Contributor III

Is Sonos One inferior to Amazon Echo 2nd Gen?

Forum|Forum|8 years ago
January 27, 2018
6 replies
7391 views

I recently read a Which review of the Sonos One (https://www.which.co.uk/reviews/wireless-and-bluetooth-speakers/sonos-one/review), which was damning.

I was quite surprised as the forums and other reviews I have seen are quite positive. For those that have both, I would like to know what is your overall impression of the Sonos One sounds quality vs. the Amazon Echo 2nd Gen?

To quote Which:

"Should I buy this speaker? No."

"[It's] mediocre. Music sounds very processed, rough and harsh rather than natural, with a heavy bass that is not well blended with the rest of the sound."

"Amazon's own Eco Second Generation sounds significantly better at a far cheaper price."

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

AjTrek1

I can't comment on the review as I'm not going to pay to read it. However, I'd be curious to know what the reviewer thought of the Play: 1 as the Sonos One is mainly the same speaker only with Alexa. All reviews I've read have said that one would be very hard pressed to categorically say the the Sonos One sounds better than the Play: 1. Not knowing what return policies are like in the UK (in the USA most offer 15 days min) I'd suggest you buy both and decide for yourself. Also here's another review from the UK that you may or may not have read (BTW it's free to read :8) Cheers!

https://www.pocket-lint.com/speakers/buyers-guides/142617-sonos-one-vs-amazon-echo-what-s-the-difference

Together Everyone Achieves More = T.E.A.M.

K

Kumar

Based on my extensive use of Echo 2nd gen and a play 1, I'd say the conclusion is rubbish. The Sonos One used for comparison may have been defective. The Echo sounds decent, far better than the Dot and you can live with it, but don't then make the mistake of listening to a 1/One.

D

dasym

Prominent Collaborator II

I wouldn't worry about a Which review. I once did subscribe but found all of their tech reviews to be lightweight and I disagreed with their findings for the items I had personal experience of. I think they use all the subscription money to pay the over-inflated salary of their chief executive and other board members.

pwt

Virtuoso

'Which?' is just wrong on this one, period.

4 x P:5 | Sub | 4 x P:1 | 3 x Connect | 2 x Boost | Connect:Amp | 2 x One | Amp | Move | Port | Era 300

U

upstatemike

Don't forget the Sonos One is a directional speaker where the Echo2 is Omnidirectional. This makes it hard to do a straight quality comparison because the different acoustic characteristics will influence your perception depending on the listening environment. I would say the Sonos One is a much higher fidelity speaker than any Echo speaker currently available though I prefer the Sonos in pairs rather than in Mono. An Echo can sound pretty good when placed near a wall for some low end reinforcement but that would be very dependent on the environment it is playing in. I also think the original Echo sounded a bit better than the Echo2 despite the claims of improved sound so there is always going to be an element of subjectivity in any listening test.

Local music library with carefully constructed playlists - no shuffling!, Integration with Homeseer Automation, No touch screen devices, No streaming services, No Apple products ever

J

John B

Just for completeness, the Sonos One is not a Play:1 with Alexa. All the relevant comment from Sonos employees that I have seen on this forum has said that the components are largely different, despite the similar outward appearances.

Sign up

Login to the community