Skip to main content
Enthusiast II
May 15, 2024 2:12 PM UTC

**Class Action Lawsuit** We all deserve to recoup all hardware investment

If ever a situation called for a class action lawsuit, this is it:

  • Company sells customers expensive, multi-unit hardware systems
  • Tethers customers to a software ecosystem to use them effectively
  • Dramatically changes software into an auto-update environment
  • Unsuspecting customers lose access to extensive, core media sources and features that significantly diminish the value of their expensive hardware and/or make it untenable for usage they had every reason to believe they would continue to have
  • Customers wishing to continue meeting these essential needs forced to sell Company hardware that they had no intention of doing at a loss and buy competitor hardware.
  • Pattern of behavior by Company indicates that choices made to remove said functionality were part of an intentional, plan to damage the product experience of many users in favor of others.

Seriously. This would be like selling someone a car and then updating the operating system so that the steering wheels was controlled by AI instead of manual because there’s more profit there for the company.

Even if they resolve this issue with their awful software release, how much in damages are deserved for every customer for heir lost time and undue harm?

The store value of my hardware suite, which I had no intention of replacing is probably $7,000 - $8,000. How much do others have invested who believe they need to leave SONOS?

I am not someone who can start a class action lawsuit, but I’m sure there are people here who can, and I’d be at the front of the line to join it and recoup my losses. If you feel similarly, then bump up this thread so that SONOS is held accountable

This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

277 replies

Prodigy III
May 29, 2024 7:06 AM UTC

 

Also I don’t quite understand why some peoples systems ended up broken and yet my 20+ Sonos device system is all showing and working okay?… even the 18+ installed music services are working/playing here - post update, including the local SMBv2 NAS local library. 

 

It’s because the app is a buggy POS. Surprised you don’t understand that yet Ken. 
 

FWIW there have been some threads here about people claiming forced updates. I think they or someone in their house made a mistake, but posts like this keep popping up 

https://www.reddit.com/r/sonos/s/gpWBf4miMo

I have an ipad.  In the Appstore, the Sonos icon is yellow.  The icon on the homepage changed automatically to black.

No humans were involved in this behaviour. 

Forced?  I don't know but Spooky? Yes! 

 

Not that spooky, surely? Unless you’ve specifically turned off auto updating for certain apps, all your phone and iPad apps will update on their own. Sometimes you’ll go into the App Store and there will be apps showing Update, but mostly that’s because those have yet to be done automatically. They are updated overnight and/or while devices are on charge.

Translate
Prodigy I
May 29, 2024 7:18 AM UTC

 

Also I don’t quite understand why some peoples systems ended up broken and yet my 20+ Sonos device system is all showing and working okay?… even the 18+ installed music services are working/playing here - post update, including the local SMBv2 NAS local library. 

 

It’s because the app is a buggy POS. Surprised you don’t understand that yet Ken. 
 

FWIW there have been some threads here about people claiming forced updates. I think they or someone in their house made a mistake, but posts like this keep popping up 

https://www.reddit.com/r/sonos/s/gpWBf4miMo

I have an ipad.  In the Appstore, the Sonos icon is yellow.  The icon on the homepage changed automatically to black.

No humans were involved in this behaviour. 

Forced?  I don't know but Spooky? Yes! 

 

Not that spooky, surely? Unless you’ve specifically turned off auto updating for certain apps, all your phone and iPad apps will update on their own. Sometimes you’ll go into the App Store and there will be apps showing Update, but mostly that’s because those have yet to be done automatically. They are updated overnight and/or while devices are on charge.

Uh-huh... auto update set to off.  Same happened with Android - the black Angel appears.  I haven't allowed auto update on any device for years. Maybe not spooky, but how about paranormal(?!). 

Translate
🎵 First We Take Manhattan Then Berlin 🎵
Ken_Griffiths
May 29, 2024 10:11 AM UTC

Uh-huh... auto update set to off.  Same happened with Android - the black Angel appears.  I haven't allowed auto update on any device for years. Maybe not spooky, but how about paranormal(?!). 

