Skip to main content
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

29 replies

ianm_42Author
Enthusiast I
August 20, 2024

SMB v1 needs to stay gone, Sonos took too much bad press, mostly clickbait but still harmful over having it.

Anyone not able to provide current versions of SMB from their NAS can easily and cheaply set up an SMB gateway that will provide v2 and v3 on pretty much any computer that runs SMB. I used a Pi Zero here to play with that, under $20 for the full kit. Not currently using it as using the Pi to provide the SMB share and host my music was so easy.

Could you share details please as all my CD’s are stored on my Media player (Popcorn hour) that supports only SMBv1 and works absolutely fine, as it has done since 2009.  It plays movies on TV and PC and music on PC and once upon a time music on Sonos.

Enthusiast I
August 20, 2024

SMB v1 needs to stay gone, Sonos took too much bad press, mostly clickbait but still harmful over having it.

Anyone not able to provide current versions of SMB from their NAS can easily and cheaply set up an SMB gateway that will provide v2 and v3 on pretty much any computer that runs SMB. I used a Pi Zero here to play with that, under $20 for the full kit. Not currently using it as using the Pi to provide the SMB share and host my music was so easy.

Could you share details please as all my CD’s are stored on my Media player (Popcorn hour) that supports only SMBv1 and works absolutely fine, as it has done since 2009.  It plays movies on TV and PC and music on PC and once upon a time music on Sonos.

From the developer of SMB https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/storage-at-microsoft/stop-using-smb1/ba-p/425858

Stanley_4
Grand Maestro
August 20, 2024

I did this SMB v1 gateway to see if it would work, I used a Raspberry Pi but the same basic instructions should work on any computer.

SMB v1 Gateway  https://stan-miller.livejournal.com/357.html

ianm_42Author
Enthusiast I
August 21, 2024

I did this SMB v1 gateway to see if it would work, I used a Raspberry Pi but the same basic instructions should work on any computer.

SMB v1 Gateway  https://stan-miller.livejournal.com/357.html

Will give it a try. All I want to do is listen to my MP3/CD files on my Sonos’s as I have done for years and not get into the cost of a new NAS/configuration/setup and more devices consuming power !!!

controlav
Lead Maestro
August 21, 2024

I did this SMB v1 gateway to see if it would work, I used a Raspberry Pi but the same basic instructions should work on any computer.

SMB v1 Gateway  https://stan-miller.livejournal.com/357.html

Will give it a try. All I want to do is listen to my MP3/CD files on my Sonos’s as I have done for years and not get into the cost of a new NAS/configuration/setup and more devices consuming power !!!

Upload them to ibroadcast.com

Author of the leading independent Sonos apps for Android, MacOS, iOS, Windows and Xbox.
Lyricist I
August 22, 2024

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/08/sonos-laying-off-100-people-amid-expensive-app-problems/

 

Oh and bring back SMBv1 support so we can all access our music as we had done perfectly well for at least the last 10 years...please.

I wish I could listen to my Sonos 5 but after multiple tries over multiple days I give up. My sonos 5 is going into the trash and it’s time to go back to Bluetooth speakers or wired passive speakers and vinyl. Nice to know I am not alone in this very frustrating experience. As a very experienced engineer and audiophile, it’s so frustrating when digital devises fail due to software issues. 

buzz
August 22, 2024

There are some serious security issues with SMBv1. That’s why drive manufacturers are no longer supporting it SONOS has stopped supporting it.


Note that SMBv1 drives are likely rather old and it would be a good idea to back them up. A couple months ago I was able to install an SMBv1 driver in W10 and backup a couple old drives.

nyCecilia
Prominent Collaborator I
August 22, 2024

Funny, my system is on 8.4 and my NAS with SMBv1 is working perfectly fine (yes, it’s backed up just in case).  So are my CR100s.  I wish I could update for some minor inconveniences but I don’t trust SONOS, they have repeatedly proved themselves untrustworthy.  And no, the batteries in my CR100s never exploded LOL

forum says i'm a member since 2011 but really since 2004/5 ish ZP100, ZP80, ZP120, S5 and still using CR100 daily. SAVE THE CR100!
buzz
August 22, 2024

The SMBv1 drives are supporting S1 systems. When the drives ultimately fail, we’ll need to adjust things.

Dogdad
Headliner III
August 22, 2024

It’s not going to happen says the CEO Spence..