEC. I'm not complaining, just curious.

Translate
Airgetlam
Aug 23, 2023 10:53 AM UTC

When you use optical, there is no ‘principle of CEC’ involved. There’s no connection. The remote is connecting via IR to the Sonos device. 

Translate
Bruce
CaptJohnAuthor
Contributor III
Aug 23, 2023 4:26 PM UTC

I seem to be missing something here. If I had a working HDMI ARC port what would I be able to utilise that I can't when using the optical port?

In the term Audio Return Channel where and what is being returned?

Translate
jgatie
Aug 23, 2023 4:30 PM UTC

I seem to be missing something here. If I had a working HDMI ARC port what would I be able to utilise that I can't when using the optical port?

In the term Audio Return Channel where and what is being returned?

 

CEC, which is required for HDMI-ARC would allow you to control the soundbar from the TV.  In other words, the remote tells the TV to raise/lower the volume, and the TV then commands the soundbar to raise/lower via CEC. 

Translate
CaptJohnAuthor
Contributor III
Aug 23, 2023 5:00 PM UTC

I've connected the Beam to the TV optical port using the adaptor and I can still adjust the volume of the Beam with the TV remote. That's why I'm confused.

Translate
jgatie
Aug 23, 2023 5:07 PM UTC

I've connected the Beam to the TV optical port using the adaptor and I can still adjust the volume of the Beam with the TV remote. That's why I'm confused.

 

It could be that the optical is set to variable, so the volume of the output can be raised/lowered.   That can work, but the volume level in the Sonos app would not be accurate. 

Translate