Just from reading the things mentioned in your post here, it seems you did not turn off the update. There are two sides to an update. The speaker firmware and the Sonos App software - they go hand in hand. The latest App needs the latest firmware for all to work and vice versa.

So nothing is achieved by switching off just one of these things only… as is mentioned repeatedly in this community, especially during the S1/S2 separation.

Once again the Sonos updates are not forced on anyone, they’re entirely optional. My Son is happily still using the S2 App with his products on the older version of the firmware. He has chosen to wait until some further features are added to the new App before installing the updates.

Translate
Prodigy I
May 29, 2024 10:56 AM UTC

Believe it or not... Years of multi-device & software installs.  Both levels of auto set to off - it's the first thing I do with any setup if it's available (eg. Some Echo devices can't be 'protected'). Anyway, makes no difference as the Sonos universe is definitely black and there's only a one-way ticket. 

Otherwise, the app such as it is (especially the newly intrusive useless Headphone option - I don't have one & won't ever buy one) works somewhat sluggishly for me.   How I would feel about the permanent absence of my SMBv1 music library, if I had had a big curated collection, is a moot point.  And as far as I can tell, without investing time, effort and possibly cash, there's still no way to install / specify a smbv2 device using the app as it is now.

Overall, I'm still left with a bitter taste over all this farago. 

Translate
🎵 First We Take Manhattan Then Berlin 🎵
Lyricist II
May 29, 2024 6:54 PM UTC


 

when can we expect an actual update? And no, “in the coming weeks” isn’t good enough. This is effectively planned obsolescence. Having just moved house I can’t update the network rendering them absolutely useless 
 

I really want to know how on earth this update was rolled out? Whoever approved the roll out needs to be sacked. 

Translate
Lyricist II
May 29, 2024 6:56 PM UTC

Personally, I’d love a lawsuit against Sonos.  Discovery is a wonderful and powerful tool, I’d love to know what Sonos knew about this app before they rolled it out.  

Same here 100%. Hope they lose a lot of their customers for it too. Not too long ago Apple was nailed for planned obsolescence this doesn’t feel too dissimilar 

Translate
Enthusiast II
May 29, 2024 7:08 PM UTC

I also see comparisons to Bed Bath and Beyond.  They revamped and did away with their famed coupons which their most loyal customers loved.  They did eventually bring them back but too late, they are bankrupt now.  Question is how many of their most loyal customers will Sonos lose over the new app and slow response to fix?  Companies always pay a price for alienating their most loyal customers.  A successful business adds customers doesn’t lose them with the hope of finding replacements.  We will see the impact of this disaster over the next year.  Do their customers forget about this in time and move on, or do they not forget and move away?  

Translate
Lyricist II
May 29, 2024 7:34 PM UTC

I also see comparisons to Bed Bath and Beyond.  They revamped and did away with their famed coupons which their most loyal customers loved.  They did eventually bring them back but too late, they are bankrupt now.  Question is how many of their most loyal customers will Sonos lose over the new app and slow response to fix?  Companies always pay a price for alienating their most loyal customers.  A successful business adds customers doesn’t lose them with the hope of finding replacements.  We will see the impact of this disaster over the next year.  Do their customers forget about this in time and move on, or do they not forget and move away?  

The whole fiasco seems completely unnecessary and avoidable - test the system before punting an update on live products? Complete incompetence, not exactly rocket science that they need to review their workings before submitting it. 

Translate
jgatie
May 29, 2024 7:38 PM UTC

The whole fiasco seems completely unnecessary and avoidable - test the system before punting an update on live products? Complete incompetence, not exactly rocket science that they need to review their workings before submitting it. 

 

I’m pretty sure it was tested, and there are accounts from beta testers that said it was found lacking.  This feedback was obviously overridden by a need to support the new hardware slated for the end of the fiscal year in June.  That’s not the developers doing, that’s a decision made well above them. 

Translate
Enthusiast II
May 29, 2024 7:42 PM UTC

Jgatie, I agree, probably not incompetent developers, but definitely an incompetent CEO.  

Translate