Skip to main content
Avid Contributor I
Sep 26, 2024 9:17 AM UTC
Answered

What alternative methods can we use to listen to our music library

Good morning

Many thanks to all that helped on my previous question regarding the SMB V1.0 issue. I like most of you have not been able to play my music library since the May update. I have now had 4 months playing around with various fixes / updates / experiments to no avail.

I have therefore decided to try an alternative method of playing my music library on my Sonos system.

I am aware that there are a number of ways to do this, some might be very easy to implement, but cost a large sum of money. Others may be very cost effective, but require extensive knowledge in software systems.

So, with this in mind could I ask what options are out there with a brief synopsis of what would be required to get my music library up and running. I will start….

  1. Get a NAS with SMB3 – May be costly and could be a pain to get up and running.
  2. Raspberry PI – Low cost – will be difficult for the layman to get up and running
  3. Copy my music to Windows media player – PC must always be switched on.
  4. Please add your thoughts below

Many thanks

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.
106rallye
106rallyeAnswer
Sep 26, 2024 4:50 PM UTC

Use iBroadcast, use Plex.

28 replies

MoPac
Headliner III
Sep 29, 2024 2:09 PM UTC

 This assumes you have a Windows PC…If you end up with a  WD NAS map the Shared Music folder to your computer then copy your USB library to the Shared Music folder ( A Western Digital default folder. At least on mine ).

Translate
MoPac
Headliner III
Sep 29, 2024 2:14 PM UTC
jonmichael
Enthusiast II
Sep 29, 2024 4:52 PM UTC

I have a Roon sub that I use for serious listening with wired speakers, DAC, Integrated Amp et al. I can stream Roon from my server to my Arc, sub and surrounds for casual listening. Best of both worlds, so far.

Translate
Old guy with toys.
MoPac
Headliner III
Sep 29, 2024 9:37 PM UTC

 ROON is great for controlling a number of different brand streamers.  Had it for a year.  Now I just use MinimServer to serve up my music library to KEF & WiiM.  Sonos indexes the library from the same NAS location.  Also LMS for SqueezeBox players ( WiiM included ) also from the same NAS location.  Another option used is Linn’s Open Home for the Sonos Port ( UPnP-not gapless.  Open Home-gapless ).  None of these as universal as ROON, but no SQ loss issues caused by ROON processing.  LMS-SqueezeBox = best SQ.

Translate
106rallye
Sep 30, 2024 5:42 AM UTC

I like iBroadcast - it works at least. The music quality on the free version is only so-so though.

Translate
GMRAuthor
Avid Contributor I
Sep 30, 2024 8:54 AM UTC

@106rallye 

I uploaded everything in FLAC, took a while, but it is there if I decide to stay with iBroadcast and move to the paid service.

As you say it does work.

I am currently following @Belly M comments and looking at the WD cloud home units.

 

Translate
Lyricist III
Oct 24, 2024 6:22 AM UTC

I had a 512GB USB drive plugged into the back of my BT Home Hub (probably the UK’s most popular router) which was rendered unusable in May by the app update and the Samba change.

I’ve resurrected this with a Raspberry Pi Zero 2 W with not much effort and at a cost of about £45 ($60). It draws 2W in power, and delivers almost the same functionality as the £600 ReadyNAS NV+ I started out with about 15 years ago, in a tiny low-power unit.

if it would be useful I’d be happy to lay out the steps.

Translate
GMRAuthor
Avid Contributor I
Oct 24, 2024 8:51 AM UTC

@healthily_skeptical 

 

ibroadcast is “working”, but I feel I am being short changed as I am not “in charge” i.e. I am reliant on iBroadcast working.

I looked at the Pi route, but ended up not being able to give it enough time to get my head around everything.

I would appreciate any guidance and support you could offer.

Cheers

 

Translate
bockersjv
Local Superstar
Oct 24, 2024 10:26 AM UTC

@GMR  Here’s my two pennies worth…

I too was in a similar situation and looked through all the options as well.

I did go down the SMB (Single Board Computer) of which Raspberry Pi and Arduino are example.

I went for an Odroid HC2 using linux free OpenMediaVault.  I am not familiar with Linux but managed to get it working and by using an old Hard drive i had a working solution.  I learnt a lot but would I do so again… the answer is no.  Too much fussing about and doing things with blind faith.

The next options I considered was buying an old Corporate computer from ebay, such as an old Dell corporate machine, attaching an old drive or memory stick and using that.  Old pcs can be had from £50.  It’s quick and easy and can be expanded in the future to include more storage.  It’s not as quiet or small as a NAS but does the same thing.

 

In the end I went for a NAS as I wanted a solution to back up ALL my files not just the music.  I am very happy but it was not cheap, especially when factoring in new HDs.  Been running 3 years now and never an issue.

Translate
GMRAuthor
Avid Contributor I
Oct 24, 2024 3:30 PM UTC

@bockersjv

I have a history of upgrading computers, so the bits and pieces are not an issue for me. I did look at running an old mini Lenovo PC, but people say its a bit overkill just for the music.

Translate