Skip to main content
Contributor I
Nov 20, 2026 3:45 AM UTC
Question

Why Are Old Albums Sometimes Duplicated And Corrupted When I Add A New Album To my Sonos Library

My music is stored on a single NAS location,  This location is shared by a single node S1 system and a multi-node S2 system.  The S1 system has no issues.  I have seen this duplicated album problem multiple times in the past but recently it has been in a stable state.  Then I tried to add a new album to my system for the first time in a while and things started going wrong again.  I have done a lot of testing but here is a sample of my testing:

  • I start with 203 albums and no duplicates
  • I add a new album of 18 MP3 and re-index
    • I now have 205 albums?
    • New album is OK
    • One old album is now duplicated with each copy containing only the last song on the album
  • I delete the song that is present in both copies of the old album and re-index
    • I now have 204 albums
    • New album is OK
    • Old album is now OK except that it is missing the one song I deleted
  • I place back the old album song and re-index
    • Back to 205 albums
    • New album is OK
    • Same old album is again duplicated with each copy containing only the last song on the album
  • I delete the last song in the new album and re-index
    • I now have 204 albums
    • New album is OK except for missing the manually deleted song
    • Old album is now OK
  • I delete the second last song in the new album (2 songs now deleted) and re-index
    • I now have 206 albums?
    • New album is OK except for missing the two manually deleted songs
    • Original old album is still OK
    • Two different old albums are now duplicated each copy containing only the last song on their respective albums
  • I add back the second last song on the new album and re-index
    • Back to 204 album
    • New album is OK except for missing the one manually deleted song
    • All the old albums are OK

It is very strange that adding and deleting songs on one album could impact how another album is represented.  It indicates to me an indexing issue and not a metadata issue with the new song files.

12 replies

kdowling
Nov 20, 2026 4:00 AM UTC

A bug introduced in Sept 2025 and yet to be fixed. There has been much discussion here about it. You don’t even need to add or delete songs to see this problem affect other albums. You can just rename a folder/directory, re-index and see a different set of albums display the problem.

Edit: The albums shown incorrectly can be found in Music Library → Folders, where they will be correct and can be played from there. 

Here’s one thread:

 

Translate
jwlentAuthor
Contributor I
Nov 20, 2026 4:11 PM UTC

Thanks. At least in my case, once I get in this situation the results are very consistent as I make changes.  It would seem pretty easy to debug.

Translate
Smilja
Nov 20, 2026 5:28 PM UTC

Even if it takes extra work, will rebuilding the Sonos music library from scratch after making changes prevent these duplicates?

Translate
»And the world is like an apple whirling silently in space, Like the circles that you find in the windmills of your mind.« (›Windmills Of Your Mind‹ [1967]. Music by Michel Legrand ; English lyrics written by Alan & Marilyn Bergman)
Stanley_4
Grand Maestro
Nov 20, 2026 5:45 PM UTC

Deleting and rebuilding hasn't cured the issue for me.

 

Until this makes the priority fix list and Sonos finds a programmer that knows or can understand the code a fix is unlikely.

Translate
buzz
Grand Maestro
Nov 20, 2026 6:42 PM UTC

Any relation to title length, included characters, track position (first, second, third)?

Translate
kdowling
Nov 20, 2026 8:17 PM UTC

Non that we’ve been able to determine. Although, it is usually the last track (only) that shows in the duplicates.

We’ve determined that the problem has nothing to do with the albums that are displayed incorrectly. When making any change to the library, different unrelated albums then display the problem and the ones that were showing the problem no longer do. 

Edit: And S1 pointed at the same library has no problems.

Translate